Page 293
IN the last place we are to consider how truly he affirmeth that our doctrine leaveth a Minister none but weake grounds, and those insufficient to quiet the tempted.
And whereas he saith We cannot conceive, and make it evident to the understanding of the tempted that he is not (that which he feares) a Reprobate; we willingly acknowledge it. For not to be a reprobate is to be an elect. Now how can any Arminian convince and make it evident to the understanding (I doe not say of the tempted, but) of one that is a believer, and walkes on comfortablely in the wayes of Godli∣nesse; is he (I say) able to convince such a one, and make it evident unto him that he is one of Gods elect? I doe not think they dare professe that they presume they can; or make it evident to their owne understanding, that themselves are of the number of Gods elect. How unreasonable then is this course, to require of us to convince a man, that acknowledgeth neither faith nor repentance in him, (for this is the condition of a man tempted, as himselfe fashioneth it;) and to make it evident to his understanding that he is an elect and no reprobate; when himselfe cannot convict him that believeth of this; no nor their owne consciences neither, notwithstanding all their confidence, that they alone are in the right way of salva∣tion. Was there ever heard a more unreasonable course then this? Againe, to feare to be a reprobate, or least he be a Reprobate, is one thing, to perswade himselfe that he is a Reprobate, and to despaire thereupon, is another thing. We say, and that according to our Doctrine, that there is no cause why any man (who hath not sinned the sinne unto death, the sinne against the Holy Ghost) should perswade himselfe that he is a Reprobate and despaire thereupon; we doe not say there is no cause of feare. In as much as he hath no evidence of his election, there is just cause to feare; but then a∣gaine, seeing he neither hath nor can have any evidence of his reprobation (excepting the guilt of the sinne against the Holy Ghost) he hath every way as good cause to hope. And for the comforting of such a one, I would make bold to tell him that there is more hope of such a one as himselfe, then of those who goe on in the wayes of their owne heart, and in the light of their owne eyes without all remorse and check of con∣science, without feare or wit, not considering that for all these things God will bring them to judgment. And towards such I would think it fit to use all meanes and mo∣tives to make them feare. The Apostle seemes to me to take the like course with better men then such, even with such as went on in a faire and comfortable profes∣sion of Gospell; namely to make them feare and suspect themselves, as when he saith, Prove youre selves whether you are in the faith, examine your selves. Know ye not that Christ is in you except ye be Reprobates. 2 Cor. 13. 5. And for good reason; for as Paul was jealous over the Corinthians with a Godly jealousy, for feare, least as the Serpent beguilde Eve through his subtilty, so their minds should be corrupt from that simplicity which is in Christ. 2 Cor. 11. 2, 3. And in like manner entertained feare, least when he came he should not find them such as he would, and that he should be found unto them such as they would not &c. 2 Cor. 12. In like manner I should think it is good for a man to be jealous over himselfe with a godly jealousy, least their minds should be corrupt, their wayes corrupt, more then they are a ware of, and there upon give themselves to the examining of themselves and to the searching and trying of their wayes whereunto the Holy Ghost