Observations upon the origin of the malignant bilious, or yellow fever in Philadelphia, and upon the means of preventing it: addressed to the citizens of Philadelphia / by Benjamin Rush.

About this Item

Title
Observations upon the origin of the malignant bilious, or yellow fever in Philadelphia, and upon the means of preventing it: addressed to the citizens of Philadelphia / by Benjamin Rush.
Author
Rush, Benjamin, 1746-1813.
Publication
Philadelphia: :: Printed by Budd and Bartram, for Thomas Dobson, at the stone house, no 41, South Second Street.,
1799.
Rights/Permissions

To the extent possible under law, the Text Creation Partnership has waived all copyright and related or neighboring rights to this keyboarded and encoded edition of the work described above, according to the terms of the CC0 1.0 Public Domain Dedication (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/). This waiver does not extend to any page images or other supplementary files associated with this work, which may be protected by copyright or other license restrictions. Please go to http://www.textcreationpartnership.org/ for more information.

Subject terms
Yellow fever -- Pennsylvania -- Philadelphia
Link to this Item
http://name.umdl.umich.edu/N27197.0001.001
Cite this Item
"Observations upon the origin of the malignant bilious, or yellow fever in Philadelphia, and upon the means of preventing it: addressed to the citizens of Philadelphia / by Benjamin Rush." In the digital collection Evans Early American Imprint Collection. https://name.umdl.umich.edu/N27197.0001.001. University of Michigan Library Digital Collections. Accessed May 14, 2025.

Pages

Page [unnumbered]

OBSERVATIONS, &c. &c.

HAVING laboured nearly six years to no pur|pose, to persuade the citizens of Philadelphia that the yellow fever is of domestic origin, I had con|cluded to desist from all further attempts to produce conviction upon this subject; but a retrospect of the scenes of distress which I have witnessed from that terrible disease, and the dread of seeing them speedily renewed, with aggravated circumstances, have induced me to make one more effort to pre|vent them, by pointing out their causes, and re|medies. I anticipate from it, a renewal of the ca|lumnies to which my opinion of the origin of our annual calamity has exposed me; but these will be less difficult to bear, than the suppression of truths which involve in their consequences the prosperity of our city, and the lives of many thousand people, whom poverty and despair will finally compel to

Page 4

become the unwilling victims of the fever, should it again prevail in our city.

Of the Remote Causes of the Yellow Fever.

This disease is the offspring of putrid vegetable and animal exhalations in all countries.—It prevails only in hot climates and seasons.—The sources of it in Philadelphia are chiefly the following—

1. The docks; these contain a large quantity of filthy matters in a highly concentrated state. They are first acted upon, by the heat of the sun, and hence sailors and the inhabitants of Water street, are generally the first persons who are affected by the yellow fever every year. It is derived to fre|quently from the docks in New York, that it has obtained there, the name of the dock fever.

2. The foul air of ships.

3. The common sewers. A yellow fever was produced by a large sewer in Calcutta. It was af|terwards prevented by closing it up, and removing the filth of the city in another way.

4. The gutters.

Page 5

5. Dirty cellars and yards.—Foul air is sometimes generated in cellars which produces sporadic cases of fever in all seasons of the year. Swen Warner died of a yellow fever on the 30th of January 1799, received by breathing the air of a cellar which had been shut up for several months.

6. Privies. An epidemic fever was once traced to this source in the city of Frankfort in Germany.

7. The putrefying masses of matter which lie in the neighbourhood of the city, and

8. Impure pump-water.

All the physicians in our city agree in deriving the common bilious fever and dysentery from these sources; now as these diseases have, we are told, by the College of Physicians, "lately very much diminished,"* 1.1 and as the putrid exhalations still continue, the presumption is, that they pro|duce our higher grade of bilious, which is the yel|low fever.

Page 6

Of the Cause of the Yellow Fever not occurring more frequently before the Year 1793.

It has often been asked, "Why did not the yellow fever prevail in Philadelphia before the year 1793, particularly in the year 1778, when it was left in a more filthy state by the British army than it has been at any time since?" To this, I answer, that for the production of our pestilential disease, three things are necessary, 1. Putrid exhalations, 2. An inflammatory constitution of the atmosphere, and 3. An exciting cause, such as great heat, cold, fatigue from riding, walking, swimming, gun|ning, or unusual labour, intemperance in eating, or drinking, ice creams, indigestible aliment, or a violent emotion of the mind. The first cause acts but feebly without the concurrence of the second, producing mild diseases only, such as common re|mitting and intermitting fevers. By the co-opera|tion of an inflammatory constitution of the air, we observe not only common bilious fevers, have be|come malignant, but all those diseases which are occasioned by the sensible qualities of the air, have assumed a more violent character. This has been remarked by most of the physicians of Philadel|phia for several years past. The pleurisy, rheu|matism, gout, hives and several other diseases, re|quire remedies of twice as much force to subdue

Page 7

them, as they did ten years ago. On what circum|stances this change of the atmosphere depends is not known. But the fact is certain. It was taken notice of by Hippocrates two thousand years ago, and is mentioned over and over in the writings of Dr. Sy|denham. The records of medicine prove, that it has continued from one year, to fifty-two years in different countries. Dr. Sims has given along and interesting account of these inflammatory consti|tutions of the atmosphere from the year 1590 to 1782, in the first volume of the Manchester me|moirs, from which it appears that they were some|times general over Europe, and at other times con|fined to particular countries. The pestilential con|stitution of the air in the United States began in 1791. This I infer from the yellow fever making its appearance that year in New-York—It pre|vailed in Charleston in 1792, and it has been epi|demic in one or more of the cities and country towns* 1.2 of the United States every year since.

Page 8

We observe the effects of changes in the qualities of the atmosphere not only upon diseases, but up|on animal and vegetable life. Insects of different kinds have lately appeared and multiplied in an un|usual manner, and the fruits of the earth have ri|pened, and decayed in many instances sooner than in common years. These facts have been noticed by the farmers in every part of the United States. The uncommon mortality in the summer and autum|nal months, among horses, cattle and the cats, for several years past, is an additional proof of a change in our atmosphere. It has arisen probably from the same cause which has increased the mortality of our annual epidemic. As a further answer to the ques|tion under this head, it might be asked, why was not the fever imported oftener before the year 1791? It is seldom absent from the West-India islands. It raged in most of them during the two wars previous to the present, and yet but one in|stance occurred of it in the United States in those

Page 9

two periods of seven years each, and that was in Philadelphia in the year 1762. The intercourse between our cities and the islands during that time was extensive and constant, particularly in the war between the years 1756 and 1763. (Quarantine laws then existed in but few of our cities, and where they did, they were feebly executed or eluded every day.

It has been asked,

Why does not the yellow fever prevail every year in cities, where the filth is always the same in its quantity and quality. To this I answer, that filth may be in two states in which it will not pro|duce this disease, viz. a dry, and a liquid state. From excessive heat or from heavy rains, it is of|ten in one of those conditions in our cities. When this is the case, they escape a visitation from this disease. It is only when filth is acted upon by a hot sun in a moist state that it produces fevers. The Neck below Philadelphia which has been sub|ject to the bilious fever, time immemorial, was uncommonly healthy in the autumn of 1793; ow|ing to the low grounds there being completely dried by the hot weather of that season. Fell's Point near Baltimore I have been informed escaped the yellow fever in 1798 from a similar cause.

Page 10

I shall illustrate the origin of the yellow fever by a familiar simile. The foul air of our city may be compared to gunpowder with which the bodies of our citizens are charged from the beginning of summer. The atmosphere may be compared to sparks of fire. Heat, cold, fatigue, intemperance and the other exciting causes which have been mentioned, may be compared to a hand, which combines these sparks, with the gunpowder ac|cumulated in our bodies. The concurrence of all these causes is necessary to produce a yellow fever. Putrid exhalations act but feebly upon the body, unless they are aided by the inflammatory activity of the atmosphere. This atmosphere in like manner, acts but feebly upon the body with|out the concurrence of putrid exhalations. Both of them for the most part, require the hand of an exciting cause to produce the disease. An exciting cause without them, is harmless, or induces only a transient indisposition.

If putrid exhalations produce the yellow fever, it has been asked, why are those neighbourhoods some|times healthy that are constantly exposed to their offen|sive smell? This question may be answered by re|sorting to the effects of habit upon the system, which renders it insensible after a while, of irritat|ing impressions. The noxious matter which pro|duces

Page 11

the yellow fever exists independently of smell, and is probably not formed till after that process of fermentation is ended, which evolves the faetor from putrefying animal and vegetable substances. This faetor, like the rattle of the snake, seems to have been intended to give us no|tice of our danger, and to remove, or fly from the filth which emits it. It is possible it may in some cases predominate so much in its action upon the system over that matter which produces the fever, as to defend the body from its morbid effects. It is thus, the constant stimulus of spirituous liquors has been found effectual in some instances in pre|serving habitual drunkards from the yellow fever.

Is the Yellow Fever a Contagious Disease?

To answer this question, it will be necessary to remark, that contagion is of two kinds.

1st. It is secreted as in the small pox and measles, in which state it acts uniformly and without the aid of exciting causes, upon persons of all ages and constitutions who have not been previously ex|posed to it, and is not controuled by the obvious changes in the weather.

Page 12

2dly. It is derived from certain matters dis|charged from the body which afterwards by stag|nation, or confinement, undergo such a change, as to partake of the same nature as the putrid ex|halations which produce the fever. If the breath, perspiration, and other excretions of a person in a yellow fever be confined in a small close room, they may produce a similar disease, especially when they act upon a body previously debilitated by grief, or fatigue. But they are generally inoffensive, where the sick are accommodated in open well ventilated situations. Out of upwards of one thousand persons who have carried this disease into the country from our cities, there are not more than three or four instances to be met with, of its having been propagated by contagion. In the city hospital of Philadelphia, there was no instance of this disease being contagious in 1793, 1797, and 1798. The fever of which Dr. Cooper died in the hospital last year, Dr. Physick assures me was derived from the exhalations of Water-street, which place he visited a few days before he sicken|ed, in order to examine the state of the air in that unhealthy part of the city. The disease perished when carried from Fell's Point to Baltimore in 1794. The same fate attended it, when it was carried from the places in New York and Boston

Page 13

in which it was generated, to distant parts of those cities. Clothes impregnated with the effluvia of a person who had died of the yellow fever might produce a similar disease, but it would be only in consequence of those effluvia partaking of the nature of putrid matters derived from any other animal source.* 1.3 The same thing may be said of the efflu|via emitted from a putrefying dead body.

In the first settlement of the West India islands, pains were taken by several physicians, to prove that the yellow fever was imported from Siam into the West Indies. I was educated in the belief of this opinion, but the testimony of many learned, and eminent modern physicians, has convinced me that it is a vulgar error, and that the disease is

Page 14

generated there as it is here, by putrid exhalations. To the names of Drs. Huck, Hillary, Hunter, Hec|tor, M'Lean, and Clark, I shall add those of Doc|tors Jackson, Borland, Pinkard and Scott, physi|cians to the British army in the West Indies, who lately visited this city. They all denied the conta|gious nature of the yellow fever in the West In|dies.* 1.4—In those cases where a fever appeared to

Page 15

spread by contagion in vessels at a distance from the shore, Dr. Scott informed me that there was al|ways

Page 16

reason to believe it to be the common ship fever which is every where admitted to be of con|tagious nature.—The ship, goal, and hospital fever mean one and the same disease. It is produced by exhalations from living bodies in a crouded, filthy, or debilitated state. The fevers which have been imported into Philadelphia from Holland and Ire|land in passenger ships, were of this nature. It is sometimes confounded with the yellow fever by writers, but it is materially different from it.

The power which heavy rains, and frost have of destroying our fever, clearly prove that it does not spread by contagion. We have seen it check|ed three times, in three different years by frosty nights. The cold in these cases cannot act upon the disease in our houses, and of course it does not alter the quality of the matters discharged from the bodies of the sick. It acts only upon the putrid exhalations which float in the atmosphere.

Page 17

The interests of humanity are deeply concerned in the admission of the rare and feeble contagion of the yellow fever. Hundreds have perished by be|ing deserted by their friends in situations in which the disease could not have been taken by contagion, and where there was no danger to the attendants from putrid exhalations, either from the sick, or the adjacent neighbourhood. Many people have perished likewise in places exposed to putrid exha|lations, who have believed themselves to be safe, because they kept at a distance from the sick.

Can the Yellow Fever be Imported?

I once thought it might, but the foregoing facts authorise me to assert, that it cannot, so as to become epidemic in any city or country. There are but two authorities on which the belief of this disease being imported, rests. These are Dr. Lining's and Dr. Lind's. The former says it was imported into Charleston in 1732, 1739, 1745 and 1748. The latter says it was con|veyed into Philadelphia where it afterwards be|came epidemic, by means of the clothes of a young man who died in Barbadoes. No circum|stances of ships, or names are mentioned with these assertions to entitle them to credit, and from the facility with which vague reports of the foreign ori|gin of this disease have been admitted and propa|gated

Page 18

by physicians in other countries, there is rea|son to believe the assertions of those two physici|ans are altogether without foundation.—The Col|lege of Physicians of Philadelphia after two weeks investigation, were unable to discover any ships, clothes, or sick person, that could have introduced the disease into Philadelphia in the year 1793. The Academy of Medicine have clearly proved, by many documents, that the disease was not imported in the years 1797 and 1798. The origin of a few cases, reported by Dr. Griffitts and other members of the College of Physicians, which have lately ap|peared in our city, has in vain been sought for from a prize sloop of the Ganges. Two affidavits of Messieurs Hill and Ingersol, prove that she had been healthy in the West Indies, and that no per|son had been sick on board of her during her voy|age, nor after her arrival in our port. Equally unsuccessful have been the attempts to derive those cases, from beds, and blankets infected by the fe|ver of last year. In Boston, Connecticut, New York, Baltimore, Norfolk and Charleston, both physicians and citizens have long ago rejected the opinion of the importation of the fever. Some phy|sicians suppose it possible for the contagion of this fever to adhere to the timbers of ships that have sailed from West India ports, and that it may be propagated from them to a whole neighbourhood,

Page 19

although houses, and even streets, interpose be|tween them. This opinion is too absurd to stand in need of refutation. Indeed every thing that re|lates to the importation of this fever is contrary to reason and facts.—It is an error, substituted in the room of a belief that all pestilential diseases were derived from the planets.—The existence of a health-law founded upon this error, in the close of the eighteenth century, and in a city abounding with literary institutions, will appear incredible to posterity. Thinking men alone will discover its possibility, in their knowledge of the nature of the human mind. It is possible this law may in the course of many years be the means of preventing the disease being received, in a solitary instance.— To enforce it under this circumstance, at the ex|pense of our commerce, is to imitate the conduct of the man, who in attempting to kill a fly upon his child's forehead with a hammer, knocked out its brains.

It has been said, if we admit the yellow fever to be of domestic origin, it will ruin the credit and com|merce of our city. The reverse of this opinion is true; for by admitting that it is generated among ourselves, we shall soon remove its causes, where|as, by supposing that it may be imported, and act|ing accordingly, we shall naturally be led to ne|glect

Page 20

the removal of the sources of putrid exhala|tion, and thus after driving our commerce to other ports, we shall entail the disease upon future generations. Many of the cities of Europe, and of the West-Indies, that once generated pesti|lential diseases, now enjoy an exemption from them by adopting measures for removing their caus|es. The hereditary cleanliness of the Hollanders was imposed upon them by the diseases to which their country was formerly subject from putrid ex|halations.—The town of Harrisburgh in Pennsylva|nia, lost more of its inhabitants in proportion to their number, than the city of Philadelphia by the yellow fever in 1793. The cause of this great mortality was traced to a mill dam. It was soon afterwards removed, and the town has ever since been healthy. It is of the utmost consequence for the cities of the middle and northern states of America to adopt measures of strict and universal cleanliness, inasmuch as the disease may be taken as often as our inhabitants are exposed to its sourc|es. In the West-Indies, the constant action of the sun and of putrid exhalations upon the bodies of the natives and old settlers, render them for the most part, insensible to any morbid impressions from them; hence the disease is never taken a se|cond time except by persons who have left the islands, and after spending two or three years in

Page 21

a cold climate, have returned to them. New comers are the principal victims of the highest grade of their bilious fever. The winters in North America, by destroying the habit of insensibility to heat, and putrid exhalation induced by the previ|ous summers, place our citizens every year in the condition of new comers in the West-Indies, or of persons who have spent two or three years in a cold climate. This circumstance increases the dan|ger of depopulation to our city from our annual epidemic, and should produce corresponding exer|tions to prevent it.

Of the Means of Preventing the Yellow Fever.

1. Let the docks be immediately cleaned, and let the accumulation of filth in them, be prevent|ed in future, by conveying water into them by a passage under the wharves, or by paving them with large flag stones inclining in such a manner towards the channel of the river, as that the filth of the streets shall descend from them (after it falls into the docks) into the river. This method of paving docks has been used with success in the city of Brest. The street now known by the name of Dock-street once exposed a large surface of filth to the action of the sun. Its neighbourhood was

Page 22

more sickly at that time, than any other part of the city. By means of the present arch over that filth, Dock-street has been exempted from an un|usual number of sick people during the summer and autumnal months.

2. Let every ship that belongs to our port be compelled by law to carry a ventilator. Let all such ships as are discovered to contain foul air in their holds, be compelled to discharge their cargoes before they reach our city, and let the ships in port, be compelled to pump out their bilge water every day.* 1.5

Page 23

3. Let the common sewers be washed frequent|ly with streams of water from our pumps. Per|haps an advantage would arise from opening them and removing such foul matters, as streams of wa|ter are unable to wash away.

4. Let the gutters be washed every evening in warm weather. By frequently washing the streets and pavements the heat of the city would be les|sened, and thereby one of the predisposing causes of the fever would in some measure be obviated. The use of water for the above purposes, has be|come more necessary since the streets and gutters have been so closely paved; for the filth which formerly soaked into the earth, is now confined, and emits its noxious vapors into the atmosphere.

5. The utmost care should be taken to remove the filth from the yards and cellars of every house in the city. Hog-styes should be forbidden in yards, and the walls of cellars should be white-washed two or three times a year, and their floors should be constantly covered with a thin layer of lime.* 1.6 White washing the outside of houses in sickly streets, would probably be useful.

Page 24

6. Let the privies be emptied frequently; and let them be constructed in such a manner as to prevent their contents from oozing through the earth so as to contaminate the water of the pumps. The fa|mous Ambrose Parey ascribed one of the plagues of Paris wholly to foul air, and impure water. Mr. Latrobe in a note, in his proposal for his present important undertaking, has very properly pointed out the impurity of our water as one of the remote causes of the yellow fever.—Happy will it be for the citizens of Philadelphia if by means of that gentleman's plan for supplying the city with river

Page 25

water, they should be delivered from the necessity of making use of the water from their pumps for drinking, and culinary purposes.

7. Let all the filth be removed from the neigh|bourhood of the city, and let the brick kiln, and other ponds be filled up, from time to time with the earth which is obtained in digging cellars.

8. In the future improvements of our city, let there be no more dwelling houses erected in alleys. They are often the secret receptacles of every kind of filth. The plague always makes its first appear|ance in the narrow streets, or in the dirty huts of the suburbs of Constantinople.

9. The predisposition of our citizens to be affect|ed by the remote and exciting causes of the yellow fever, would be very much lessened by their living sparingly upon fresh animal food and chiefly upon broths and fresh vegetables rendered savoury by spic|es, and a small quantity of salted meat, during the summer and autumnal months. A constant attenti|on should be paid at the same time to bodily cleanli|ness.

The expenses of removing all the sources of putrid exhalations which have been mentioned, should not be weighed for a moment with the loss of three or

Page 26

four thousand lives every year, with the diminution of our commerce by the fever, nor the delays and charges of our present oppressive quarantine law. Let us not be alarmed, nor discouraged for the fate of our city. To every natural evil, Heaven has provided an antidote, and it is not more certain, that houses are preserved from the destruc|tive effects of lightning by metal conductors, than that our cities might be preserved, under the usual operation of the laws of nature, from the yellow fever by cleanliness. It would seem as if the neglect of it, was necessarily connected with suffering. We observe it in the human body, as well as in our cities. The suspension of sickness from filth, no more proves it to be inoffensive, than the temporary absence of remorse for wicked actions, proves them to be innocent. A regard to cleanliness was en|joined upon the Jews by divine authority.* 1.7 To

Page 27

prevent diseases among them, was one of the de|signs of their frequent ablutions, and of many other of their ceremonial institutions. The same reasons exist for removing the filth from large cities, as from a camp, and the same advantages of health, and order have attended it in all warm countries, in every age of the world.

Reason was given to man chiefly to promote his physical happiness. We expect a miracle, in wait|ing to be delivered from our epidemic, by the wrong application of the reasoning faculties of our minds. In their proper use, we may humbly hope for a blessing upon our endeavours, to avert our calamity, from that Being, who loves truth in every thing, and who afflicts not willingly the children of men. Citizens of Philadelphia, bear with this attempt to persuade you to reconsider the facts and reasonings that have from time to time been laid before you upon this important subject. Think of the unsuc|cessful issue of all your efforts for five years past, to guard against the prevalence of our summer and autumnal pestilence, by adhering to the popular hypothesis of its origin. The measures that have been recommended are cheap, compared with the costly apparatus for preventing its supposed impor|tation. The adoption of them will render our city agreeable to ourselves, and inviting to strangers, at

Page 28

the same time that it will defend it from the yellow fever.

Philadelphia was once preeminent over all the cities in North America, in plans of public utility and happiness—she must admit the unwelcome truth sooner, or later, that the yellow fever is engender|ed in her own bowels, or she must renounce her character for knowledge and policy, and perhaps with it, her existence as a commercial city.

May Heaven forbid this catastrophe to the present capital of the United States! and in mercy command the destroying angel of pestilence to sheath his up|lifted sword! in spite of the numerous execrations that have been heaped upon me for my opinions and conduct upon the subject of this address, by the citizens of Philadelphia, her prosperity is still the object of my constant solicitude.—Yes— Dear asylum of my ancestors! Beloved nurse and protectress of my infant and youthful years! May thy health, thy commerce, thy freedom and thy happiness exist, till time shall be no more!

16th, July 1799.

THE END.

Notes

Do you have questions about this content? Need to report a problem? Please contact us.