V. The First Rule. That is an Affirmative Proposition in which the Subject and Attribute are joyned, or do agree; and Negative, in which they are disjoyned, or dis∣agree.
VI. Explica∣tion of the Rule. For a Thing is then affirmed to be what it is, when the Predicate or Attribute agrees with the Subject, or when it is one and the same thing with it: As when we say, Man is an Animal. But a thing is pronounced not to be, what it is not, when the Attribute differs from the Subject, and agrees not with it: As when we say, Man is not a Beast, because Man is declared not to be such, as indeed he is not. This Division of a Proposition is accord∣ing to Quality; because when any one asks, of what kind the Proposition is, it is answered, Affir∣mative or Negative.
VII. In an Af∣firmative Proposition the Attri∣bute is re∣strained. We are to observe, that in an Affirmative Pro∣position the Attribute is to be taken in all its Com∣prehension, but not in all its Latitude. As when I say, Every Circle is a Figure; whatsoever is con∣tained in the Idea or Essence of a Figure, the same is affirmed of a Circle; but yet the word Figure is not taken in its whole Latitude, for it is of much larger extent than that of Circle; and there∣fore this Proposition cannot be simply converted in saying, Every Figure is a Circle. Wherefore in this Proposition the Attribute is restrained by the Subject, and reacheth no farther than the Sub∣ject doth.
VIII. But not in a Nega∣tive. But the case is different in a Negative Proposi∣tion; as, No Circle is a Square: For here the At∣tribute is taken in its whole Latitude; so as that we may say as well, that No Square is a Circle, and all Squares must be denied of a Circle. But the Attribute is not taken according to the whole Com∣prehension of its Idea, as if all the Attributes of a Square, were to be denied of a Circle: For a Circle and Square agree in the Idea or Notion of Figure.