Church Action on Temperance [pp. 595-632]

The Princeton review. / Volume 43, Issue 4

1871.] of Bible Lands, and of the Lord's Suyper. 595 ever plausible they appear, yet they contain a lurking fallacy, which needs only to be brought out to spoil them all. Now, why confirm such prejudices by doing violence to the acknowledged meaning of words? What is an intelligent man to think of the unfermented wine which some insist shall be used at the sacrament when he reads such definitions?" Writers generally agree that our Saviour used the ordinary wine provided for the Passover. Thus L. Coleman, D.D.,* says: "The common wine of Palestine is of a red color. Such was the wine which our Saviour used at the Sacrament, as it would seem both from the nature of the case and the declaration: 'This is my blood.'" Why then imperil the cause of temperance, as promoted by the pratice of total abstinence, by undermining faith in the obvious meaning of the word of God as understood by the Church in all ages; by putting it on grounds against which the convictions of its most devoted, pious, and intelligent friends, and of the great majority of Christian scholars and divines, are arrayed; which inlovate upon the Holy Sacrament; which must tend to narrow its influence to the small minority who can be gained over to such views; and which, so far, enlist in their defence more of misrepresentation and vituperation than of truth and argument, candor and charity? [The ethical, Scriptural, and ecclesiastical relations of total abstinence will be discussed in our next article.] ART. VI.-Testimonies of the General Assemblies of the Pres byterian Church in the United States against Intemperance. Philadelphia: Presbyterian Board of Publication. Tis is the pamphlet ordered to be printed by our last Assembly, containing the collective deliverances of past Assemblies on Temperance. It was also ordered to be sent to all ministers, and read to all churches in our body. Before directly discussing the questions it presents, we propose to give a brief * Ancient C&hristianity Exempglified, p. 437. VOL. XLIII.-NO. IV. 48


1871.] of Bible Lands, and of the Lord's Suyper. 595 ever plausible they appear, yet they contain a lurking fallacy, which needs only to be brought out to spoil them all. Now, why confirm such prejudices by doing violence to the acknowledged meaning of words? What is an intelligent man to think of the unfermented wine which some insist shall be used at the sacrament when he reads such definitions?" Writers generally agree that our Saviour used the ordinary wine provided for the Passover. Thus L. Coleman, D.D.,* says: "The common wine of Palestine is of a red color. Such was the wine which our Saviour used at the Sacrament, as it would seem both from the nature of the case and the declaration: 'This is my blood.'" Why then imperil the cause of temperance, as promoted by the pratice of total abstinence, by undermining faith in the obvious meaning of the word of God as understood by the Church in all ages; by putting it on grounds against which the convictions of its most devoted, pious, and intelligent friends, and of the great majority of Christian scholars and divines, are arrayed; which inlovate upon the Holy Sacrament; which must tend to narrow its influence to the small minority who can be gained over to such views; and which, so far, enlist in their defence more of misrepresentation and vituperation than of truth and argument, candor and charity? [The ethical, Scriptural, and ecclesiastical relations of total abstinence will be discussed in our next article.] ART. VI.-Testimonies of the General Assemblies of the Pres byterian Church in the United States against Intemperance. Philadelphia: Presbyterian Board of Publication. Tis is the pamphlet ordered to be printed by our last Assembly, containing the collective deliverances of past Assemblies on Temperance. It was also ordered to be sent to all ministers, and read to all churches in our body. Before directly discussing the questions it presents, we propose to give a brief * Ancient C&hristianity Exempglified, p. 437. VOL. XLIII.-NO. IV. 48

/ 168
Pages Index

Actions

file_download Download Options Download this page PDF - Pages 593-602 Image - Page 595 Plain Text - Page 595

About this Item

Title
Church Action on Temperance [pp. 595-632]
Canvas
Page 595
Serial
The Princeton review. / Volume 43, Issue 4

Technical Details

Link to this Item
https://name.umdl.umich.edu/acf4325.1-43.004
Link to this scan
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/m/moajrnl/acf4325.1-43.004/599:6

Rights and Permissions

The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials are in the public domain in the United States. If you have questions about the collection, please contact Digital Content & Collections at [email protected]. If you have concerns about the inclusion of an item in this collection, please contact Library Information Technology at [email protected].

DPLA Rights Statement: No Copyright - United States

Manifest
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/t/text/api/manifest/moajrnl:acf4325.1-43.004

Cite this Item

Full citation
"Church Action on Temperance [pp. 595-632]." In the digital collection Making of America Journal Articles. https://name.umdl.umich.edu/acf4325.1-43.004. University of Michigan Library Digital Collections. Accessed June 21, 2025.
Do you have questions about this content? Need to report a problem? Please contact us.