Miss Evans; St. Elmo [pp. 268-273]

Debow's review, Agricultural, commercial, industrial progress and resources. / Volume 3, Issue 3

MISS EVANS -ST. ELMO. teenth century gather to test their ratiocinative skill, and bear off the crown of bay on the point of a syllogism or the wings of an audacious hypothesis." What wonder then that this gifted young female projects a book, which in its scope and erudition rivals any production that has electrified the world for eighteen hundred years, and "muid night often found her groping in the classic dust of extinct sys tems." Disdaining the frivolities of youth, she devotes herself to this work, and Miss Evans adds: "The vastness of the cosmic field she was now compelled to traverse, the innumerable ramifications of polytheistic and monotheistic creeds, necessi tated-unwearied research as she rent asunder the superstitious vails which various nations and successive epochs had woven before the shining features of truth. Having once grappled with her theme, she wrestled as Jacob for the blessing of a successful solution, and in order to popularize a subject bristling withl recondite archaisms and philologic problems, she cast it in the mould of fiction! Verily! an ambitious literary programme for a girl over whose head scarcely eighteen years had hung their dripping, drab, wintry skies and peaily summer clouds." Happy printer, publisher and reader, that such a "literary programme" figures only in the mental kaleidoscope of the writer! Pursued by the addresses of St. Elmo, who rules her heart, but against whom her judgment rebels, Edna starts forth again on her travels, and is safely landed in New York, where she becomes a governess, and at the same time obtains great notoriety by her writings for a popular magazine. The best drawn character ill the book is here introduced, Mr. Douglas G. Manning, an editor, who talks sensibly and frames his ideas in comprehensible language. HIis advent is the signal for a decided improvement in the tone of the book; the style loses some of its verbosity, the scenes become more natural, the conversations less weighty. The heroine descends firom her jaded steed, and, walking along the path of every-day life, shows us the sunny side of her character. By her devotion to a little invalid boy, and consistency of purpose in following the dictates of conscience rather than passion, she wins a higher place in our esteem than while burning the midnight taper to write unreadable books, or launchbing at the devoted heads of the patient listeners quotations from Burke, Buckle, Mill and Buskin, with plentiful libations of Anthon's Classical Dictionary. By these remarks we do not wish to be understood as denying woman " her right to erudition," so far from it, we agree with Miss Evans that in "this nineteenth century it is her privilege to be as learned as Cuvier or Sir William Hamilton or Humboldt," provided she has the capacity to digest the material. But let such knowledge serve to develop her own ideas so that her conversation may not be but a continual advertisement of the contents of her library, and if she have wit enough to write a book, let it emanate from the native mint, and be stamped with the author's seal. 272

/ 112
Pages Index

Actions

file_download Download Options Download this page PDF - Pages 265-274 Image - Page 272 Plain Text - Page 272

About this Item

Title
Miss Evans; St. Elmo [pp. 268-273]
Author
Lady of Virginia, A
Canvas
Page 272
Serial
Debow's review, Agricultural, commercial, industrial progress and resources. / Volume 3, Issue 3

Technical Details

Link to this Item
https://name.umdl.umich.edu/acg1336.2-03.003
Link to this scan
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/m/moajrnl/acg1336.2-03.003/276:4

Rights and Permissions

The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials are in the public domain in the United States. If you have questions about the collection, please contact Digital Content & Collections at [email protected]. If you have concerns about the inclusion of an item in this collection, please contact Library Information Technology at [email protected].

DPLA Rights Statement: No Copyright - United States

Manifest
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/t/text/api/manifest/moajrnl:acg1336.2-03.003

Cite this Item

Full citation
"Miss Evans; St. Elmo [pp. 268-273]." In the digital collection Making of America Journal Articles. https://name.umdl.umich.edu/acg1336.2-03.003. University of Michigan Library Digital Collections. Accessed May 18, 2025.
Do you have questions about this content? Need to report a problem? Please contact us.