Of Fines certain.
It was the Opinion of Richardson Chief Ju∣stice, There is scarce a Copy-holder in England but the Fines are uncertain; for (saith he) If the Rolls make it appear that at any time a greater and lesser sum was paid for a Fine, this makes the Fine uncertain; the ordinary course to search it is by Bill in Chancery, Lit. Rep. 252. It was but his private Opinion, for Fines are certain in great numbers of Manors: And I suppose he means as to Evidence; for in the Case of Allen and Abraham, 2 Bulst. 32. there is diversity between proof in case of Descents Page 160 and Purchase: The Case was this. Upon not Guilty in Ejectment, the matter upon the issue was about the Custom of a Copy-hold Ma∣nor, whether the Copy-holders upon their Ad∣mittances have used to pay Fines uncertain at the will of the Lord, or certain, i. e. the value of two years Rent? To prove the Fines un∣certain,* the Plaintiff shewed divers Court Rolls of Admittances upon Surrenders, and that the Fines taken by the Lord were not certain, but sometimes one, sometimes another: Per Curiam, To prove a Custom for uncertainty of Fines, and not to be certain two years Rent, there ought to be shewed Court Rolls,* and that in Cases of Descents; and that upon such Admit∣tances, they used to pay two years Rent, the proof ought to be in case of Descents; for in case of a Surrender or Purchase, the Lord may take what Fine he will: But such Fines are no proof to prove the taking uncertain Fines by the Custom, but the same ought to be in cases of Descents.