So Chrysost. Aliud est concupiscere, aliud velle.
Saint Bern. doth distinguish our Cogitations thus.
1. Sunt Cogitationes otiosae, idle thoughts, & ad rem non per∣tinentes: these he calleth Lutum simplex, that is, a thinne clay which cleaveth not, yet it coloureth.
2. Sunt Cogitationes violentae & fortius adhaerentes, violent and faster cleaving thoughts. These he calleth Lutum viscosum, a viscous clay, stick-fast;
3. Sunt Cogitationes faetidae, Filthy thoughts, quae ad luxuriam; invidiam avaritiam &c. pertinet, which belong to luxury, &c. Coe∣lum immundum, foul mud.
The first of these cogitationes & motus primi, may be either in phantasie only, so they defile not: or in voluntate, in the will; a little infecting that, so they break the law.
St. Chrysost. Si concupiscentiae non consentit voluntas, sola concu∣piscentia non condemnat, if the Will consenteth not, the Concupis∣cence condemns not.
I dare not embrace his judgement Saint Paul found by the law, and he could find it by no law but this of the tenth Com∣mandement that Concupiscentia est peccatum, Concupiscence is sin.
This is part of the misery of our fall from God, we cannot think a good thought of our selves.
4. Sins of evil-affection.
The spirit doth detect this further misery, when the consent of the will, and the bent of desire doth affect evil; in which kind our Saviour the best interpreter of the Law, doth call anger mur∣ther, and unchast desires adultery, and desires of our neighbours goods theft;
These are not only sins in proventu ex corde, but in corde, as Christ saith, out of the heart cometh murther, adultery, theft.
5. Sins of evil action.
These are evil praevarications, and actual transgressions of the law, such as the erecting of another God against the true God, worshipping of idols, Swearing and blasphemy, Breach of the Sabbath in the first table of the law.
Disobedience to authority, murther, adultery, theft, false witnesse in the second Table.
They that do these things have not God in their ways: Haec sunt quae polluunt hominem, saith Jesus Christ.