ï~~VOLUME 71
NUMBER 15
GAUZE MASKS-HAL.
empyema showed, in this survey, a high incidence of
diphtheria. From these facts one must conclude that,
as has already been shown by others, a man from a
rural community is not as great an asset to his organization in the early part of his military career as is an
urban individual.
CONCLUSIONS
1. A single negative culture is only of relative value,
as is shown by the fact that preoperative cultures,
taken from tonsils that later proved positive for diphtheria, were negative in 22.8 per cent. of the cases.
2. The importance of nasal cultures is shown by the
fact that in routine cultures taken from carriers, 26 per
cent. were positive from the nose.
3. Cultures from, chronic carriers should be tested
for virulence.
4. The carrier state is maintained by some underlying pathologic condition of the affected tissues.
5. In the great majority of cases the carriers harbor
the bacilli in the tonsils; a few carry the germs in the
nose only; a small group maintains the infection in
both nose and tonsils.
6. Conclusions based on the results of local
treatment should be founded on careful and prolonged
bacteriologic study. Cultures should be taken immediately before treatment, or, if local treatment is being
TABLE 2.-OCCURRENCE OF DIPHTHERIA BY ORGANIZATIONS
Organization
Source
137th Infantry...............Rural..........
138th Infantry................Urban.........
139th Infantry................Rural..........
140th Infantry................Rural and nrban..
128th Field Artillery............Urban.........
129th Field Artillery............ Rural and urban..
130th Field Artillery............ Rural....
128th Machine Gun Battalion.....Rural..........
129th Machine Gun Battalian. Rural..........
130th Machine Gun Battalion.......Rural..........
110th Engineers.............R.ural and urban.
110th Sanitary Train...........Rural.......
110th Ammunition Train............Rural and urban..
110th Military Police...........Rural..............
110th Supply Train.............Urban..........
110th Field Signal Battalion. Rural..........
110th Trceh Mortar Battalion..Rural..........
Base Hospital.................Rural and urban..
Quartermaster................Rural and urban...
Miscellaneous..................Rural and urban..
Carriers
Pee Cent.
6.7
J.7
9.2.3
2.7
1.3
2.3
3.0
4.1
1.0
0.4
16.7
3.2
2.3
Cases
Per Cent.
24.2
6.c
13.9
9.3
1.8
4.6
3.9
1.8
0.4
1.7
4.9
3.111
2.8
3.2
1.1
1.3
0.0
10.6.
2.1
2.2
LER AND COLWELL 1213
13. Toxin for the Schick test should be prepared
fresh, and no diluted toxin should be used after twentyfour hours. The undiluted toxin should be kept in
the dark and in a refrigerator.
14. Intermittent chronic carriers should be employed
as attendants in diphtheria wards or in quarantine
camps. They should be separated from the hospital
personnel and from their organizations.
15. Diphtheria patients may be discharged from the
hospital after they have had at least three negative cultures at three-day intervals. Chronic carriers should
not be discharged until cultures taken over a long
period of time prove consistently negative.
We take this opportunity of expressing our appreciation for
the cooperation accorded us during this study to the following members of the staff of the base hospital: Major A. C.
Magruder, Capts. W. B. Post, E. E. Hopkins, A. W. Cox, H. E.
Blanchard, R. Appleberry and A. E. Edgerton, Lieut. F. H.
Thorne, Miss Marjorie Bates, Miss Dorothy Loomis, and Pvt.,
First Class, Stephens Moore.
THE PROTECTIVE QUALITIES OF THE
GAUZE FACE MASK
EXPERIMENTAL STUDIES
DAVID A. HALLER, M.D. (POCAHONTAS, VA.)
Major, M. R. C., U. S. Army
AND
RAYMOND C. COLWELL
First Lieutenant, S. C., N. A.
CAMP GRANT, ROCKFORD, ILL.
The use of the face mask by surgeons and their
assistants to protect clean operative fields which they
otherwise would spray with their own mouth organisms at every cough or sneeze is an old and well
established procedure. The utilization of the face
mask to protect the wearer from droplet infection
in the presence of those ill with acute infectious diseases is likewise now a well established custom owing
in large part to the careful studies at the Durand
Hospital in Chicago. Weaver' has shown its efficacy
when used in this institution in protecting attendants
on infectious disease cases both from contracting these
diseases and from becoming carriers of them. Capps2
has published statistics tending to confirm the work
of Weaver and has proposed a new adaptation for the
face mask, the essential idea being to use this mask
to protect patients from cross-infection in the ambulances, and in the admission rooms and wards of the
hospital. The clinical results of this adaptation of the
face mask were described by Capps3 recently.
The work described in this paper was carried out
for several reasons. The masks used at this hospital
have come from several different sources. Masks
found in use in the various wards on the same day
showed extreme variation in the number of layers of
gauze. Some were made with only three layers, and
were obviously too thin. Others were made with eight
layers, and these were quite hard to breathe through;
also they were very warm and uncomfortable. The
gauze of which the masks were made varied in quality,
1. weaver, G. H.: The Value of the Face Mask and Other
Measures, THE JOURNAL A. M. A., Jan. 12, 1918, p. 26.
2. Capps, J. A.: A New Adaptation of the Fase Mask in Control of
Contagious Diseases, THE JOURNAL A. M. A., March 30, 1918, p. 910.
3. Capps, J. A.: Measures for the Prevention and Control of Respiratory Infeetions in Military Camps, THE JOURNAL A. M. A., Aug. 10,
1918, p. 448.
administered, this should be suspended for a number
of days before cultures are taken. The results of local
treatment are problematical, since the organisms are
situated deeply in the tissues.
7. In persistent carriers in whom the' focus of infection is the tonsil, enucleation offers the *only certain
procedure for terminating the carrier state.
8. The most persistent nasal carriers are those in
whom chronic inflammatory or atrophic processes are
found. It is almost impossible, in view of the varying
culture returns, to state when the condition has finally
cleared.
90 Centralization of authority is necessary for the
control of an epidemic of diphtheria and diphtheria
carriers in camp. Release of patients from quarantine
should be under the supervision of the laboratory.
10. During 'an epidemic, patients should not be
admitted to a clean ward unless they have had at least
two successive negative cultures from the nose and
throat.
11. Improperly constructed and improperly worn
masks give a sense of false security.
12. The hospital personnel should be given a Schick
test, and those giving a positive reaction should be
immunized with toxin-antitoxin mixture.