1871.] of Bible Lands, and of the Lord's Suyper. 595 ever plausible they appear, yet they contain a lurking fallacy, which needs only to be brought out to spoil them all. Now, why confirm such prejudices by doing violence to the acknowledged meaning of words? What is an intelligent man to think of the unfermented wine which some insist shall be used at the sacrament when he reads such definitions?" Writers generally agree that our Saviour used the ordinary wine provided for the Passover. Thus L. Coleman, D.D.,* says: "The common wine of Palestine is of a red color. Such was the wine which our Saviour used at the Sacrament, as it would seem both from the nature of the case and the declaration: 'This is my blood.'" Why then imperil the cause of temperance, as promoted by the pratice of total abstinence, by undermining faith in the obvious meaning of the word of God as understood by the Church in all ages; by putting it on grounds against which the convictions of its most devoted, pious, and intelligent friends, and of the great majority of Christian scholars and divines, are arrayed; which inlovate upon the Holy Sacrament; which must tend to narrow its influence to the small minority who can be gained over to such views; and which, so far, enlist in their defence more of misrepresentation and vituperation than of truth and argument, candor and charity? [The ethical, Scriptural, and ecclesiastical relations of total abstinence will be discussed in our next article.] ART. VI.-Testimonies of the General Assemblies of the Pres byterian Church in the United States against Intemperance. Philadelphia: Presbyterian Board of Publication. Tis is the pamphlet ordered to be printed by our last Assembly, containing the collective deliverances of past Assemblies on Temperance. It was also ordered to be sent to all ministers, and read to all churches in our body. Before directly discussing the questions it presents, we propose to give a brief * Ancient C&hristianity Exempglified, p. 437. VOL. XLIII.-NO. IV. 48
Church Action on Temperance [pp. 595-632]
The Princeton review. / Volume 43, Issue 4
Annotations Tools
1871.] of Bible Lands, and of the Lord's Suyper. 595 ever plausible they appear, yet they contain a lurking fallacy, which needs only to be brought out to spoil them all. Now, why confirm such prejudices by doing violence to the acknowledged meaning of words? What is an intelligent man to think of the unfermented wine which some insist shall be used at the sacrament when he reads such definitions?" Writers generally agree that our Saviour used the ordinary wine provided for the Passover. Thus L. Coleman, D.D.,* says: "The common wine of Palestine is of a red color. Such was the wine which our Saviour used at the Sacrament, as it would seem both from the nature of the case and the declaration: 'This is my blood.'" Why then imperil the cause of temperance, as promoted by the pratice of total abstinence, by undermining faith in the obvious meaning of the word of God as understood by the Church in all ages; by putting it on grounds against which the convictions of its most devoted, pious, and intelligent friends, and of the great majority of Christian scholars and divines, are arrayed; which inlovate upon the Holy Sacrament; which must tend to narrow its influence to the small minority who can be gained over to such views; and which, so far, enlist in their defence more of misrepresentation and vituperation than of truth and argument, candor and charity? [The ethical, Scriptural, and ecclesiastical relations of total abstinence will be discussed in our next article.] ART. VI.-Testimonies of the General Assemblies of the Pres byterian Church in the United States against Intemperance. Philadelphia: Presbyterian Board of Publication. Tis is the pamphlet ordered to be printed by our last Assembly, containing the collective deliverances of past Assemblies on Temperance. It was also ordered to be sent to all ministers, and read to all churches in our body. Before directly discussing the questions it presents, we propose to give a brief * Ancient C&hristianity Exempglified, p. 437. VOL. XLIII.-NO. IV. 48
-
Scan #1
Page 483
-
Scan #2
Page 484
-
Scan #3
Page 485
-
Scan #4
Page 486
-
Scan #5
Page 487
-
Scan #6
Page 488
-
Scan #7
Page 489
-
Scan #8
Page 490
-
Scan #9
Page 491
-
Scan #10
Page 492
-
Scan #11
Page 493
-
Scan #12
Page 494
-
Scan #13
Page 495
-
Scan #14
Page 496
-
Scan #15
Page 497
-
Scan #16
Page 498
-
Scan #17
Page 499
-
Scan #18
Page 500
-
Scan #19
Page 501
-
Scan #20
Page 502
-
Scan #21
Page 503
-
Scan #22
Page 504
-
Scan #23
Page 505
-
Scan #24
Page 506
-
Scan #25
Page 507
-
Scan #26
Page 508
-
Scan #27
Page 509
-
Scan #28
Page 510
-
Scan #29
Page 511
-
Scan #30
Page 512
-
Scan #31
Page 513
-
Scan #32
Page 514
-
Scan #33
Page 515
-
Scan #34
Page 516
-
Scan #35
Page 517
-
Scan #36
Page 518
-
Scan #37
Page 519
-
Scan #38
Page 520
-
Scan #39
Page 521
-
Scan #40
Page 522
-
Scan #41
Page 523
-
Scan #42
Page 524
-
Scan #43
Page 525
-
Scan #44
Page 526
-
Scan #45
Page 527
-
Scan #46
Page 528
-
Scan #47
Page 529
-
Scan #48
Page 530
-
Scan #49
Page 531
-
Scan #50
Page 532
-
Scan #51
Page 533
-
Scan #52
Page 534
-
Scan #53
Page 535
-
Scan #54
Page 536
-
Scan #55
Page 537
-
Scan #56
Page 538
-
Scan #57
Page 539
-
Scan #58
Page 540
-
Scan #59
Page 541
-
Scan #60
Page 542
-
Scan #61
Page 543
-
Scan #62
Page 544
-
Scan #63
Page 545
-
Scan #64
Page 546
-
Scan #65
Page 547
-
Scan #66
Page 548
-
Scan #67
Page 549
-
Scan #68
Page 550
-
Scan #69
Page 551
-
Scan #70
Page 552
-
Scan #71
Page 553
-
Scan #72
Page 554
-
Scan #73
Page 555
-
Scan #74
Page 556
-
Scan #75
Page 557
-
Scan #76
Page 558
-
Scan #77
Page 559
-
Scan #78
Page 560
-
Scan #79
Page 561
-
Scan #80
Page 562
-
Scan #81
Page 563
-
Scan #82
Page 564
-
Scan #83
Page 565
-
Scan #84
Page 566
-
Scan #85
Page 567
-
Scan #86
Page 568
-
Scan #87
Page 569
-
Scan #88
Page 570
-
Scan #89
Page 571
-
Scan #90
Page 572
-
Scan #91
Page 573
-
Scan #92
Page 574
-
Scan #93
Page 575
-
Scan #94
Page 576
-
Scan #95
Page 577
-
Scan #96
Page 578
-
Scan #97
Page 579
-
Scan #98
Page 580
-
Scan #99
Page 581
-
Scan #100
Page 582
-
Scan #101
Page 583
-
Scan #102
Page 584
-
Scan #103
Page 585
-
Scan #104
Page 586
-
Scan #105
Page 587
-
Scan #106
Page 588
-
Scan #107
Page 589
-
Scan #108
Page 590
-
Scan #109
Page 591
-
Scan #110
Page 592
-
Scan #111
Page 593
-
Scan #112
Page 594
-
Scan #113
Page 595
-
Scan #114
Page 596
-
Scan #115
Page 597
-
Scan #116
Page 598
-
Scan #117
Page 599
-
Scan #118
Page 600
-
Scan #119
Page 601
-
Scan #120
Page 602
-
Scan #121
Page 603
-
Scan #122
Page 604
-
Scan #123
Page 605
-
Scan #124
Page 606
-
Scan #125
Page 607
-
Scan #126
Page 608
-
Scan #127
Page 609
-
Scan #128
Page 610
-
Scan #129
Page 611
-
Scan #130
Page 612
-
Scan #131
Page 613
-
Scan #132
Page 614
-
Scan #133
Page 615
-
Scan #134
Page 616
-
Scan #135
Page 617
-
Scan #136
Page 618
-
Scan #137
Page 619
-
Scan #138
Page 620
-
Scan #139
Page 621
-
Scan #140
Page 622
-
Scan #141
Page 623
-
Scan #142
Page 624
-
Scan #143
Page 625
-
Scan #144
Page 626
-
Scan #145
Page 627
-
Scan #146
Page 628
-
Scan #147
Page 629
-
Scan #148
Page 630
-
Scan #149
Page 631
-
Scan #150
Page 632
-
Scan #151
Page 633
-
Scan #152
Page 634
-
Scan #153
Page 635
-
Scan #154
Page 636
-
Scan #155
Page 637
-
Scan #156
Page 638
-
Scan #157
Page 639
-
Scan #158
Page 640
-
Scan #159
Page 641
-
Scan #160
Page 642
-
Scan #161
Page 643
-
Scan #162
Page 644
-
Scan #163
Page 645
-
Scan #164
Page 646
-
Scan #165
Page 647
-
Scan #166
Page 648
-
Scan #167
Page 649
-
Scan #168
Page 650
- Introduction to a New System of Rhetoric. By Rev. J. H. McIlvaine, D. D. - pp. 483-515
- The Life and Letters of Frederick William Faber. By Rev. William Scribner - pp. 515-532
- Future Retribution. By Rev. George S. Mott - pp. 532-554
- Plan in History. By Rev. E. A. Lawrence, D. D. - pp. 555-564
- The Wine of the Bible, of Bible Lands, and of the Lord's Supper - pp. 564-595
- Church Action on Temperance - pp. 595-632
- Notices of Recent Publications - pp. 633-642
- Miscellaneous Back Matter - pp. 643-650
Actions
About this Item
- Title
- Church Action on Temperance [pp. 595-632]
- Canvas
- Page 595
- Serial
- The Princeton review. / Volume 43, Issue 4
Technical Details
- Collection
- Making of America Journal Articles
- Link to this Item
-
https://name.umdl.umich.edu/acf4325.1-43.004
- Link to this scan
-
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/m/moajrnl/acf4325.1-43.004/599:6
Rights and Permissions
The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials are in the public domain in the United States. If you have questions about the collection, please contact Digital Content & Collections at [email protected]. If you have concerns about the inclusion of an item in this collection, please contact Library Information Technology at [email protected].
DPLA Rights Statement: No Copyright - United States
Related Links
IIIF
- Manifest
-
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/t/text/api/manifest/moajrnl:acf4325.1-43.004
Cite this Item
- Full citation
-
"Church Action on Temperance [pp. 595-632]." In the digital collection Making of America Journal Articles. https://name.umdl.umich.edu/acf4325.1-43.004. University of Michigan Library Digital Collections. Accessed June 21, 2025.