189.] Manzoni. 587 single other extract will, it is hoped, justify its admission here: "Superficial education is an education to daily and deliberate falsehood. It is all pretence, and no reality, on the part of teacher and taught; each professing loudly to do, what each is conscious he is not accomplishing; so that the whole of the student's life, from year to year, is an habitual falsehood, a living lie; till truth and honor, religion, friendship, all that is most sacred in the relations and sensibilities of human life, degenerate into a sham. Hence an age of superficial knowledge, is necessarily an age of pretenders, quacks, hollow insincerity, frivolous scepticism, heartless formality; without depth, intensity, earnestness, heroism, faith. * * * Perhaps the briefest and surest recipe to make a sorry villain, at once a showy impostor and a shallow dupe, is to give him a superficial college education. Better learn to make shoes, well and truly, better for the intellect and the heart, better for himself and for others, than to mis-learn the whole circle of knowledge, classical, mathematical, philosophical."-p. 25. This Address seems richer than is usual with such performances, in fresh native thought. There are several other parts of it which it would be pleasant to exhibit and remark upon-especially that idea which seems to be the key-note, so to speak, of the author's system; the tendency of one thing well and truly learned, to spread its power, like leven, through the mind, when in turn it comes to learn other things. But we must forbear. The pamphlet itself, of twentynine pages, will richly repay the labor, or rather add profit to the pleasure of perusal. * MANZONI. BY H. T. TUCKERMAN. As I stood by the taflrail of the little steamer that plies up and down Lake Como, a good-na tured fellow-passenger, whose costume and bear ing denoted the experienced gentleman, indica ted the various points of interest along the beau tiful shores. It was a clear warm day of that enchanting season, in those climates, when spring is just verging into summer. The atmosphere was transparent and every indentation of the beach had a well-defined relief; the sails of the fishing-boats were reflected, in the water, as dis tinctly as if it were a mirror; and the cloudless sky wore the densely azure hue peculiar to that region. My companion urbanely pointed out every object worthy of note, which the shifting landscape afforded; here was the site of Pliny's country-seat, there the former residence of Queen Caroline of England, and now we are directly opposite the villa of Pasta; but there was a more genial animation in his look and voice, as a low promontory loomed in sight neither remarkable for the cultivation at its base. nor the picturesque beauty of its treeless slope; "just behind that ridge," said he, " is the road which Don Abbondio followed until he encountered the bravi who forbade him to marry the Promessi Sposi." The perfectly natural manner in which the locality of an imaginary scene was thus designated, as if quite as real and more interesting than the abodes of actual persons, struck me as the very best evidence of Manzoni's genius and fame. All genuine creations assert and maintain a distinct personality; and this is, perhaps, the readiest and most faithful test whereby the legitimate characters of fiction may be distinguished from the counterfeit. The most universal triumph of this kind is that of Shakespeare, of whose personages we habitually speak not only as actual, but worldfamiliar celebrities. It is probable that if the origin of those characters in fiction, which are recognised by the general feeling of mankind as living originals, could be analyzed, it would appear that their essential features were drawn carefully from life. The chief attraction of the novels of the reign of George the Third, is said to have been that the individuals depicted were wellknown at that period, and this fact gave a relish to the infirmities of character thus revealed. But a more recent instance occurs in regard to several of the best delineations of Dickens, whose Pecksniff, Squeers, brothers Cheerbyle and others are confidently identified; so that, even if there is an error in the designation, it only shows how nearly the author followed nature. Another convincing proof of the substantial relation to our experience, such daguerreotypes from life, bear, is the habit so prevalent of naming our ac quaintances from the well-drawn characters of able novelists. To realize the variety of fanci ful beings who have been added by modern ge nius to the world's vast gallery of memorable portraits, it is only requisite to summon before our minds, the long array of Scott's familiar cre ations. Charles Swain has done this in a poem entitled Dryburgh Abbey; and the obsequies of no human being were ever graced by so glorious an array of the representatives of human nature, acknowledged as such by the verdict of mankind, as this procession of his own "beings of the mind and not of clay," which are described as following Sir Walter to the tomb. An avidity for fabulous narrative seems to have characterized the oriental races. The indolent life of that dreamy clime naturally induced a ne cessity of being amused. Professed story-tellers were patronized by those in authority; and doubt 1819.] Manzoni. 587
Manzoni [pp. 587-593]
Southern literary messenger; devoted to every department of literature and the fine arts. / Volume 15, Issue 10
Annotations Tools
189.] Manzoni. 587 single other extract will, it is hoped, justify its admission here: "Superficial education is an education to daily and deliberate falsehood. It is all pretence, and no reality, on the part of teacher and taught; each professing loudly to do, what each is conscious he is not accomplishing; so that the whole of the student's life, from year to year, is an habitual falsehood, a living lie; till truth and honor, religion, friendship, all that is most sacred in the relations and sensibilities of human life, degenerate into a sham. Hence an age of superficial knowledge, is necessarily an age of pretenders, quacks, hollow insincerity, frivolous scepticism, heartless formality; without depth, intensity, earnestness, heroism, faith. * * * Perhaps the briefest and surest recipe to make a sorry villain, at once a showy impostor and a shallow dupe, is to give him a superficial college education. Better learn to make shoes, well and truly, better for the intellect and the heart, better for himself and for others, than to mis-learn the whole circle of knowledge, classical, mathematical, philosophical."-p. 25. This Address seems richer than is usual with such performances, in fresh native thought. There are several other parts of it which it would be pleasant to exhibit and remark upon-especially that idea which seems to be the key-note, so to speak, of the author's system; the tendency of one thing well and truly learned, to spread its power, like leven, through the mind, when in turn it comes to learn other things. But we must forbear. The pamphlet itself, of twentynine pages, will richly repay the labor, or rather add profit to the pleasure of perusal. * MANZONI. BY H. T. TUCKERMAN. As I stood by the taflrail of the little steamer that plies up and down Lake Como, a good-na tured fellow-passenger, whose costume and bear ing denoted the experienced gentleman, indica ted the various points of interest along the beau tiful shores. It was a clear warm day of that enchanting season, in those climates, when spring is just verging into summer. The atmosphere was transparent and every indentation of the beach had a well-defined relief; the sails of the fishing-boats were reflected, in the water, as dis tinctly as if it were a mirror; and the cloudless sky wore the densely azure hue peculiar to that region. My companion urbanely pointed out every object worthy of note, which the shifting landscape afforded; here was the site of Pliny's country-seat, there the former residence of Queen Caroline of England, and now we are directly opposite the villa of Pasta; but there was a more genial animation in his look and voice, as a low promontory loomed in sight neither remarkable for the cultivation at its base. nor the picturesque beauty of its treeless slope; "just behind that ridge," said he, " is the road which Don Abbondio followed until he encountered the bravi who forbade him to marry the Promessi Sposi." The perfectly natural manner in which the locality of an imaginary scene was thus designated, as if quite as real and more interesting than the abodes of actual persons, struck me as the very best evidence of Manzoni's genius and fame. All genuine creations assert and maintain a distinct personality; and this is, perhaps, the readiest and most faithful test whereby the legitimate characters of fiction may be distinguished from the counterfeit. The most universal triumph of this kind is that of Shakespeare, of whose personages we habitually speak not only as actual, but worldfamiliar celebrities. It is probable that if the origin of those characters in fiction, which are recognised by the general feeling of mankind as living originals, could be analyzed, it would appear that their essential features were drawn carefully from life. The chief attraction of the novels of the reign of George the Third, is said to have been that the individuals depicted were wellknown at that period, and this fact gave a relish to the infirmities of character thus revealed. But a more recent instance occurs in regard to several of the best delineations of Dickens, whose Pecksniff, Squeers, brothers Cheerbyle and others are confidently identified; so that, even if there is an error in the designation, it only shows how nearly the author followed nature. Another convincing proof of the substantial relation to our experience, such daguerreotypes from life, bear, is the habit so prevalent of naming our ac quaintances from the well-drawn characters of able novelists. To realize the variety of fanci ful beings who have been added by modern ge nius to the world's vast gallery of memorable portraits, it is only requisite to summon before our minds, the long array of Scott's familiar cre ations. Charles Swain has done this in a poem entitled Dryburgh Abbey; and the obsequies of no human being were ever graced by so glorious an array of the representatives of human nature, acknowledged as such by the verdict of mankind, as this procession of his own "beings of the mind and not of clay," which are described as following Sir Walter to the tomb. An avidity for fabulous narrative seems to have characterized the oriental races. The indolent life of that dreamy clime naturally induced a ne cessity of being amused. Professed story-tellers were patronized by those in authority; and doubt 1819.] Manzoni. 587
-
Scan #1
Page 521
-
Scan #2
Page 522
-
Scan #3
Page 523
-
Scan #4
Page 524
-
Scan #5
Page 525
-
Scan #6
Page 526
-
Scan #7
Page 527
-
Scan #8
Page 528
-
Scan #9
Page 529
-
Scan #10
Page 530
-
Scan #11
Page 531
-
Scan #12
Page 532
-
Scan #13
Page 533
-
Scan #14
Page 534
-
Scan #15
Page 535
-
Scan #16
Page 536
-
Scan #17
Page 537
-
Scan #18
Page 538
-
Scan #19
Page 539
-
Scan #20
Page 540
-
Scan #21
Page 541
-
Scan #22
Page 542
-
Scan #23
Page 543
-
Scan #24
Page 544
-
Scan #25
Page 545
-
Scan #26
Page 546
-
Scan #27
Page 547
-
Scan #28
Page 548
-
Scan #29
Page 549
-
Scan #30
Page 550
-
Scan #31
Page 551
-
Scan #32
Page 552
-
Scan #33
Page 553
-
Scan #34
Page 554
-
Scan #35
Page 555
-
Scan #36
Page 556
-
Scan #37
Page 557
-
Scan #38
Page 558
-
Scan #39
Page 559
-
Scan #40
Page 560
-
Scan #41
Page 561
-
Scan #42
Page 562
-
Scan #43
Page 563
-
Scan #44
Page 564
-
Scan #45
Page 565
-
Scan #46
Page 566
-
Scan #47
Page 567
-
Scan #48
Page 568
-
Scan #49
Page 569
-
Scan #50
Page 570
-
Scan #51
Page 571
-
Scan #52
Page 572
-
Scan #53
Page 573
-
Scan #54
Page 574
-
Scan #55
Page 575
-
Scan #56
Page 576
-
Scan #57
Page 577
-
Scan #58
Page 578
-
Scan #59
Page 579
-
Scan #60
Page 580
-
Scan #61
Page 581
-
Scan #62
Page 582
-
Scan #63
Page 583
-
Scan #64
Page 584
-
Scan #65
Page 585
-
Scan #66
Page 586
-
Scan #67
Page 587
-
Scan #68
Page 588
-
Scan #69
Page 589
-
Scan #70
Page 590
-
Scan #71
Page 591
-
Scan #72
Page 592
-
Scan #73
Page 593
-
Scan #74
Page 594
-
Scan #75
Page 595
-
Scan #76
Page 596
-
Scan #77
Page 597
-
Scan #78
Page 598
-
Scan #79
Page 599
-
Scan #80
Page 600
-
Scan #81
Page 601
-
Scan #82
Page 602
-
Scan #83
Page 603
-
Scan #84
Page 604
-
Scan #85
Page 605
-
Scan #86
Page 606
-
Scan #87
Page 607
-
Scan #88
Page 608
-
Scan #89
Page 609
-
Scan #90
Page 610
-
Scan #91
Page 611
-
Scan #92
Page 612
-
Scan #93
Page 613
-
Scan #94
Page 614
-
Scan #95
Page 615
-
Scan #96
Page 616
-
Scan #97
Page 617
-
Scan #98
Page 618
-
Scan #99
Page 619
-
Scan #100
Page 620
-
Scan #101
Page 621
-
Scan #102
Page 622
-
Scan #103
Page 623
-
Scan #104
Page 624
-
Scan #105
Page 625
-
Scan #106
Page 626
-
Scan #107
Page 627
-
Scan #108
Page 628
-
Scan #109
Page 629
-
Scan #110
Page 630
-
Scan #111
Page 631
-
Scan #112
Page 632
-
Scan #113
Page 633
-
Scan #114
Page 634
-
Scan #115
Page 635
-
Scan #116
Page 636
-
Scan #117
Page 637
-
Scan #118
Page 638
-
Scan #119
Page 639
-
Scan #120
Page 640
- Fremont's First and Second Expeditions (review) - Charles Campbell - pp. 521-529
- Lines Suggested by the Conversation with a Friend - Julia Mayo Cabell - pp. 529
- Lady Alice, or The New Una (review) - pp. 529-538
- Boyhood - Paul Hamilton Hayne - pp. 538-539
- The Tablet of the Theban Cebes - J. Jones Smyth - pp. 539-546
- Epigram - pp. 546
- The Instinct of Immortality - L. - pp. 547
- Rome: Papal and Republican - W. R. H. - pp. 547-551
- The Inch Cape Bell - C. C. L. - pp. 552
- Lays of the Scottish Cavaliers (review) - pp. 553-561
- National Lyrics: Battle of Bunker Hill - James W. Simmons - pp. 561-562
- Moore's Anacreon - pp. 562-568
- The Chevalier Merlin, Chapters X-XII - Philip Pendleton Cooke - pp. 569-578
- Maria Edgeworth - John Blair Dabney - pp. 578-585
- Dr. Green's Inaugural Address - pp. 585-587
- Manzoni - Henry Theodore Tuckerman - pp. 587-593
- Paris Correspondence - William W. Mann - pp. 593-600
- Marginalia, Part V - Edgar Allan Poe - pp. 600-601
- A Bachelor's Reverie - Ik Marvel - pp. 601-609
- Song - Paul Hamilton Hayne - pp. 609
- The Old Swan - pp. 609-611
- Sonnet - Elizabeth Jessup Eames - pp. 611
- The Seldens of Sherwood, Chapters VI-IX - Martha Fenton Hunter - pp. 612-622
- The Ode of Regner Lodborg - Mary Elizabeth Moore Hewitt - pp. 623
- A Plea for Art - B. - pp. 624-626
- Fredrick Jerome - William Ross Wallace - pp. 627-628
- Camp Life of the Hon. William Wirt - pp. 628-630
- To Miss Amelie Louise Rives on Her Departure from France - John Reuben Thompson - pp. 630
- What's in a Name? - pp. 630-632
- A Peep Into Futurity - pp. 632-634
- The Marseilles Hymn - J. E. Leigh [trans.] - pp. 634-635
- A Few Reflections on the Conquest of Mexico by Cortez - H. - pp. 635-637
- Notices of New Works - pp. 638-640
Actions
About this Item
- Title
- Manzoni [pp. 587-593]
- Author
- Tuckerman, Henry Theodore
- Canvas
- Page 587
- Serial
- Southern literary messenger; devoted to every department of literature and the fine arts. / Volume 15, Issue 10
Technical Details
- Collection
- Making of America Journal Articles
- Link to this Item
-
https://name.umdl.umich.edu/acf2679.0015.010
- Link to this scan
-
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/m/moajrnl/acf2679.0015.010/591:16
Rights and Permissions
The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials are in the public domain in the United States. If you have questions about the collection, please contact Digital Content & Collections at [email protected]. If you have concerns about the inclusion of an item in this collection, please contact Library Information Technology at [email protected].
DPLA Rights Statement: No Copyright - United States
Related Links
IIIF
- Manifest
-
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/t/text/api/manifest/moajrnl:acf2679.0015.010
Cite this Item
- Full citation
-
"Manzoni [pp. 587-593]." In the digital collection Making of America Journal Articles. https://name.umdl.umich.edu/acf2679.0015.010. University of Michigan Library Digital Collections. Accessed June 22, 2025.