SOUTHERN LITERARY MESSENGER. they adopt an entirely different course from the most common one, and pursue it, both with body and soul. They must learn to consider children-not as machines and spinning tops, to be governed by whips, cords, springs, pullies and levers-not as mere living animals, incapable of any other impulse than fear or ambition, but as rational beings, made after God's own image, and gifted by him with immortal souls, whose appropriate regulators are the high, celestial, ever glorious attributes of reason, judgment, and understanding-all which are to be kept in continual exercise by the ardent love of truth, wisdom, knowledge, and virtue. The faults of children will all continue to grow with their growth, and strengthen with their strength; nay, they will live and die with them, as surely as that death itself will come to them all, unless their treatment in all future time, be made to conform, from the nursery even unto the college, to the principles just stated. This is not said in any spirit of presumptuous dictation; for neither is the principle itself any discovery of my own, nor have there been wanting many writers of great ability and experience in teaching, to recommend it most earnestly and zealously. But it is a thing of such deep and universal importance to the happinessnot only of the present generation, but to that of millions yet unborn, that it cannot be too frequently insisted upon-especially while so many parents and teachers are to be found, who appear almost entirely to disregard it. If this were not strictly true, could we possibly find either so many private families or schools as we do find, wherein it is manifest, that unpolished manners and awkwardness of person appear to be infinitely more dreaded, than deformities of mind or diseases of temper; where external attractions are evidently prized far above all intellectual acquirements, and where children in fact are educated much more assiduously for all the purposes of the present life, than for any of that everlasting life which is to come? Having now finished the particular examination of the faults and vices most common among parents, teachers and scholars, which form the mass of obstacles to education, there are many general reflections that suggest themselves as proper to be stated-so many indeed, that the present lecture cannot embrace them all, without trespassing too far on your time. A few of them however, I beg leave to present on the present occasion. To describe in general terms all the hindrances heretofore attributed to the three great classes who establish, fill, and regulate schools, we may say, that there is not, in the first place, sufficient care, either in the selection of suitable means, nor subsequently, in regard to the best means of applying them. Parents themselves are too often badly educated, or not at all. They are too frequently incompetent, either from sheer ignorance —from defects in temper and principle-or from utter blindness to their children's faults, to direct in the great business of their education. Teachers are much too often suffered to decide on their own qualifications, and are encouraged to proceed in the vital undertaking, without any thing like an examination into their fitness by competent judges. Scholars too, are not unfrequent]y suffered to choose for themselves, not only what, but where, and how they shall learn, as well as to decide on the time to be devoted to scholastic pursuits; although it is most manifest, on a moment's reflection, that none are competent to form a correct judgment on all these important points, but those who have already received a liberal education, and have some experience in the ways of the world, as well as knowledge of the various advantages and disadvantages of its chief callings, trades and professions. Upon the prevalent let-alone-plan, boys and girls are often left to do, as their immature judgments may direct, what their criminally neglectful fathers and mothers ought to do for them; and an inverse order of proceeding is thus established, which cannot possibly end in any thing but "confusion worse confounded." A still more fatal error than this transfer of the right and duty of judging for their children to the children themselves is, that the religious principles (I do not mean sectarian opinions,) of their teachers are rarely ever made a subject of inquiry, much less of anxious solicitude. They may be heathens, or confirmed infidels, for aught that is known or cared about them; neither is any concern felt or taken to know what particular provision is made in schools for the moral and religious instruction of the many thousand children, who are there to form their principles of conduct for all future time. Yet, if the question were asked, whether any thing in the whole circle of sciences and the arts, be at all comparable in importance with these principles, a negative answer would assuredly be given, even by the most careless of all those persons who have the control of the whole subject of education in all its parts. That the peace, comfort, prosperity, and happiness of all orders in society, depend upon the soundness of their moral and religious principles, none, I believe, will be either so foolish or wicked as to deny. And yet, where shall we find the schools in which the acquisition of knowledge in various other matters, such as physical science, foreign languages, and what are called polite accomplishments, is not made the chief, if not the sole object of pursuit? The great springs of all human action-the powerful regulators of all human conduct-such as it ought to be, are either not thought of at all, or it is taken for granted that the whole have been so carefully adjusted while the poor children were taking pap in their nurseries, or conning over their alphabet, while under their good mother's supervision, as to require no farther care. When we consider well the nature, tendency, and general prevalence of the faults which I have enumerated among all the parties concerned in the great business of education, together with the errors so commonly committed in regard to its chief ends and purposes, or rather in the choice of means for their attainment, and then endeavor to measure the destructive power of their combined influence, the contemplation is truly appalling. It is in vain to turn our eyes to the bright region of science and the arts, displaying all their glories, and diffusing their innumerable blessings over the whole face of our happy country. None can rejoice in such a delightful prospect, nor give nmore heartfelt thanks to God for it, than I do. But alas! I cannot always avoid the sight of the dark, portentous, and terrific clouds of vice and crime which always obscure, in some direction or other, and often threaten to destroy this heavenly view. I cannot avoid asking myself why these things should be; nor have I the power to shut the eyes of my understanding against the soul-sickening VOL. II-72 565
Fourth Lecture [pp. 561-568]
Southern literary messenger; devoted to every department of literature and the fine arts. / Volume 2, Issue 9
-
Scan #1
Page A525
-
Scan #2
Page A526
-
Scan #3
Page A527
-
Scan #4
Page A528
-
Scan #5
Page A529
-
Scan #6
Page A530
-
Scan #7
Page A531
-
Scan #8
Page A532
-
Scan #9
Page A533
-
Scan #10
Page A534
-
Scan #11
Page A535
-
Scan #12
Page A536
-
Scan #13
Page A537
-
Scan #14
Page A538
-
Scan #15
Page A539
-
Scan #16
Page A540
-
Scan #17
Page A541
-
Scan #18
Page A542
-
Scan #19
Page A543
-
Scan #20
Page A544
-
Scan #21
Page A545
-
Scan #22
Page A546
-
Scan #23
Page A547
-
Scan #24
Page A548
-
Scan #25
Page A549
-
Scan #26
Page A550
-
Scan #27
Page A551
-
Scan #28
Page A552
-
Scan #29
Page A553
-
Scan #30
Page A554
-
Scan #31
Page A555
-
Scan #32
Page A556
-
Scan #33
Page A557
-
Scan #34
Page A558
-
Scan #35
Page A559
-
Scan #36
Page A560
-
Scan #37
Page A561
-
Scan #38
Page A562
-
Scan #39
Page A563
-
Scan #40
Page A564
-
Scan #41
Page A565
-
Scan #42
Page A566
-
Scan #43
Page A567
-
Scan #44
Page A568
-
Scan #45
Page A569
-
Scan #46
Page A570
-
Scan #47
Page A571
-
Scan #48
Page A572
-
Scan #49
Page A573
-
Scan #50
Page A574
-
Scan #51
Page A575
-
Scan #52
Page A576
-
Scan #53
Page A577
-
Scan #54
Page A578
-
Scan #55
Page A579
-
Scan #56
Page A580
-
Scan #57
Page A581
-
Scan #58
Page A582
-
Scan #59
Page A583
-
Scan #60
Page A584
-
Scan #61
Page A585
-
Scan #62
Page A586
-
Scan #63
Page A587
-
Scan #64
Page A588
-
Scan #65
Page A589
-
Scan #66
Page A590
-
Scan #67
Page A591
-
Scan #68
Page A592
-
Scan #69
Page A593
-
Scan #70
Page A594
-
Scan #71
Page A595
-
Scan #72
Page A596
-
Scan #73
Page A597
-
Scan #74
Page A598
-
Scan #75
Page A599
-
Scan #76
Page A600
-
Scan #77
Page A601
-
Scan #78
Page A602
-
Scan #79
Page A603
-
Scan #80
Page A604
- The Ruler's Faith - Lydia Howard Huntley Sigourney [Signed] - pp. 525
- Sketches of the History and Present Condition of Tripoli, No. XI - Robert Greenhow [Unsigned] - pp. 525-530
- Stanzas - William Gilmore Simms [Signed] - pp. 530
- The Right of Instruction - Judge Joseph Hopkinson [Signed] - pp. 530-535
- To— - William Gilmore Simms [Signed] - pp. 535
- A Reminiscence - Dr. Francis Lieber - pp. 535-538
- The Old Man's Carousel - James Kirke Paulding [Signed] - pp. 538
- Piscatory Reminiscences - pp. 538-539
- Israfel - Edgar Allan Poe [Signed] - pp. 539
- Judgment of Rhadamanthus - James Kirke Paulding [Signed] - pp. 539-540
- Scenes in Campillo - Lieutenant A. Slidell [Signed] - pp. 540-541
- The Pine Wood—A Song Written in Georgia - Robert Montgomery Bird - pp. 541
- The Battle of Lodi - Major Henry Lee - pp. 541-545
- Marcus Curtius - Omega - pp. 545-546
- British Parliament in 1835, No. II - pp. 547-549
- To a Tortoise Shell Comb - Elizabeth Fries Lummis Ellet [Signed] - pp. 549
- Influence of Names - H - pp. 549-552
- The City of Sin - Edgar Allan Poe [Unsigned] - pp. 552
- A Hint: Touching the Greek Drama - James Waddell Alexander, Signed Borealis - pp. 552-554
- Sacred Song - William Maxwell [Signed] - pp. 554
- A Tour of the Isthmus - A Yankee Dauber - pp. 554-557
- Lines - Philip Pendleton Cooke, Signed P. P. Cooke - pp. 557
- The Learned Languages - Mathew Carey [Signed] - pp. 557-561
- Fourth Lecture - James Mercer Garnett - pp. 561-568
- A Case not to be Found in any of the Books - pp. 568
- MSS. of John Randolph, Letter IV - Nathaniel Beverley Tucker [Unsigned] - pp. 568-571
- A Polite Struggle - pp. 571
- A Profession for Ladies - Mrs. Sarah Josepha Buell Hale [Signed] - pp. 571-572
- Right of Instruction - pp. 573
- Pinakidia - Edgar Allan Poe [Unsigned] - pp. 573-582
- Critical Notices - pp. 582-600
- Autography - Edgar Allan Poe [Unsigned] - pp. 601-604
Actions
About this Item
- Title
- Fourth Lecture [pp. 561-568]
- Author
- Garnett, James Mercer
- Canvas
- Page A565
- Serial
- Southern literary messenger; devoted to every department of literature and the fine arts. / Volume 2, Issue 9
Technical Details
- Collection
- Making of America Journal Articles
- Link to this Item
-
https://name.umdl.umich.edu/acf2679.0002.009
- Link to this scan
-
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/m/moajrnl/acf2679.0002.009/571:24
Rights and Permissions
The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials are in the public domain in the United States. If you have questions about the collection, please contact Digital Content & Collections at [email protected]. If you have concerns about the inclusion of an item in this collection, please contact Library Information Technology at [email protected].
DPLA Rights Statement: No Copyright - United States
Related Links
IIIF
- Manifest
-
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/t/text/api/manifest/moajrnl:acf2679.0002.009
Cite this Item
- Full citation
-
"Fourth Lecture [pp. 561-568]." In the digital collection Making of America Journal Articles. https://name.umdl.umich.edu/acf2679.0002.009. University of Michigan Library Digital Collections. Accessed June 21, 2025.