With Readers and Correspondents [pp. 562-569]

Catholic world. / Volume 45, Issue 268

562 WITH READERS AND CORRESPONDENTS. [July, until he has done away with the chief obstacle to matrimony in his case, and fallen heir to a fortune. Mrs. Molesworth's philosophy is one not generally taught in novels. She teaches that the material conditions of marriage cannot safely be overlooked, and that the thoughtlessness and carelessness of parents are the causes of the great number of unhappy marriages. French parents present no young man to their daughters who is not suitable in every way. The French home is most exclusive, most impenetrable. No stranger not responsibly introduced is admitted. The chaperon is an institution; and the results show that a community of interests is as binding as a community of sentiment. Duty, after all, becomes a habit more likely to last than the first glow of inclination, when "in the spring a young man's fancy lightly turns to thoughts of love." Marriage and Giving in Marriage might profitably be considered and discussed by American fathers and mothers. MAURICE FRANCIS EGAN. WITH READERS AND CORRESPONDENTS. Under this head we purpose for the future to give a variety of articles too brief, too informal, or too piersonal for the body of the magazine. For obvious reasons these communications will be, for the most part, unsigned. THE STORY OF A CONVERSION. I belong to a Connecticut family of Puritan descent, and was baptized, as an infant, in the Congregational Church. Later on my father began to attend the Episcopal Church, and in that church I was confirmed. In my last year at college I read McIlvaine's Evidences of Christianity, a book considered at the time a standard Protestant authority. This book made me an infidel. My reasoning was this: Here is the best that can be said on the evidences of Christianity; if these are the best evidences, then I am an infidel. I was much interested at the time in Darwin, in the works of John Stuart Mill and Herbert Spencer, in Lewes' History of Philosophy and in his account of the Positive philosophy, and in the articles published by the Westminster Review. After graduating at an American college I went to Germany as a devotee of ,the Positive philosophy. Having heard of the materialistic tendencies of German thought, I was much surprised to find that the Positive philosophy had no standing in Germany. I found, also, that thle names of Mill and Spencer, and the freethinking English school, had no great weight in that country. I became inoculated with German tendencies, and they led me to respect all religions. I found, for example, that a German historian of Buddhism placed himself in the mood of the Buddhist, and conceived his mission of historian as one mainly of sympathy, not of criticism; and so with regard to other religions. Thus I came to believe


562 WITH READERS AND CORRESPONDENTS. [July, until he has done away with the chief obstacle to matrimony in his case, and fallen heir to a fortune. Mrs. Molesworth's philosophy is one not generally taught in novels. She teaches that the material conditions of marriage cannot safely be overlooked, and that the thoughtlessness and carelessness of parents are the causes of the great number of unhappy marriages. French parents present no young man to their daughters who is not suitable in every way. The French home is most exclusive, most impenetrable. No stranger not responsibly introduced is admitted. The chaperon is an institution; and the results show that a community of interests is as binding as a community of sentiment. Duty, after all, becomes a habit more likely to last than the first glow of inclination, when "in the spring a young man's fancy lightly turns to thoughts of love." Marriage and Giving in Marriage might profitably be considered and discussed by American fathers and mothers. MAURICE FRANCIS EGAN. WITH READERS AND CORRESPONDENTS. Under this head we purpose for the future to give a variety of articles too brief, too informal, or too piersonal for the body of the magazine. For obvious reasons these communications will be, for the most part, unsigned. THE STORY OF A CONVERSION. I belong to a Connecticut family of Puritan descent, and was baptized, as an infant, in the Congregational Church. Later on my father began to attend the Episcopal Church, and in that church I was confirmed. In my last year at college I read McIlvaine's Evidences of Christianity, a book considered at the time a standard Protestant authority. This book made me an infidel. My reasoning was this: Here is the best that can be said on the evidences of Christianity; if these are the best evidences, then I am an infidel. I was much interested at the time in Darwin, in the works of John Stuart Mill and Herbert Spencer, in Lewes' History of Philosophy and in his account of the Positive philosophy, and in the articles published by the Westminster Review. After graduating at an American college I went to Germany as a devotee of ,the Positive philosophy. Having heard of the materialistic tendencies of German thought, I was much surprised to find that the Positive philosophy had no standing in Germany. I found, also, that thle names of Mill and Spencer, and the freethinking English school, had no great weight in that country. I became inoculated with German tendencies, and they led me to respect all religions. I found, for example, that a German historian of Buddhism placed himself in the mood of the Buddhist, and conceived his mission of historian as one mainly of sympathy, not of criticism; and so with regard to other religions. Thus I came to believe

/ 144
Pages Index

Actions

file_download Download Options Download this page PDF - Pages 553-562 Image - Page 562 Plain Text - Page 562

About this Item

Title
With Readers and Correspondents [pp. 562-569]
Canvas
Page 562
Serial
Catholic world. / Volume 45, Issue 268

Technical Details

Link to this Item
https://name.umdl.umich.edu/bac8387.0045.268
Link to this scan
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/m/moajrnl/bac8387.0045.268/566:14

Rights and Permissions

The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials are in the public domain in the United States. If you have questions about the collection, please contact Digital Content & Collections at [email protected]. If you have concerns about the inclusion of an item in this collection, please contact Library Information Technology at [email protected].

DPLA Rights Statement: No Copyright - United States

Manifest
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/t/text/api/manifest/moajrnl:bac8387.0045.268

Cite this Item

Full citation
"With Readers and Correspondents [pp. 562-569]." In the digital collection Making of America Journal Articles. https://name.umdl.umich.edu/bac8387.0045.268. University of Michigan Library Digital Collections. Accessed June 24, 2025.
Do you have questions about this content? Need to report a problem? Please contact us.