The Young-students-library containing extracts and abridgments of the most valuable books printed in England, and in the forreign journals, from the year sixty five, to this time : to which is added a new essay upon all sorts of learning ... / by the Athenian Society ; also, a large alphabetical table, comprehending the contents of this volume, and of all the Athenian Mercuries and supplements, etc., printed in the year 1691.

About this Item

Title
The Young-students-library containing extracts and abridgments of the most valuable books printed in England, and in the forreign journals, from the year sixty five, to this time : to which is added a new essay upon all sorts of learning ... / by the Athenian Society ; also, a large alphabetical table, comprehending the contents of this volume, and of all the Athenian Mercuries and supplements, etc., printed in the year 1691.
Publication
London :: Printed for John Dunton ...,
1692.
Rights/Permissions

To the extent possible under law, the Text Creation Partnership has waived all copyright and related or neighboring rights to this keyboarded and encoded edition of the work described above, according to the terms of the CC0 1.0 Public Domain Dedication (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/). This waiver does not extend to any page images or other supplementary files associated with this work, which may be protected by copyright or other license restrictions. Please go to http://www.textcreationpartnership.org/ for more information.

Subject terms
Athenian gazette, or, Casuistical Mercury -- Indexes.
Athenian mercury -- Indexes.
English essays -- Early modern, 1500-1700.
Books -- Reviews.
Cite this Item
"The Young-students-library containing extracts and abridgments of the most valuable books printed in England, and in the forreign journals, from the year sixty five, to this time : to which is added a new essay upon all sorts of learning ... / by the Athenian Society ; also, a large alphabetical table, comprehending the contents of this volume, and of all the Athenian Mercuries and supplements, etc., printed in the year 1691." In the digital collection Early English Books Online. https://name.umdl.umich.edu/A36910.0001.001. University of Michigan Library Digital Collections. Accessed May 4, 2024.

Pages

A Clergy Mans Letter to the Nuns, who have the care of the Education of young Women, exhorting them to second the Popes Intentions about Nakedness.

I Received a Memoire not long since, from an unknown hand, containing that the Censurer of the Books of the Arch-Bi∣shop of Malines being of Liege, and a Iansnist had approved a Letter directed to the Nuns, wherein the Heresie of M. Arnaud concerning the Two heads of the Church, and the Pela∣gian Errors, comdemning all kind of Orna∣ments, are renewed. As I do not love to speak of a Book before I see it, especially if any ones Reputation is concerned, so I have deferr'd speaking of this Letter before I had seen it. I do not repent this delay, for having at last examined this little Writing, I have seen nothing in it of Mr. Arnaud's pre∣tended Heresie, nor any thing but what agreed with the Doctrin of St. Peter and Paul, concerning Womens Dresses; so that if it be an Opinion of Pelagius's, I see no harm that would come of setting it on foot again; it surprises me more, that any should send such false Advices.

I shall say somewhat of this little Book; and first observe that the Pope not being able by all the means he used to oblige the Women to cover their Breasts and Arms; and understanding that the fear that all Italy was in when the Turks be∣sieged Vienna, did not hinder this disorder, he had recourse to his last shift, his Ex∣communication, which he published by a Decree the 30th. of November, 83. com∣manding all Women and Girls to cover their Shoulders and Breasts to the Neck, and their Arms to their Hands, and this with no Tran∣sparent, but thick Cloth, under pain, if they did not exactly obey it within six days, to be excommunicated Ipso facto, that in no other case but at the Point of Death, none but the Pope himself should absolve them: For it was declared, That the Confessors that durst presume to absolve from this Excommu∣nication, should incur it themselves, and should become subject to what Temporal and Spiritual punishments the Pope would be pleas'd to lay on them, to which Temporal punishments, also the Fa∣thers, Husbands, Masters, or other heads of Fami∣lies should be subject, that continued at, or permit∣ted their Wives, Daughters or Maids, to disobey this Ordinance. This is all there at length, with two Letters which relate to it; one was writ through the Pope's Order, by the Procurer general of the Capuchins, to all the Provincials of his Order, to oblige their Preachers and Confessors, to endeavour more than ordinarily against the corrup∣ruption of Manners, and chiefly in rela∣tion to Women, to strive to bring them off their Dresses that are too Luxurious, and im∣modest. The other Letter is that of Mr.

Page 425

Stravius, Administrator of the Nuncia∣ture of the Low-Countries, which he writ to the Bishops the 31th. of March, 35. by order from Urban the VIII. to put them in mind of proceeding against worldly Wo∣men, who uncovered their Breasts and Shoulders, and cover'd their Faces with Patches; And to proceed against them to the very shutting them out of the Church, if it could be done. This shews that for a long time they have taken pains to remedy these Nakednesses, and that they are obstinately resisted therein. This in all likelyhood will be an employ∣ment that will never be wanting to the Preachers of Reformation. All these pieces which I have quoted, come after the Let∣ter to the Nuns; the Clergy-man that writes it to them, directs it only to the Re∣verend Mothers. He represents to them to the Life, the extent of that disorder, which Innocent the XI. punished with so much severity. He adds, that its their business chiefly to endeavour this Refor∣mation, as well because the Publick trusts them with the Education of their young Daughters, as that it is easie for them to instruct 'em in all that is modest in such a tender age, wherein they have all the Bashfulness and Tractableness of their Sex. He tells them, that in the best go∣vern'd Monasteries, It happens but too often that for want of applying themselves sufficient∣ly to express the first motions of Youthful Va∣nities, and forward of giving them an aversion to ill Books, and immodest sights, for too ten∣der friendships, and the too great love of their Bodies, and for the Inclination of shewing such parts as Modesty and Decency require to be covered with the greatest care and exact∣ness: These young Scholars have their Hearts full of the World and its desires, and with a great impatience of having the full satisfa∣ction of all the pleasures and liberties that they think their Cloysters kept them from, or the vigilance of their Mistresses. Experience is a very strong Proof of this, and all the World acknowledge it; whether it really proceeds from what he pretends here, that the first Progress of corruption is not repressed with viligance and care enough, or whether it be that Nature is more pre∣vailing than all the dexterous endeavours of Art. Nature is an inward Master, whose Precepts lead a young Disciple very far, without the assistance of any one, though his Precepts be exposed by contrary ones; Then what cannot this Nature do, when it is assisted by the Dictates of an outward Master, who passionately Caresses, and cajoles a young Pensioner but lately come from a Convent? 'Tis said, he does more in an hour, than the Reverend Mothers in a 1000; and in 2 or 3 times head to head; he blots out all their Repetitions. Here is what one may do that works upon Mat∣ter naturally well prepared. This does not hinder Peoples getting their Children brought up at Convents, for it is thought the evil would be the more universal, if they were not armed with this defence before they imbarked in the World. And moreover, it is thought Family Examples should not be suffered to their knowledge.

This Author shews a great Zeal for the Education of Young Women; he would have them to be made to comprehend well, that it is but in vain, that they flat∣ter themselves with having a Chaste Heart, or a love for Purity, either in the Cloyster, or in the World, if they do not love these things in others, as well as in themselves; and to convince themselves of this Love they ought to keep from all that may lessen it in their own Hearts, or in their Neighbours, and always forbid themselves the use of these ill Fashions, which by Violence, and open force made passage for desires, and designs opposite to Chastity into the best disposed Hearts. He proceeds, and says, that it is not suffi∣cient to cover what might give scandal to our Neighbour, and hurt Chastity, but they are to cover it modestly, and they must be learned; that very often these worldly Ornaments, and these cheating Vails that cover without hiding, serve only to irritate and multiply in a Thou∣sand different ways, the desires and mo∣tions of a corrupted Heart; and it is for this, that the Pope's Edict has in express terms enjoyn'd them, They shall cover themselves with a thick, and not with a tran∣sparent Cloath: This takes away all Equi∣vocation which might be made use of to cheat the Governours Vigilance. For though according to remark of a certain Ancient, A Man cannot well take an Oath, if he is not quite naked; for when Men are clad with any prejudices, &c. there are abundance that would not stick to swear any thing: So the Pope did very well, to mark expresly Cloth not transparent. Afterwards the Au∣thor shews, that the Scripture condemns all Equipage, and vanity in Cloathing, and that for greater reason it condemns these Nakednesses, which shew so much self love, and inclination to be the occa∣sion of sin to our Neighbour. He does not quote the Fathers, which he might many on the same occasions: He suppo∣ses, that those he speaks to, have no need of proofs for what he says. It must be allowed, that the principles of this Mora∣lity are agreeable to Christianity; never∣theless, there are many Casuists who have pardoned Nakedness on many accounts, which the famous Voetius reproaches them with in the 4th. Volume of his Disputes, p. 461. where he takes notice, that he knew but one Divine of this Communion, which was Alstedius, who has said, that a Woman might go naked, or covered with slight Gause, in the Countreys where it is the custom to go so. This Clause serves to excusest the Casuists, because it is certain that Nakedness loses the great∣est part of its Allurement by custom.

Page 426

Schookius the constant defender of dissolute Morality against Preciseness; for it is so he called the Scrupulous and Austere Morals of Voetius, cites upon this Subject among other things which the Minister Iohn Leri re∣marks upon the occasion of the Womens going quite nak∣ed in Brasil, which is, that Dressing works a greater effect than the most natural sim∣plicity.

As for the rest, This Stranger that gave me the account of the publishing this Book for the Nuns, was the occasion that I made an Article of it in my Novels, he also was the cause of my speaking of the Factum of the Iansenists: For it was thro him that I understood it was published. Both these advices came to me at the same time, from the same place, and with Glosses that have not been found true; perhaps People may be willing enough that I should add at the end of this Article, the present condition of the Iansenists Process.

I say then, that they published a Second Factum, wherein they declared, that hav∣ing the advice of some godly Persons they were willing to end the debate some mild∣er way than by a rigorous Judgment; that for this end they Declared to Mr. Inter∣nance, presenting him a Form of Retractati∣on to be sent to Father Hazart, That they were ready to desist from all Pursuits. If that Father and Mr. Hoesslaegh Signed this Mo∣del and Published it afterwards, its at length here accompanyed with the 19th. Decree of the 12 General Congregation of Iesuits, because it might engage Father Hazards Superiours to bring him more Effi∣caciously, to which he could not refuse with∣out renouncing his hopes of safety. This Decree speaks in most express Terms how the Superiours of the Jesuits are obliged to impose rigourous Penance on those of their Society who offend their Neighbour, through the indiscretion of their Pen, and must make them presently lawful satisfa∣ction; Mr. Internance has promised to send the Model to Father Hazard, and has Named Judges, which makes some be∣lieve that there is nothing to be hoped for from the expedient, that the Plantiffs have offered. This is the more manifest by two Letters, that this Jesuit has writ to a per∣son of Quality, that he is not inclin'd to do what is propos'd to him.

The first of these Letters contains a ve∣ry sharp Invective against the Iansenists, and a promise to answer in writing the complaints of the Plantiffs.

The Second shews, that Father Hazard will make no answer at all, both because the Judgment of many Lawyers and Di∣vines determined it beneath him, and be∣cause he sees his Adversaries abhorred by the Catholicks, and even refuted by the Hereticks; to prove which he alledges what we said of the First Factum, and makes Observations thereon, which are not so just as those that are made here of his two Letters; the two Articles of our Nouvelles, which concern the First Factum, are inserted in these Factums, and may be well enough understood by the Reader, without our Commentary.

If Father Hazard imitated M. Arnaud, he would fairly have shewn the model of Retractation, which was propos'd to him; for Mr. Arnaud, understanding that Mr. Southwell, an English Protestant, had com∣plained how unjustly he had been dealt with in the Apology of the Catholicks, up∣on the account of Coleman's Tryal, pre∣sently offered him any fitting satisfaction; and as soon as he had seen the proofs of Mr. Southwell's Innocency, he writ to him in the most honest and obliging way in the World, for the reparation of his Ho∣nour; and that the matter might become publick, he desired one of his Friends to print all that passed in clearing this mat∣ter. It was done according to his Wishes; since a second addition has been Printed, for the first part of the Apology of the Ca∣tholicks, in which addition are the Letters about M. Arnaud writ upon this Subject, those which M. Southwell has answered, and what justifies the innocence of this last. This will not be the least glorious action in the Life of M. Arnaud, when the History is finished.

Notes

Do you have questions about this content? Need to report a problem? Please contact us.