Duelling—Code of Honour [pp. 542-560]

The Princeton review. / Volume 20, Issue 4

Duelling. originated by sympathy; but on the impulse of principles which, original in themselves, originate the sympathy that we feel. When we see an unoffending individual subjected in his person to the wanton insult of a blow, oir in his property to the inroad of some ruthless depredation-we do not need to witness the resentment of his bosom, ere a like or a kindred feeling shall arise as by infection in our own; nor mentally to place ourselves inll his situation, and thus to ascertain how we should feel aggrieved or affronted by the treatment that we see him to experience. The circumstance of iio) being the sufferer myself may give a greater authority to my judgmentbecause a judgment unwarped by the passions or the partialities of selfishness; but still it is a judgment that comes forth without that process of internal manLufacture, of which Dr. Smith conceives it to be the resulting commodity. We judge as immediately and directly on a question of equity between one man and another, as we can onil a question of equality betw een onle line and another: And when that equity is violated, there is as instantaneous an emotion awakened in the heart of me the spectator, as there is in the heart of him the sufferer. With him it is anger. With me it is denonminated indignation-the one being the resentment of him who simply feels, that he has been disturbed or encroached upon the enjoyment of that which he hath habitually regarded to be his own; the other a resentment felt on perceiving a like encroachment on that which might equitably (i' ightfully be regarded as his own." The X. chapter on "Perfect and Imperfect Obligation," is properly a continuance of the same subject, and contains a number of original and discriminating remarks, worthy the attention of the reader. ART. III.-Duelting-Code of Honour. A duel is a combat with deadly weapons between two persons agreeably to previous arrangemients. It differs from a boxing match because in it no weapons are used. It differs from a rencounter, because that is a sudden combat without pre-meditation. The boxing match and rencounter may be as immnoral and as fatal in their consequences as the duel, but neither of them is a duel, neither of them, in our country at least, is regulated by the code of honour. There have been four kinds of duels in the world. The first was where two hostile armies agreed to select each a champion to meet and fight. Thus David and Goliah fought. Thus Diomedes and Xneas fought. The combat between the Hao 542 [OCTOBER,


Duelling. originated by sympathy; but on the impulse of principles which, original in themselves, originate the sympathy that we feel. When we see an unoffending individual subjected in his person to the wanton insult of a blow, oir in his property to the inroad of some ruthless depredation-we do not need to witness the resentment of his bosom, ere a like or a kindred feeling shall arise as by infection in our own; nor mentally to place ourselves inll his situation, and thus to ascertain how we should feel aggrieved or affronted by the treatment that we see him to experience. The circumstance of iio) being the sufferer myself may give a greater authority to my judgmentbecause a judgment unwarped by the passions or the partialities of selfishness; but still it is a judgment that comes forth without that process of internal manLufacture, of which Dr. Smith conceives it to be the resulting commodity. We judge as immediately and directly on a question of equity between one man and another, as we can onil a question of equality betw een onle line and another: And when that equity is violated, there is as instantaneous an emotion awakened in the heart of me the spectator, as there is in the heart of him the sufferer. With him it is anger. With me it is denonminated indignation-the one being the resentment of him who simply feels, that he has been disturbed or encroached upon the enjoyment of that which he hath habitually regarded to be his own; the other a resentment felt on perceiving a like encroachment on that which might equitably (i' ightfully be regarded as his own." The X. chapter on "Perfect and Imperfect Obligation," is properly a continuance of the same subject, and contains a number of original and discriminating remarks, worthy the attention of the reader. ART. III.-Duelting-Code of Honour. A duel is a combat with deadly weapons between two persons agreeably to previous arrangemients. It differs from a boxing match because in it no weapons are used. It differs from a rencounter, because that is a sudden combat without pre-meditation. The boxing match and rencounter may be as immnoral and as fatal in their consequences as the duel, but neither of them is a duel, neither of them, in our country at least, is regulated by the code of honour. There have been four kinds of duels in the world. The first was where two hostile armies agreed to select each a champion to meet and fight. Thus David and Goliah fought. Thus Diomedes and Xneas fought. The combat between the Hao 542 [OCTOBER,

/ 128
Pages Index

Actions

file_download Download Options Download this page PDF - Pages 535-544 Image - Page 542 Plain Text - Page 542

About this Item

Title
Duelling—Code of Honour [pp. 542-560]
Canvas
Page 542
Serial
The Princeton review. / Volume 20, Issue 4

Technical Details

Link to this Item
https://name.umdl.umich.edu/acf4325.1-20.004
Link to this scan
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/m/moajrnl/acf4325.1-20.004/558:3

Rights and Permissions

The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials are in the public domain in the United States. If you have questions about the collection, please contact Digital Content & Collections at [email protected]. If you have concerns about the inclusion of an item in this collection, please contact Library Information Technology at [email protected].

DPLA Rights Statement: No Copyright - United States

Manifest
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/t/text/api/manifest/moajrnl:acf4325.1-20.004

Cite this Item

Full citation
"Duelling—Code of Honour [pp. 542-560]." In the digital collection Making of America Journal Articles. https://name.umdl.umich.edu/acf4325.1-20.004. University of Michigan Library Digital Collections. Accessed June 22, 2025.
Do you have questions about this content? Need to report a problem? Please contact us.