Reason and Faith. after the pungent condemnation he has uttered in regard to an analogous view of prayer, as set forth by Kant.* A corollary from the foregoing positions, which our author enounces, is that "the legitimate object of a rational criticism of revealed religion, is not to be found in the contents of that religion, but in its evidences." Pp. 204, 205. He seems, however, to be aware that the two cannot thus be separated and sharply contrasted. A most material part of the evidence is the contents of revelation. It is this in-evidence of divinity that has borne it to the hearts of God's people of every age and nation in demonstration of the Spirit and of power. It ismbecause they hear a voice therein speaking as man never spake, and see a radiance of divinity not paralleled in the material creation or the light of nature, that they are conscious of vastly stronger evidence that the Bible is the word, than that the material world is the work of God. It is not merely miracles in contrast to the " contents" of revelation, but these very contents, too, that attest its Divine origin. MAr. Mansel says, "The primary and direct inquiry which human reason is entitled to make concerning a professed revelation is-how far does it tend to promote or hinder the moral discipline of man. It is but a secondary and indirect question, and one very liable to mislead, to ask how far it is compatible with the Infinite Goodness of God." P. 210. With all deference, this seems to us a baz-poev,rpor7EOV. It is because we see the impress of the "Infinite Goodness of God" upon the Scriptures, that we believe them "given by inspiration of God, and thus profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness, that the man of God may be per * "Let us hear then the philosopher's rational explanation, upon this assumption, of the duty of prayer. It is a mere superstitious delusion, he tells us, to consider prayer as service addressed to God, and as a means of obtain. ing his favour. The true purpose of the act is not to alter or affectin any way God's relation towards ia; but only to quicken our own moral sentiments, by keeping alive within us the idea of God as a moral Lawgiver. He, therefore, neither admits the duty unconditionally, nor rejects it entirely; but leaves it optional with men to adopt that or any other means, by which, in their own particular case, this moral end may be best promoted;-as if any moral benefit couldpossibly accruefrom the habitual exercise of an act of conscious self-decep tion." P. 56. VOL. XXXII.-NO. IV. 87 1860.] 681
Reason and Faith [pp. 648-685]
The Princeton review. / Volume 32, Issue 4
-
Scan #1
Page 577
-
Scan #2
Page 578
-
Scan #3
Page 579
-
Scan #4
Page 580
-
Scan #5
Page 581
-
Scan #6
Page 582
-
Scan #7
Page 583
-
Scan #8
Page 584
-
Scan #9
Page 585
-
Scan #10
Page 586
-
Scan #11
Page 587
-
Scan #12
Page 588
-
Scan #13
Page 589
-
Scan #14
Page 590
-
Scan #15
Page 591
-
Scan #16
Page 592
-
Scan #17
Page 593
-
Scan #18
Page 594
-
Scan #19
Page 595
-
Scan #20
Page 596
-
Scan #21
Page 597
-
Scan #22
Page 598
-
Scan #23
Page 599
-
Scan #24
Page 600
-
Scan #25
Page 601
-
Scan #26
Page 602
-
Scan #27
Page 603
-
Scan #28
Page 604
-
Scan #29
Page 605
-
Scan #30
Page 606
-
Scan #31
Page 607
-
Scan #32
Page 608
-
Scan #33
Page 609
-
Scan #34
Page 610
-
Scan #35
Page 611
-
Scan #36
Page 612
-
Scan #37
Page 613
-
Scan #38
Page 614
-
Scan #39
Page 615
-
Scan #40
Page 616
-
Scan #41
Page 617
-
Scan #42
Page 618
-
Scan #43
Page 619
-
Scan #44
Page 620
-
Scan #45
Page 621
-
Scan #46
Page 622
-
Scan #47
Page 623
-
Scan #48
Page 624
-
Scan #49
Page 625
-
Scan #50
Page 626
-
Scan #51
Page 627
-
Scan #52
Page 628
-
Scan #53
Page 629
-
Scan #54
Page 630
-
Scan #55
Page 631
-
Scan #56
Page 632
-
Scan #57
Page 633
-
Scan #58
Page 634
-
Scan #59
Page 635
-
Scan #60
Page 636
-
Scan #61
Page 637
-
Scan #62
Page 638
-
Scan #63
Page 639
-
Scan #64
Page 640
-
Scan #65
Page 641
-
Scan #66
Page 642
-
Scan #67
Page 643
-
Scan #68
Page 644
-
Scan #69
Page 645
-
Scan #70
Page 646
-
Scan #71
Page 647
-
Scan #72
Page 648
-
Scan #73
Page 649
-
Scan #74
Page 650
-
Scan #75
Page 651
-
Scan #76
Page 652
-
Scan #77
Page 653
-
Scan #78
Page 654
-
Scan #79
Page 655
-
Scan #80
Page 656
-
Scan #81
Page 657
-
Scan #82
Page 658
-
Scan #83
Page 659
-
Scan #84
Page 660
-
Scan #85
Page 661
-
Scan #86
Page 662
-
Scan #87
Page 663
-
Scan #88
Page 664
-
Scan #89
Page 665
-
Scan #90
Page 666
-
Scan #91
Page 667
-
Scan #92
Page 668
-
Scan #93
Page 669
-
Scan #94
Page 670
-
Scan #95
Page 671
-
Scan #96
Page 672
-
Scan #97
Page 673
-
Scan #98
Page 674
-
Scan #99
Page 675
-
Scan #100
Page 676
-
Scan #101
Page 677
-
Scan #102
Page 678
-
Scan #103
Page 679
-
Scan #104
Page 680
-
Scan #105
Page 681
-
Scan #106
Page 682
-
Scan #107
Page 683
-
Scan #108
Page 684
-
Scan #109
Page 685
-
Scan #110
Page 686
-
Scan #111
Page 687
-
Scan #112
Page 688
-
Scan #113
Page 689
-
Scan #114
Page 690
-
Scan #115
Page 691
-
Scan #116
Page 692
-
Scan #117
Page 693
-
Scan #118
Page 694
-
Scan #119
Page 695
-
Scan #120
Page 696
-
Scan #121
Page 697
-
Scan #122
Page 698
-
Scan #123
Page 699
-
Scan #124
Page 700
-
Scan #125
Page 701
-
Scan #126
Page 702
-
Scan #127
Page 703
-
Scan #128
Page 704
-
Scan #129
Page 705
-
Scan #130
Page 706
-
Scan #131
Page 707
-
Scan #132
Page 708
-
Scan #133
Page 709
-
Scan #134
Page 710
-
Scan #135
Page 711
-
Scan #136
Page 712
-
Scan #137
Page 713
-
Scan #138
Page 714
-
Scan #139
Page 715
-
Scan #140
Page 716
-
Scan #141
Page 717
-
Scan #142
Page 718
-
Scan #143
Page 719
-
Scan #144
Page 720
-
Scan #145
Page 721
-
Scan #146
Page 722
-
Scan #147
Page 723
-
Scan #148
Page 724
-
Scan #149
Page 725
-
Scan #150
Page 726
-
Scan #151
Page 727
-
Scan #152
Page 728
-
Scan #153
Page 729
-
Scan #154
Page 730
-
Scan #155
Page 731
-
Scan #156
Page 732
-
Scan #157
Page 733
-
Scan #158
Page 734
-
Scan #159
Page 735
-
Scan #160
Page 736
-
Scan #161
Page 737
-
Scan #162
Page 738
-
Scan #163
Page 739
-
Scan #164
Page 740
-
Scan #165
Page 741
-
Scan #166
Page 742
-
Scan #167
Page 743
-
Scan #168
Page 744
-
Scan #169
Page 745
-
Scan #170
Page 746
-
Scan #171
Page 747
-
Scan #172
Page 748
-
Scan #173
Page 749
-
Scan #174
Page 750
-
Scan #175
Page 751
-
Scan #176
Page 752
-
Scan #177
Page 753
-
Scan #178
Page 754
-
Scan #179
Page 755
-
Scan #180
Page 756
-
Scan #181
Page 757
-
Scan #182
Page 758
-
Scan #183
Page 759
-
Scan #184
Page 760
-
Scan #185
Page 761
-
Scan #186
Page 762
-
Scan #187
Page 763
-
Scan #188
Page 764
-
Scan #189
Page 765
-
Scan #190
Page 766
-
Scan #191
Page 767
-
Scan #192
Page 768
-
Scan #193
Page 769
-
Scan #194
Page 770
-
Scan #195
Page 771
-
Scan #196
Page 772
-
Scan #197
Page 773
-
Scan #198
Page 774
-
Scan #199
Page 775
-
Scan #200
Page 776
-
Scan #201
Page 777
-
Scan #202
Page 778
-
Scan #203
Page 779
-
Scan #204
Page 780
-
Scan #205
Page 781
-
Scan #206
Page 782
-
Scan #207
Page 783
-
Scan #208
Page 784
- The Logical Relations of Religion and Natural Science - pp. 577-608
- The Law of Spiritual Growth - Rev. W. E. Boardman - pp. 608-640
- Horace Binney's Pamphlets - Horace Binney - pp. 641-647
- Reason and Faith - Rev. James McCosh - pp. 648-685
- Napoleon III and the Papacy - pp. 686-702
- Theory of the Eldership - pp. 702-759
- Short Notices - pp. 759-784
Actions
About this Item
- Title
- Reason and Faith [pp. 648-685]
- Author
- McCosh, Rev. James
- Canvas
- Page 681
- Serial
- The Princeton review. / Volume 32, Issue 4
Technical Details
- Collection
- Making of America Journal Articles
- Link to this Item
-
https://name.umdl.umich.edu/acf4325.1-32.004
- Link to this scan
-
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/m/moajrnl/acf4325.1-32.004/689:4
Rights and Permissions
The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials are in the public domain in the United States. If you have questions about the collection, please contact Digital Content & Collections at [email protected]. If you have concerns about the inclusion of an item in this collection, please contact Library Information Technology at [email protected].
DPLA Rights Statement: No Copyright - United States
Related Links
IIIF
- Manifest
-
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/t/text/api/manifest/moajrnl:acf4325.1-32.004
Cite this Item
- Full citation
-
"Reason and Faith [pp. 648-685]." In the digital collection Making of America Journal Articles. https://name.umdl.umich.edu/acf4325.1-32.004. University of Michigan Library Digital Collections. Accessed June 21, 2025.