yet he saith that he was a man beloved of God, 2 Sam. 12 25.
Therefore say we he fell not totally and finally, he lost not all grace because he had still so much grace as kept him from falling finally, as we may see by his book or repentance.
Fifthly, David. Bellarmine saith, he fell totally.
But that is not so, he lost not all when he fell into sin, as appeareth Psalm 51. 12.
Though the operation of his faith ceased, yet lost he not the substance and habit thereof, for there was a spi∣rit of prayer and repentance still left, he had a conflict within that made him so earnestly pray, restore me to the joy of thy salvation, &c. where note he prayes not simply for salvation, for that he was assured of, but for the com∣fort of it, and his prayers we know were the prayers of faith, for they brought him joy and comfort. So that then he had not lost all his faith.
Sixtly, Peter.
But he also lost not all, which to hold were directly contrary to that of our Saviour, Luke 22. 32. where he tels Peter, that he had prayed to the Father that his faith might not fail him, and it is a priveledge Christ hath purchased for every beleeving soul, that howsoever he may be grie∣vously and continually tempted on every side, yet shall his faith never utterly fail, because Christ hath prayed for it.
Seventhly, He brings Simon Magus.
But we deny him to be a true believer, he was at the best but in the gall of bitterness, his heart was stark naught, and therefore for him to fall away it is no won∣der.
Lastly, Iudas, whom we deny to be given to Christs keeping to eternal salvation, though he was given him as an Apostle, for Christ to prevent all, declared plainly that he was the son of perdition from the beginning; so that there is indeed no strength in all these to weaken