Page 157
CHAPTER XV.
* 1.1VERS. 1. 2. Then came to Iesus the Scribes, and Pharisees, which were of Hierusalem, saying, Why doe thy Disciples transgresse the Tradition of the Elders? for they wash not their hands when they Eate Bread.
[Quest.] WHat is meant by this word Tradition?
This voice Tradition is equi∣vocall, [Answ.] and hath divers signi∣fications, namely,
First, sometimes it is taken for all Doctrine, whether written or not written, 2 Thessal. 2.15. Hold fast the Traditions which ye have been taught whether by word or our Epistle.
Secondly, sometimes it is taken for that Doc∣trine which is delivered only Vivâ Voce by word of mouth; as in this verse, Why doe thy Disciples transgresse the Tradition of the Elders; which Traditi∣ons were never written, but delivered with a living voice from one to another.
Thirdly, sometimes it is taken for the written word of God. As Acts 6.14. and 1 Corinth. 15.3.
Fourthly, by the Papists this word Tradition is taken for that Doctrine which is written, but not in the holy Scriptures.
Fiftly, the Fathers by this voyce, did under∣stand sometimes those Doctrines which were contained in the Apostolicall writings; and un∣written Traditions, they called that which was not Totidem verbis, expresly commanded, or laid down in the Scripture; but yet the thing it self was extant in the Scripture, and might be proved from thence. And sometimes by Tradition they did understand, not Doctrines, but Ecclesiasticall order, and Rites. Scharp. de sa∣cra Script. pag. 125.
* 1.2Vers. 3. But he answered, and said unto them, Why do you also transgresse the Commandement of God, by your Tradition?
[Argu∣ment.] Against the Popish Traditions we produce this Argument from this place. All Traditions a∣mong the Jews, besides the Law, were condemned in this verse. Therfore all unwritten Traditions must now be abolished. To this, Bellarmine an∣swers two things; namely,
[Answ. 1] First, Christ condemneth not the ancient Tra∣ditions of Moses, but those which were newly and lately invented.
[Answ. 2] Secondly, Christ taxeth, and findeth fault one∣ly with wicked and impious Traditions.
To his first answer, we answer two things; viz.
[Replie 1] First, the Scripture maketh no mention of any such Traditions of Moses; Christ biddeth them search the Scriptures, and not run unto Tradi∣tions.
Secondly, these which our Saviour here speaks [Replie 2] of, seemed to be ancient Traditions, bearing the name of Elders Traditions, and they were in great authority among the Iewes: most like, because of some long continuance.
To his second Answer we answer likewise two things, to wit,
First, their Traditions were not openly and [Replie 3] plainly evill and pernicious, but had some shew of holinesse, as the washing of pots, and Tables; and beds; yea the Traditions of the Papists come nearer to open impietie, and blasphemie, then the Jewish Traditions did.
Secondly, Christ in opposing the Scripture a∣gainst [Replie 4] Traditions, therein condemneth all Tra∣ditions not written, which were urged as necessa∣ry besides the Scripture.
What may wee safely hold concerning the [Quest. 1] Traditions of the Church?
First, that besides the written word of God, [Answ. 1] there are, profitable and necessary constitutions and E••clesiasticall Traditions, to wit, of those things which respect the outward decencie and comelinesse of the Church, and service of God.
Secondly, the efficient cause of all true Tradi∣tions, [Answ. 2] is the Holy Spirit, which directs the Bi∣shops and Ministers assembled together in Councell or Convocation, for the determining of such orders and Constitutions, according to the word of God: and doth also direct the Churches, in the approving and receiving of such Traditions.
Thirdly, no Tradition of the Church, can con∣stitute [Answ. 3] or ratifie, a Doctrine contrary to the writ∣ten word of God, neither any rite or ceremony: for both Constitutions and Doctrines ought to be agreeable (at least not contrary) to the written word. And as all Civill Lawes ought to have their beginning from the Law of nature, so all Ecclesiasticall Traditions from the word of God. Rom. 14.23. and 1. Corinth. 14.26, 40.
Fourthly, although Ecclesiasticall Traditi∣ons [Answ. 4] may be derived from the word, yet they are not of equall authority with the word.
How may the true Traditions of the Church [Quest. 2] be known or discerned, from humane, and super∣stitious Ordinances?
By these foure notes and marks, to wit, [Answ.]
First, true Traditions are founded upon the word, and consentaneous unto the word, and de∣duced, derived and taken from the word.
Secondly, true Traditions are profitable for the conserving and promoting both of piety and externall and internall worship.
Thirdly, true Traditions make for the order decorum, and edification of the Church. And
Fourthly, are not greevous and intollerable, as the Traditions of the Pharisees were, and the Papists are. Matth. 23.4.