Individuality-Its Be(ring upon the Art of Utterance. The gallant Martin and Vizitelly, congenial spirits among genial men, who wished only to be happy and to make happiness among their fellows, have both left hosts of friends to mourn over their tragic and mysterious fates-the one with his grave in the mighty deep, the other amid the shifting sands of the Sahara, and each the victim of consummate villains, who selfishly and fiendishly subordinated all the rights and interests of others to their own overwhelming and unholy ambition. It is, also, worth recalling in these reminiscences that another of the companions of Martin and Vizitelly, on the trip of the "Lillian" here recited, was Captain Young, who, with a band of Confederates that had escaped into Canada from Northern prisons, soon afterwards spread consternation along our Canadian borders, by his sudden raid on St. Albans, Vermnont. Captain Young still survives, and in these piping and prosperous days of "white-winged Peace," when Northmen and Southmen are friends once more, he is a prominent railroad man, in the good old commonwealth of Kentucky. May our goodly land never again know these hazards, and pangs, and desolations of civil war, and may the world's records never again be blackened by the name of so hideous a monster in human form as was Alexander Keith. j W. A. Wright. INDIVIDUALITY-ITS BEARING UPON THE ART OF UTTERANCE. As there is no dissent to the opinion that the study of the art of utterance is a most important one, the fact of the unpopularity of that study in most of our higher institutions of learning is to be explained. Surely, nothing more can be done than is done in the way of systematic development of the voice; and rules have been given to cover, apparently, every phase of expression. What, then, is the radical error on the part of the teacher of elocution? To me it is indicated by a persistent and vain effort to lose his individuality-to sink it entirely-in such impersonations as are required by recitation or declamation, and in encouraging his pupils to do likewise. Even upon the stage, where every theatrical help is extended, the actor often fails, because he does not grasp the essential truth that the individuality of the performer can never be absolutely lost in the character assumed. It may sound paradoxical, but I venture the assertion that the fiurther the actor gets away from himself, the worse is his acting. It must be borne in mind, that this whole business of the theater is a compromise between actor and audience. The auditors agree that Mr. Booth, or Mr. Irving, or Mr. Barrett, as the case might be, shall attempt a certain impersonation; but at the same time, it is tacitly understood that the actor is simply tickling the imagination, and the hearers will permit that agreeable operation only to a limited extent. What is called over-acting is but another name for insulting the imagination of the audience. In fact, the highest enjoyment of the cultured listener is not in being carried away by, we will say, the Hamlet of Booth, but in watching just how far Mr. Booth can thrust his individuality into the representation of Hamrnlet. And so it is that every actor who has achieved signal success has discovered that he is best fitted for one part-the part in which he can best portray himself. Booth would. have failed as Hamlet, were he not in his very personality, seemingly, the studious, reserved, melancholy counterpart of the "dreamy Dane." There seems to me a solid philosophy at the bottom of this theory. We all love truth better than falsehood: so we enjoy the attempt to personate (which is a truth) more than the personation itself (which is a falsity). Take other theatrical modern instances. I will designate but a few. Sothern on the [March), 302
Individuality—Its Bearing Upon the Art of Utterance [pp. 302-304]
Overland monthly and Out West magazine. / Volume 7, Issue 39
Annotations Tools
Individuality-Its Be(ring upon the Art of Utterance. The gallant Martin and Vizitelly, congenial spirits among genial men, who wished only to be happy and to make happiness among their fellows, have both left hosts of friends to mourn over their tragic and mysterious fates-the one with his grave in the mighty deep, the other amid the shifting sands of the Sahara, and each the victim of consummate villains, who selfishly and fiendishly subordinated all the rights and interests of others to their own overwhelming and unholy ambition. It is, also, worth recalling in these reminiscences that another of the companions of Martin and Vizitelly, on the trip of the "Lillian" here recited, was Captain Young, who, with a band of Confederates that had escaped into Canada from Northern prisons, soon afterwards spread consternation along our Canadian borders, by his sudden raid on St. Albans, Vermnont. Captain Young still survives, and in these piping and prosperous days of "white-winged Peace," when Northmen and Southmen are friends once more, he is a prominent railroad man, in the good old commonwealth of Kentucky. May our goodly land never again know these hazards, and pangs, and desolations of civil war, and may the world's records never again be blackened by the name of so hideous a monster in human form as was Alexander Keith. j W. A. Wright. INDIVIDUALITY-ITS BEARING UPON THE ART OF UTTERANCE. As there is no dissent to the opinion that the study of the art of utterance is a most important one, the fact of the unpopularity of that study in most of our higher institutions of learning is to be explained. Surely, nothing more can be done than is done in the way of systematic development of the voice; and rules have been given to cover, apparently, every phase of expression. What, then, is the radical error on the part of the teacher of elocution? To me it is indicated by a persistent and vain effort to lose his individuality-to sink it entirely-in such impersonations as are required by recitation or declamation, and in encouraging his pupils to do likewise. Even upon the stage, where every theatrical help is extended, the actor often fails, because he does not grasp the essential truth that the individuality of the performer can never be absolutely lost in the character assumed. It may sound paradoxical, but I venture the assertion that the fiurther the actor gets away from himself, the worse is his acting. It must be borne in mind, that this whole business of the theater is a compromise between actor and audience. The auditors agree that Mr. Booth, or Mr. Irving, or Mr. Barrett, as the case might be, shall attempt a certain impersonation; but at the same time, it is tacitly understood that the actor is simply tickling the imagination, and the hearers will permit that agreeable operation only to a limited extent. What is called over-acting is but another name for insulting the imagination of the audience. In fact, the highest enjoyment of the cultured listener is not in being carried away by, we will say, the Hamlet of Booth, but in watching just how far Mr. Booth can thrust his individuality into the representation of Hamrnlet. And so it is that every actor who has achieved signal success has discovered that he is best fitted for one part-the part in which he can best portray himself. Booth would. have failed as Hamlet, were he not in his very personality, seemingly, the studious, reserved, melancholy counterpart of the "dreamy Dane." There seems to me a solid philosophy at the bottom of this theory. We all love truth better than falsehood: so we enjoy the attempt to personate (which is a truth) more than the personation itself (which is a falsity). Take other theatrical modern instances. I will designate but a few. Sothern on the [March), 302
-
Scan #1
Page 225
-
Scan #2
Page 226
-
Scan #3
Page 227
-
Scan #4
Page 228
-
Scan #5
Page 229
-
Scan #6
Page 230
-
Scan #7
Page 231
-
Scan #8
Page 232
-
Scan #9
Page 233
-
Scan #10
Page 234
-
Scan #11
Page 235
-
Scan #12
Page 236
-
Scan #13
Page 237
-
Scan #14
Page 238
-
Scan #15
Page 239
-
Scan #16
Page 240
-
Scan #17
Page 241
-
Scan #18
Page 242
-
Scan #19
Page 243
-
Scan #20
Page 244
-
Scan #21
Page 245
-
Scan #22
Page 246
-
Scan #23
Page 247
-
Scan #24
Page 248
-
Scan #25
Page 249
-
Scan #26
Page 250
-
Scan #27
Page 251
-
Scan #28
Page 252
-
Scan #29
Page 253
-
Scan #30
Page 254
-
Scan #31
Page 255
-
Scan #32
Page 256
-
Scan #33
Page 257
-
Scan #34
Page 258
-
Scan #35
Page 259
-
Scan #36
Page 260
-
Scan #37
Page 261
-
Scan #38
Page 262
-
Scan #39
Page 263
-
Scan #40
Page 264
-
Scan #41
Page 265
-
Scan #42
Page 266
-
Scan #43
Page 267
-
Scan #44
Page 268
-
Scan #45
Page 269
-
Scan #46
Page 270
-
Scan #47
Page 271
-
Scan #48
Page 272
-
Scan #49
Page 273
-
Scan #50
Page 274
-
Scan #51
Page 275
-
Scan #52
Page 276
-
Scan #53
Page 277
-
Scan #54
Page 278
-
Scan #55
Page 279
-
Scan #56
Page 280
-
Scan #57
Page 281
-
Scan #58
Page 282
-
Scan #59
Page 283
-
Scan #60
Page 284
-
Scan #61
Page 285
-
Scan #62
Page 286
-
Scan #63
Page 287
-
Scan #64
Page 288
-
Scan #65
Page 289
-
Scan #66
Page 290
-
Scan #67
Page 291
-
Scan #68
Page 292
-
Scan #69
Page 293
-
Scan #70
Page 294
-
Scan #71
Page 295
-
Scan #72
Page 296
-
Scan #73
Page 297
-
Scan #74
Page 298
-
Scan #75
Page 299
-
Scan #76
Page 300
-
Scan #77
Page 301
-
Scan #78
Page 302
-
Scan #79
Page 303
-
Scan #80
Page 304
-
Scan #81
Page 305
-
Scan #82
Page 306
-
Scan #83
Page 307
-
Scan #84
Page 308
-
Scan #85
Page 309
-
Scan #86
Page 310
-
Scan #87
Page 311
-
Scan #88
Page 312
-
Scan #89
Page 313
-
Scan #90
Page 314
-
Scan #91
Page 315
-
Scan #92
Page 316
-
Scan #93
Page 317
-
Scan #94
Page 318
-
Scan #95
Page 319
-
Scan #96
Page 320
-
Scan #97
Page 321
-
Scan #98
Page 322
-
Scan #99
Page 323
-
Scan #100
Page 324
-
Scan #101
Page 325
-
Scan #102
Page 326
-
Scan #103
Page 327
-
Scan #104
Page 328
-
Scan #105
Page 329
-
Scan #106
Page 330
-
Scan #107
Page 331
-
Scan #108
Page 332
-
Scan #109
Page 333
-
Scan #110
Page 334
-
Scan #111
Page 335
-
Scan #112
Page 336
- The Knights of Labor on the Chinese Situation - W. W. Stone - pp. 225-230
- A Prophecy Partly Verified - P. S. Dorney - pp. 230-234
- The Tacoma Method - George Dudley Lawson - pp. 234-239
- Sequel to the Tacoma Method - H. - pp. 239-240
- For Money.—Chapters IX-XI - Helen Lake - pp. 241-254
- At Daybreak - M. F. Rowntree - pp. 254
- Explorations in the Upper Columbia Country - Samuel Rodman, Jr. - pp. 255-266
- An Heritage of Crime - F. K. Upham - pp. 266-275
- Lost Journals of a Pioneer.—III - G. E. Montgomery - pp. 276-287
- Comrades Only - Emilie Tracy Y. Swett - pp. 287-293
- A Winter Among the Piutes - William Nye - pp. 293-298
- Mysterious Fate of Blockade Runners - J. W. A. Wright - pp. 298-302
- Individuality—Its Bearing Upon the Art of Utterance - John Murray - pp. 302-304
- A New Study of Some Problems Relating to the Giant Trees - C. B. Bradley - pp. 305-316
- March.—By the Atlantic - Helen Chase - pp. 316
- March.—By the Pacific - Ina D. Coolbrith - pp. 316
- Stedman's Poets of America - pp. 317-319
- Recent Fiction - pp. 320-324
- Italian Popular Tales - pp. 325-326
- Etc. - pp. 326-334
- Book Reviews - pp. 334-336
Actions
About this Item
- Title
- Individuality—Its Bearing Upon the Art of Utterance [pp. 302-304]
- Author
- Murray, John
- Canvas
- Page 302
- Serial
- Overland monthly and Out West magazine. / Volume 7, Issue 39
Technical Details
- Collection
- Making of America Journal Articles
- Link to this Item
-
https://name.umdl.umich.edu/ahj1472.2-07.039
- Link to this scan
-
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/m/moajrnl/ahj1472.2-07.039/308
Rights and Permissions
The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials are in the public domain in the United States. If you have questions about the collection, please contact Digital Content & Collections at [email protected]. If you have concerns about the inclusion of an item in this collection, please contact Library Information Technology at [email protected].
DPLA Rights Statement: No Copyright - United States
Related Links
IIIF
- Manifest
-
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/t/text/api/manifest/moajrnl:ahj1472.2-07.039
Cite this Item
- Full citation
-
"Individuality—Its Bearing Upon the Art of Utterance [pp. 302-304]." In the digital collection Making of America Journal Articles. https://name.umdl.umich.edu/ahj1472.2-07.039. University of Michigan Library Digital Collections. Accessed June 22, 2025.