For this doctrine may seeme to bee too broad a way, and too open a doore of hope and comfort to the most lewd men. Oh (will they say) this doctrine we like well, this giveth us assurance that our hearts are as upright, as the precisest of them all; for wee also have good desires, we would faine doe well, we desire to beleeve in Christ, we desire to repent and leave our sins. And so we shall find in the word of sundry cast-awayes, that have not onely had desires to be saved, as Baalam. Numbers 23.10. Let mee dye the death of the righteous, and let my last end be like his, and those foolish virgins that cryed, Mat. 25.11. Lord, Lord, open unto us; but have had desires also to go in the way that leadeth unto life, desires to doe well. Many I say unto you (saith our Saviour, Luke 13.24.) will seeke to enter in at the strait gate, and shall not bee able.
Now my answer unto this objection, shall consist of two parts. First. Admit, that wicked men will take hurt by this doctrine (as I doubt not but many doe, and will doe; the children of disobedience will be apt to stumble at the word, and thereunto they were even appointed, as the Apostle spea∣keth, 1 Peter 2.8.) yet must not so necessary a truth, and that tendeth so much to the comfort of poore Christians, be concealed for that; We may not indeed take the childrens bread and cast it to dogs, as our Saviour speaketh, Mat. 15.26 but yet wee must not with-hold from Gods children, their bread, because such dogs will be snatching at it. We are to have more respect in our ministery to the comfort of one poore Christian, then to the offence of an hundred such as these. And therein we are warranted by the example of our blessed Saviour himselfe Matth. 15.12—14.
But secondly I answer. If there were indeed in these, whose lives are most wicked, such infeined desires to doe well, and to please God, I will be bold to assure them in Gods name, and by warrant of his word, that (notwithstanding all the wickednes of their lives) their hearts are upright, and there is truth of saving grace in them. But (alas) no man whose life is wicked, hath indeed any good, and unfeined, and sanctified desires to doe well, nay he hath no true and unfeined desire to be saved.
Five notes of difference I will give you out of Gods word, betweene the true saving and sanctified desires which are in the regenerate, and the naturall, and counterfeit good desires that are in wicked men.
[ 1] First. The regenerate mans desire of salvation, or of any saving grace, is joy∣ned with a love and desire to the meanes of salvation and of grace. So it was with David, Psal. 119.174. I have longed for thy salvation ô Lord, and thy law is my delight. The naturall man hath no desire or love to the meanes of salva∣tion and grace, to those meanes that God hath ordained to bring them to faith and repentance by, and therefore certainly he doth not unfeinedly desire to be∣leeve, or to repent, or to be saved. He that desireth not the knowledge of Gods wayes, doth say in his heart to God, depart from me, Iob. 21.14. he doth not de∣sire Gods favour, he doth not desire to beleeve in him, or to serve him, or to have any thing to doe with him.
[ 2] Secondly. The regenerate mans desire of salvation, or of any saving grace, is constant and permanent. My soule breaketh for the longing that it hath unto thy judgements at all times, saith David, Psalme 119.20. and 27.4. One thing have I desired of the Lord, that will I seeke after, that I may dwell in the house of the Lord all the dayes of my life. The naturall mans good motions, and de∣sires, be like the fits of an ague, or flashings of lightning sudden and vanishing, when the terrours of God are upon them. Their goodnes is as the moring cloud (saith the Prophet Hos. 6.4.) and as early dew it goeth away; therfore they are counterfeit, they can have no comfort in them.
[ 3] Thirdly. The regenerate mans desire to doe well, is not without endeavour