Page 1288
A SERMON PREACHED upon
This spake be not of himself, but being High Priest that year be Prophesied, That Iesus should dye for that people.
AND is Caiphas among the Prophets? And is his counsil among the Prophesies? He the wickedest man then upon Earth, excepting Judas Iscariot: and His the wickedest counsil that ever was given, since the Serpent counselled Eve to destroy mankind. Had not the Spirit of Prophesie, by the pen of this our Evangelist, made this Interpretati∣on of it, who could ever have thought it of such a construction?
If it may be wished, I would the same Spirit had glossed upon the words of the whole Sanhedrin in vers. 47, 48. What do we? For this man doth many mi∣racles. If we let him thus alone, all men will believe on him; and the Romans shall come and take away both our place and Nation. If they grant he did so many miracles, why were they afraid that men should believe on him? Why did they not believe on him them∣selves? And afraid the Romans should destroy their City and Nation, if he were believed in? Whereas their destruction was, because they did not believe in him. Truly, Caiaphas said but truly of them, though he aimed it at another sense, Ye know nothing, neither do ye consider. (No, nor thou, O Caiaphas neither.) For had they known, they would not have crucified the Lord of life; had they considered, they had not brought that guilt upon themselves and the City, that they did.
But in what sense he makes them so senseless, is somewhat obscure; Ye know not, nei∣ther consider, that it is expedient for us, that one man should dye for the people, and that the whole Nation perish not. That they knew as well as himself, that any States-man, any reasonable man might know well enough, that it was better to put to death a ring-leader of mischief, as they took Christ to be, than that a whole Nation perish. That old Maxim in Politicks and reason, Pereat unus, potius quam unitas, would easily be observed by less States-men, than they. And the one that they would have to dye, they all agreed in: but herein Caiaphas resolution seems to have out-vied theirs: namely, that whereas they were afraid to take Christ off for fear of the multitude, he blusters through that doubt and scruple, and would have it resolved, that he must dye and be taken away.
So that in those words of his, you may observe him speaking as a Caiaphas, and as a Prophet. As a wretched Caiaphas, counselling the Sanhedrin not to fear or boggle at the business, but resolve on it, for it is expedient he should dye. And as a Prophet, or one in∣spired, signifying, that it was necessary Christ should dye for the preservation of that Nation; that it should not perish: namely, those that believed in him; and so for the preserving of all in other Nations, that should also believe: The former he spake and meant with all his heart, to stir up the Bench to destroy Christ, for all the danger of the multitude. But this later he spake indeed, but meant it not, neither understood what he spake: and therefore the Text tells us, This he spake not of himself, but being High Priest, &c.
There had not been a High Priest, a Prophet, among the Nation for above four hun∣dred years before; and must Caiaphas now become a Prophet? Nay the Jews tell us, and they tell us truly, that there had not been any Prophet at all in the Nation of so long a time: and it is wonder God should now inspire, such a wretch as Caiaphas. They tell us, that upon the death of Haggai, Zechariah and Malachi, those last Prophets, the spirit of Prophesie