Page 43
A Dialogue. CHAPTER IX.
HAving brought your Approches neere unto a Towne or a Forttesse, whether would you choose a Bulwarke or a Curtaine to be battered with your Ordnance?
A. Towne may be assaulted in divers places, sometimes you assault one side, when as you make your Batterie on an other, Sometimes you choose a Bulwarke, other∣whiles a Curtaine to be battered, with this intention, to take in the Towne, assoone as po∣ssible may bee. As for mee, if I were to take in a great Towne which is populous, I had rather choose to batter a Curtaine, then a Bulwarke, which hath a high catt, or mount upon it: especially, seeing that in great Townes the Bulwarkes lying one far from an other, they doe show the skirt of the Curtaine very open.
Why would you rather choose a Curtain then a Bulwark?
Because your Bulwarks are alwaies stronger and better fortified then your Curtain, and being as it is the principall strength of a place, and better furnished with platformes, flancks, &c. will require more time, labour, and charge to batter then your Curtaine.
But what Generall is so ill experienced, as to labour to batter a Curtaine, having two strong Bulwarkes on both sides of him, to flanker him when hee is to put over his Gallerie, and to giue an assault upon the Curtaine: peradventure for his labour and paines, hee may bee well beaten.
Soft (Good Sir,) Suppose that after a great deale of labour and paines you haue bat∣tered a Bulwarke, and falling up to the breach to assault it, you finde it cut off, and an Enemy lodged in it, must you not then beginne to sap forward againe, to make a new batterie, whereas on a Curtaine there is not that meanes of cutting it off, as upon a large Bulwarke.
Haue you ever seene the experience of it?
Yes Sir, the Prince of Orange tooke in the Bosch by a Bulwark, and also Breda, but Mastricht was taken in by making a breach, and springing of a mine, upon the Curtain bet∣ween Jonger Port and a bulwark, howsoever the Town of Cortes upon the frontiers of France, was first battered by the Arch-duke of Austria upon the point of a Bulwark, neer unto the very ioynt of the Curtain, where a high, and a strong turret stood, which did annoy us much, so that we could not advance forward, but were constrayned to leaue off our approach on that side, and began to make a new Batterie for a breach in a Curtain on the Field-side, where there lay a strong Bulwark to defend it, which did our men a great deal of harm, but wohsoever with great difficulty and much adoe, we took in the Town that way, by lodging our selues in the Curtain: Likewise the city of Cambray was battered, and taken in upon a Curtain, for all there were two strong Bulwarks that flanked it, which if we had run our line upon a Bulwark, we should not haue forced it so soon, yea such an occasion might present it self, that a Generall may be forced to batter both the one and the other, or to find out some secret way by undermining a wall, and blowing it up with powder.
This is for your great Townes, but what say you to a Castle, a Cattadel, or some nar∣row Fortresse, how will you goe to worke to take in those with the best advantage.
As for your Forts, and Castles, it is much better to batter them upon a mount or a Bulwark, then upon a Curtain: my reason is this, that in these your Bulwarks lying close one by an other, will flank one an other with the greater force, and hide the Curtain much better to defend it, so that one cannot so easily force it, if the said defences be not taken away.
Go to then; a Town then being to be battered, either upon a Curtain or a Bulwark how many peeces of Ordnance would you haue to do it, and how, and in what manner would you place, and plant your Ordnance upon your batteries to make a good breach?
To effect this, I would haue 18. peeces of canon and halfe canon, (for lesser peeces for batterie are novv grovvne out of use).
Whether would you choose more whole canon or halfe canon?
To batter a place well either upon an stony or a earthy wall, you may assure your self,