Page 141
Answer, What credit this Certificate shall have in the Hearts of the Wise and Faithful to God we see not, and we can commit the same to such to be weighed.
Robert Arch signifies, That one time when George Fox was at his House, and as he remembers it was at the same time when he was concerned in setting up Quar∣terly Meetings, and some Papers or Epistles, as Instructions in relation thereunto, was read at the same time, which George Fox had given forth, In which their was Written, saith he, as I remember, that such Friends as did pay Tythes should be Exhorted or Admonished; and at the same time was it, saith he, that George Fox advised him to buy his Tythes.
We say, this matter laid to his Charge, as that which should be his Advise, is so far remote from his known Testimony and Practice, that not a Faithful Man in the Nation, we believe, will give any credit to it: Besides, can any think, that George Fox should be so Indiscreet and Inconsistant with himself, and his own Papers of Directions and Advise, as to order such his Papers to be read, and Friends to be advised to practice accordingly, and he himself forth-with, at the same time, (if this were true concerning him) to throw down what he seemed to build up; this were such Confusion as we never heard spoken of him from any faithful Man, or could it be expected, that any Work begun on this wise could ever cone to ought; and that George Fox should advise him to buy off the Priests Tythes, is a ridiculous thing to Charge him with, there is no colour for it, being the Priest hath them not to sell; and if William Rogers, or Nathaniel Cripps, and Robert Arch, (his two In∣formers) in two several Countries, could prove it against George Fox, that he had at any time declared it to be his Judgment, That Impropriators Tythes in this Gospel Dispensation ought to be paid, (as it seems the two Informers have declared it to be theirs) it were something to the matter; but as to that we say, His many Wri∣tings and Testimonies have been very publickly as well as privately against Tythes in the Ground, and his said Paper of Direction touching that Case hath that gene∣ral tendency in it, without any exception: Upon all which Considerations it can never be supposed that George Fox would give forth such Advise; but that this Mans Darkness, through his Unfaithfulness in the matter of Tythes as aforesaid, being such, in Charity we may suppose, that he hath been under a great mistake in himself about this matter, otherwise it must needs be either gross Wickedness or Forgetfulness at the least, that caused him thus to insert in Charge against George Fox, and not from real cause by him given them, it being so far inconfistant with his Integrity and Nobility in the Truth, and readiness to lay down for his Testimony in this case, whatever might be otherwise dear to him; therefore what reason George Fox should have to advise these two unfaithful Men thus, or what occasion either, (seeing it was their Principle or Practice so to do, contrary to his own professed Testimony and Life, as Thousands in many parts of this Na∣tion, and other Nations will evidence) for our own parts we say, we are yet to Learn.
We are sorry that these two Men should do so unehristianly with themselves and their Friend that wished them well, as not to let George Fox know (before they iutended to give forth such Charges against him, and put them into the Hands of such a professed and openly declared Enemy to George Fox and the Life of Truth, and Gospel Order) what they were about to do; this manifested a wrong Spirit, and great Weakness as to Truth, that was less enclined to obey and serve the Truth, and to keep their Testimony clear therein, then to gratifie such