1. A Brief Examination of the Proofs, by which the Rev. Mr. Boardman attempts to sustain his charge that "a large and learned body of the clergy of the church (of England) have returned to some of the worst errors of Popery"; with a word or two as to his attempt, without proof, to cast the suspicion of Popery on the Protestant Episcopal Church in the United States of America: By the Right Rev. George W. Doane, D.D, L.L.D., Bishop of New Jersey. Burlington. 1841. 2. A farther Postscript to Bishop Doane's Brief Examination of Rev. Mr. Boardman's Proofs: Touching Bishop Kenrick's Letter on Christian Union, pp. 230. [pp. 450-462]

The Princeton review. / Volume 13, Issue 3

450 Bis~op Boane and tAe O~~/~rd Tracts. [JULY keu, they do not hear. It seems a hopeless attempt to bring the facts to their knowledge. It is a matter too deep, and too wide, too great for their comprehension. After all, perhaps, no obstacle to the required reform is more in the way than the spirit of faction, because there is none which more absorbs and destroys every feeling of h~manity, and every sentiment of virtue. Every consideratioi~ but success sinks into insignificance before if; the warfare of party is so close, so incessant and so vigilant, that it leaves no time nor talent for any other conquest, nor can it yield a jot of its advantages for any benefit to those who have no power. How far any of these particulars may excuse the parties affected in foro conscienti~, or in the light of divine tr~th, it is not our province to decide. We m~~h fear that how ever stroi~g some of them may appear in human eyes, the time is coming, when they will be found of no avail. Even, humanly speal~ing, it appears impossible that men by any scheme of society, oY any plan of association, can evad~ re spoiisibility for a great wrong, for which, if committed in dividually, they would be held guilty. Surely those who have all the power, and make laws to suit themselves, cannot arrogate much merit for obeying tl~eir own behests, nor claim, on that account, exemption at that tribunal before which human laws will be as strictly Judged as human actions. ART. V. —i. ~ Brief EraminatThn of tAc Proofs, b~ whick ttte Rev. Air. Boardman attempts to sustain tLis cltarge that "a large and learned 6ody of tke ctergy of ttte churcJt (of En gland) ttave returned to some of the worst errors of Popery; with a word or two as to his attempt, wit/tout proof to cast the suspicThi~ of Poper~ on the Protestant Episcopal Ch~rch in the United States of ~merTha: By the Right Rev. George W. Doane, D.D., LL.D., Bishop of New Jersey. Burlington, 1841. 2.~farther Postscrzpt to Bishop Boa ne's Brief Exam ination of Rev. Mr. Boardman's Proofs: TouchThg Bishop Kenrick's Letter on Christian Union, pp. 230. COLEflIDGE tells us of a man who never spoke of himself without taking off his hat. This, though very absurd, is


450 Bis~op Boane and tAe O~~/~rd Tracts. [JULY keu, they do not hear. It seems a hopeless attempt to bring the facts to their knowledge. It is a matter too deep, and too wide, too great for their comprehension. After all, perhaps, no obstacle to the required reform is more in the way than the spirit of faction, because there is none which more absorbs and destroys every feeling of h~manity, and every sentiment of virtue. Every consideratioi~ but success sinks into insignificance before if; the warfare of party is so close, so incessant and so vigilant, that it leaves no time nor talent for any other conquest, nor can it yield a jot of its advantages for any benefit to those who have no power. How far any of these particulars may excuse the parties affected in foro conscienti~, or in the light of divine tr~th, it is not our province to decide. We m~~h fear that how ever stroi~g some of them may appear in human eyes, the time is coming, when they will be found of no avail. Even, humanly speal~ing, it appears impossible that men by any scheme of society, oY any plan of association, can evad~ re spoiisibility for a great wrong, for which, if committed in dividually, they would be held guilty. Surely those who have all the power, and make laws to suit themselves, cannot arrogate much merit for obeying tl~eir own behests, nor claim, on that account, exemption at that tribunal before which human laws will be as strictly Judged as human actions. ART. V. —i. ~ Brief EraminatThn of tAc Proofs, b~ whick ttte Rev. Air. Boardman attempts to sustain tLis cltarge that "a large and learned 6ody of tke ctergy of ttte churcJt (of En gland) ttave returned to some of the worst errors of Popery; with a word or two as to his attempt, wit/tout proof to cast the suspicThi~ of Poper~ on the Protestant Episcopal Ch~rch in the United States of ~merTha: By the Right Rev. George W. Doane, D.D., LL.D., Bishop of New Jersey. Burlington, 1841. 2.~farther Postscrzpt to Bishop Boa ne's Brief Exam ination of Rev. Mr. Boardman's Proofs: TouchThg Bishop Kenrick's Letter on Christian Union, pp. 230. COLEflIDGE tells us of a man who never spoke of himself without taking off his hat. This, though very absurd, is

/ 156
Pages Index

Actions

file_download Download Options Download this page PDF - Pages 445-454 Image - Page 450 Plain Text - Page 450

About this Item

Title
1. A Brief Examination of the Proofs, by which the Rev. Mr. Boardman attempts to sustain his charge that "a large and learned body of the clergy of the church (of England) have returned to some of the worst errors of Popery"; with a word or two as to his attempt, without proof, to cast the suspicion of Popery on the Protestant Episcopal Church in the United States of America: By the Right Rev. George W. Doane, D.D, L.L.D., Bishop of New Jersey. Burlington. 1841. 2. A farther Postscript to Bishop Doane's Brief Examination of Rev. Mr. Boardman's Proofs: Touching Bishop Kenrick's Letter on Christian Union, pp. 230. [pp. 450-462]
Canvas
Page 450
Serial
The Princeton review. / Volume 13, Issue 3

Technical Details

Link to this Item
https://name.umdl.umich.edu/acf4325.1-13.003
Link to this scan
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/m/moajrnl/acf4325.1-13.003/456:5

Rights and Permissions

The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials are in the public domain in the United States. If you have questions about the collection, please contact Digital Content & Collections at [email protected]. If you have concerns about the inclusion of an item in this collection, please contact Library Information Technology at [email protected].

DPLA Rights Statement: No Copyright - United States

Manifest
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/t/text/api/manifest/moajrnl:acf4325.1-13.003

Cite this Item

Full citation
"1. A Brief Examination of the Proofs, by which the Rev. Mr. Boardman attempts to sustain his charge that "a large and learned body of the clergy of the church (of England) have returned to some of the worst errors of Popery"; with a word or two as to his attempt, without proof, to cast the suspicion of Popery on the Protestant Episcopal Church in the United States of America: By the Right Rev. George W. Doane, D.D, L.L.D., Bishop of New Jersey. Burlington. 1841. 2. A farther Postscript to Bishop Doane's Brief Examination of Rev. Mr. Boardman's Proofs: Touching Bishop Kenrick's Letter on Christian Union, pp. 230. [pp. 450-462]." In the digital collection Making of America Journal Articles. https://name.umdl.umich.edu/acf4325.1-13.003. University of Michigan Library Digital Collections. Accessed June 21, 2025.
Do you have questions about this content? Need to report a problem? Please contact us.