The Lyceum, Part IV [pp. 764-766]

Southern literary messenger; devoted to every department of literature and the fine arts. / Volume 3, Issue 12

SOUTHERN LITERARY MESSENGER. sage be connected by a hyphen, and read as one noun substantive:-" so that the whole, as amended, will read thus," (as they say at the capitol,) "For goodness, growing to a plurisy, Dies in his own too-much." And now for our second "conjectural reading." When Laertes demands the cause of his father's death, at the hands of the villain King of Denmark, that monarch whets the filial rage of the young soldier against Hamlet, in a long and most admirable scene: at the close of which, addressing Laertes, he thus speaks: " And where the offence is, let the great axe fall." This line is weak, and unmeaning as it stands. By Warburton's aid, smiled on with cool approbation by Johnson, (that smile itself almost a frown,) we are let into the probable intention of the poet, in writing that passage. For "axe" read tax: a word used by Shakspeare, very frequently, in a similar connexion: e.g. Thus wisdom wishes to appear most bright When it doth tax itself. Afess. for Mess. II. 4. etc. etc. The "great axe" could never have been the doom of a king, so absolute as he of Denmark, of what crime soever he might have been guilty, and could not have been invoked by Claudius, as the proper punishment for the murder, of which Laertes suspected him. But there is a meaning, and a pregnant meaning in the line, when read as we now propose. The players at "The Globe Theatre," with the same contempt for the niceties of poetical diction, and the integ,rity of Priscian's head, as that which (characterizes their modern successors, probably read the line, (thus written by the Poet,) in the slovenly way in which it has come down to us, uncorrected, through so many editions. We may resume our remarks upon the Text of Shakspeare in a future number. J. F. 0. NEW ENGLAND MORALS. We of the South are usually, quite ready to admit, in general terms, the morality that prevails in New England; but we do so, sneeringly; and are apt to accompany the admission with a sarcasm, equally novel, elegant, and just, upon "the land of steady habits and vooden nutmegtts." Few of us are aware, that in that same land an integrity and a liberality may often be found, worthy of Virginia, even according to her own highest conceptions of herself. The English traveller, Dr. Reed, speaks thus of the people in the pleasant village of Northampton, Massachusetts: '* * * There are no criminals; the jail is often empty for three months together; and the judge passes on his way, having no delivery to make. A lady's veil was found lately on the high road. It was hung on the hedge by the wayside: it remained there all day, and, in fact, till the owner came and claimed it. "Their mnorality has a yet higher complexion. No small evidence is given of this in their treatment of the ministers of the mother church. They agree to their salary in common hall. Dr. P****'s, as the actual pastor, passes as a matter of course. But Mr. W******* has resigned his charge, and is wholly superannuated. Yet they do not say of him, He is a withered tree! No: they agree, as freely and without remark, to the salary hlie has always enjoyed. This I think noble, and the delicacy admirable. Yet these people are a plain people: who shall say they are not refined and elevated?" THE LYCEUM. No. IV. ON THIE PRACTICE OF APPLAUDING PUBLIC SPEAKERS. I was lately in a city of this Union, where the governor of the state, after having that day reviewed a large body of handsomely uniformed and well disciplined troops, was, at night, to deliver an Address before a Mechanics' Association. I made one of the multitude, that crowded the immense Church where the orator spoke. Various causes wound up my interest to a very high pitch.-The Association was one for the moral and intellectual improvement of a numerous and important class of our countrymen; an object high in the regards of all who hope for the permanence of our republican institutions. The speaker was, by general admission, unrivallcd in set oratory, among living Americans — whether we look to grace in delivery, or to beauty and force of composition. He wvas the governor of a GREAT state (for "The MIND'S the measure of the man"); and here, doffing the robes of civil office as well as the gaudier finery of military parade, he, as a plain citizen, was to address an humble Mechanics' Association upon 'the importance of the mechanic arts to civilization, and to happiness.' The vastness of the throng, the newness of the people to me, and their being reputed to have some striking peculiarities,-raised my curiosity on tiptoe, to see how they could appreciate what fell from one of the most accomplished scholars on this continent. And I was equally curious to see, how he would contrive, without descending firom the dignity of learning or fi-om his habitual elegance of style, to make himself understood and relished by such an assembly; and by what mode of operation he would work out the design of his address-namely, to impress mechanics with such a self-respect, as might elevate their conduct and characters, and impress all others with a just and salutary respect for mechanical pursuits. The Address was, in most respects, happy beyond my expectations. But what was my surprise, to find every very fine passage followed by thunders of applause, from a large part of the audience!-hands clappilng —canes, feet, umbrellas, rattling upon the floor! — The sobriety of the people-their puritan descentthe supposed character of the speaker —the (supposed) sacredness of the place-had all been, to my mind, infallible guarantees against the appearance there of a practice at nearly all times indecorous and irrational, 764


SOUTHERN LITERARY MESSENGER. sage be connected by a hyphen, and read as one noun substantive:-" so that the whole, as amended, will read thus," (as they say at the capitol,) "For goodness, growing to a plurisy, Dies in his own too-much." And now for our second "conjectural reading." When Laertes demands the cause of his father's death, at the hands of the villain King of Denmark, that monarch whets the filial rage of the young soldier against Hamlet, in a long and most admirable scene: at the close of which, addressing Laertes, he thus speaks: " And where the offence is, let the great axe fall." This line is weak, and unmeaning as it stands. By Warburton's aid, smiled on with cool approbation by Johnson, (that smile itself almost a frown,) we are let into the probable intention of the poet, in writing that passage. For "axe" read tax: a word used by Shakspeare, very frequently, in a similar connexion: e.g. Thus wisdom wishes to appear most bright When it doth tax itself. Afess. for Mess. II. 4. etc. etc. The "great axe" could never have been the doom of a king, so absolute as he of Denmark, of what crime soever he might have been guilty, and could not have been invoked by Claudius, as the proper punishment for the murder, of which Laertes suspected him. But there is a meaning, and a pregnant meaning in the line, when read as we now propose. The players at "The Globe Theatre," with the same contempt for the niceties of poetical diction, and the integ,rity of Priscian's head, as that which (characterizes their modern successors, probably read the line, (thus written by the Poet,) in the slovenly way in which it has come down to us, uncorrected, through so many editions. We may resume our remarks upon the Text of Shakspeare in a future number. J. F. 0. NEW ENGLAND MORALS. We of the South are usually, quite ready to admit, in general terms, the morality that prevails in New England; but we do so, sneeringly; and are apt to accompany the admission with a sarcasm, equally novel, elegant, and just, upon "the land of steady habits and vooden nutmegtts." Few of us are aware, that in that same land an integrity and a liberality may often be found, worthy of Virginia, even according to her own highest conceptions of herself. The English traveller, Dr. Reed, speaks thus of the people in the pleasant village of Northampton, Massachusetts: '* * * There are no criminals; the jail is often empty for three months together; and the judge passes on his way, having no delivery to make. A lady's veil was found lately on the high road. It was hung on the hedge by the wayside: it remained there all day, and, in fact, till the owner came and claimed it. "Their mnorality has a yet higher complexion. No small evidence is given of this in their treatment of the ministers of the mother church. They agree to their salary in common hall. Dr. P****'s, as the actual pastor, passes as a matter of course. But Mr. W******* has resigned his charge, and is wholly superannuated. Yet they do not say of him, He is a withered tree! No: they agree, as freely and without remark, to the salary hlie has always enjoyed. This I think noble, and the delicacy admirable. Yet these people are a plain people: who shall say they are not refined and elevated?" THE LYCEUM. No. IV. ON THIE PRACTICE OF APPLAUDING PUBLIC SPEAKERS. I was lately in a city of this Union, where the governor of the state, after having that day reviewed a large body of handsomely uniformed and well disciplined troops, was, at night, to deliver an Address before a Mechanics' Association. I made one of the multitude, that crowded the immense Church where the orator spoke. Various causes wound up my interest to a very high pitch.-The Association was one for the moral and intellectual improvement of a numerous and important class of our countrymen; an object high in the regards of all who hope for the permanence of our republican institutions. The speaker was, by general admission, unrivallcd in set oratory, among living Americans — whether we look to grace in delivery, or to beauty and force of composition. He wvas the governor of a GREAT state (for "The MIND'S the measure of the man"); and here, doffing the robes of civil office as well as the gaudier finery of military parade, he, as a plain citizen, was to address an humble Mechanics' Association upon 'the importance of the mechanic arts to civilization, and to happiness.' The vastness of the throng, the newness of the people to me, and their being reputed to have some striking peculiarities,-raised my curiosity on tiptoe, to see how they could appreciate what fell from one of the most accomplished scholars on this continent. And I was equally curious to see, how he would contrive, without descending firom the dignity of learning or fi-om his habitual elegance of style, to make himself understood and relished by such an assembly; and by what mode of operation he would work out the design of his address-namely, to impress mechanics with such a self-respect, as might elevate their conduct and characters, and impress all others with a just and salutary respect for mechanical pursuits. The Address was, in most respects, happy beyond my expectations. But what was my surprise, to find every very fine passage followed by thunders of applause, from a large part of the audience!-hands clappilng —canes, feet, umbrellas, rattling upon the floor! — The sobriety of the people-their puritan descentthe supposed character of the speaker —the (supposed) sacredness of the place-had all been, to my mind, infallible guarantees against the appearance there of a practice at nearly all times indecorous and irrational, 764


SOUTHERN LITERARY MESSENGER. sage be connected by a hyphen, and read as one noun substantive:-" so that the whole, as amended, will read thus," (as they say at the capitol,) "For goodness, growing to a plurisy, Dies in his own too-much." And now for our second "conjectural reading." When Laertes demands the cause of his father's death, at the hands of the villain King of Denmark, that monarch whets the filial rage of the young soldier against Hamlet, in a long and most admirable scene: at the close of which, addressing Laertes, he thus speaks: " And where the offence is, let the great axe fall." This line is weak, and unmeaning as it stands. By Warburton's aid, smiled on with cool approbation by Johnson, (that smile itself almost a frown,) we are let into the probable intention of the poet, in writing that passage. For "axe" read tax: a word used by Shakspeare, very frequently, in a similar connexion: e.g. Thus wisdom wishes to appear most bright When it doth tax itself. Afess. for Mess. II. 4. etc. etc. The "great axe" could never have been the doom of a king, so absolute as he of Denmark, of what crime soever he might have been guilty, and could not have been invoked by Claudius, as the proper punishment for the murder, of which Laertes suspected him. But there is a meaning, and a pregnant meaning in the line, when read as we now propose. The players at "The Globe Theatre," with the same contempt for the niceties of poetical diction, and the integ,rity of Priscian's head, as that which (characterizes their modern successors, probably read the line, (thus written by the Poet,) in the slovenly way in which it has come down to us, uncorrected, through so many editions. We may resume our remarks upon the Text of Shakspeare in a future number. J. F. 0. NEW ENGLAND MORALS. We of the South are usually, quite ready to admit, in general terms, the morality that prevails in New England; but we do so, sneeringly; and are apt to accompany the admission with a sarcasm, equally novel, elegant, and just, upon "the land of steady habits and vooden nutmegtts." Few of us are aware, that in that same land an integrity and a liberality may often be found, worthy of Virginia, even according to her own highest conceptions of herself. The English traveller, Dr. Reed, speaks thus of the people in the pleasant village of Northampton, Massachusetts: '* * * There are no criminals; the jail is often empty for three months together; and the judge passes on his way, having no delivery to make. A lady's veil was found lately on the high road. It was hung on the hedge by the wayside: it remained there all day, and, in fact, till the owner came and claimed it. "Their mnorality has a yet higher complexion. No small evidence is given of this in their treatment of the ministers of the mother church. They agree to their salary in common hall. Dr. P****'s, as the actual pastor, passes as a matter of course. But Mr. W******* has resigned his charge, and is wholly superannuated. Yet they do not say of him, He is a withered tree! No: they agree, as freely and without remark, to the salary hlie has always enjoyed. This I think noble, and the delicacy admirable. Yet these people are a plain people: who shall say they are not refined and elevated?" THE LYCEUM. No. IV. ON THIE PRACTICE OF APPLAUDING PUBLIC SPEAKERS. I was lately in a city of this Union, where the governor of the state, after having that day reviewed a large body of handsomely uniformed and well disciplined troops, was, at night, to deliver an Address before a Mechanics' Association. I made one of the multitude, that crowded the immense Church where the orator spoke. Various causes wound up my interest to a very high pitch.-The Association was one for the moral and intellectual improvement of a numerous and important class of our countrymen; an object high in the regards of all who hope for the permanence of our republican institutions. The speaker was, by general admission, unrivallcd in set oratory, among living Americans — whether we look to grace in delivery, or to beauty and force of composition. He wvas the governor of a GREAT state (for "The MIND'S the measure of the man"); and here, doffing the robes of civil office as well as the gaudier finery of military parade, he, as a plain citizen, was to address an humble Mechanics' Association upon 'the importance of the mechanic arts to civilization, and to happiness.' The vastness of the throng, the newness of the people to me, and their being reputed to have some striking peculiarities,-raised my curiosity on tiptoe, to see how they could appreciate what fell from one of the most accomplished scholars on this continent. And I was equally curious to see, how he would contrive, without descending firom the dignity of learning or fi-om his habitual elegance of style, to make himself understood and relished by such an assembly; and by what mode of operation he would work out the design of his address-namely, to impress mechanics with such a self-respect, as might elevate their conduct and characters, and impress all others with a just and salutary respect for mechanical pursuits. The Address was, in most respects, happy beyond my expectations. But what was my surprise, to find every very fine passage followed by thunders of applause, from a large part of the audience!-hands clappilng —canes, feet, umbrellas, rattling upon the floor! — The sobriety of the people-their puritan descentthe supposed character of the speaker —the (supposed) sacredness of the place-had all been, to my mind, infallible guarantees against the appearance there of a practice at nearly all times indecorous and irrational, 764

/ 66
Pages Index

Actions

file_download Download Options Download this page PDF - Pages A755-A764 Image - Page A764 Plain Text - Page A764

About this Item

Title
The Lyceum, Part IV [pp. 764-766]
Author
M.
Canvas
Page A764
Serial
Southern literary messenger; devoted to every department of literature and the fine arts. / Volume 3, Issue 12

Technical Details

Link to this Item
https://name.umdl.umich.edu/acf2679.0003.012
Link to this scan
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/m/moajrnl/acf2679.0003.012/772

Rights and Permissions

The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials are in the public domain in the United States. If you have questions about the collection, please contact Digital Content & Collections at [email protected]. If you have concerns about the inclusion of an item in this collection, please contact Library Information Technology at [email protected].

DPLA Rights Statement: No Copyright - United States

Manifest
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/t/text/api/manifest/moajrnl:acf2679.0003.012

Cite this Item

Full citation
"The Lyceum, Part IV [pp. 764-766]." In the digital collection Making of America Journal Articles. https://name.umdl.umich.edu/acf2679.0003.012. University of Michigan Library Digital Collections. Accessed June 22, 2025.
Do you have questions about this content? Need to report a problem? Please contact us.