Master Edmund Calamies leading case
Calamy, Edmund, 1600-1666.
Page  [unnumbered]


Behold how he seeketh a quarrel against me?

LONDON, Printed in the Year, MDCLXIII.

Page  [unnumbered]Page  3


Lord Mayor's Officer with a Warrant.

FOr as much as I have received a Certificate from, and under the Hand and Seal of the right Reve∣rend Father in God, Gilbert Lord Bishop of London, That Mr. Edmund Calamy late Cu∣rate of the Parish Church of St. Mary Aldermanbury, in the said City of London being (according as is provi∣ded and enacted by the late Act of Parliament made for the Vniformity of Publick Prayers, &c.) by reason of his In∣conformity disabled to Preach or Read any Lecture or Ser∣mon in any Church or Chappel within his MAJESTIES Page  4 Realm of England, or Dominion of Wales, and Town of Berwick upon Tweed, and continuing and remaining still so disabled, did since the Feast of St. Bartholomew last past, upon two several daies, viz. on Tuesday the twenty sixth day of August last past, and upon Sunday the twenty eighth day of December, 1662 in the said Church of St. Mary Aldermanbury, presume, and take upon himself (without any lawful approbation and licence thereunto) to Preach or Read, and did Preach or Read two several Sermons or Lectures publickly before the Con∣gregation, then, and there in the said Church assembled, contrary to, and in contempt of Authority of the said Act of Parliament: These are therefore (as I am required by the said Act) in His MAJESTIES Name to will and command you to receive into your Custody within the Gaol of Newgate, the Body of the said Edmund Calamy brought unto you herewith, and him there detein for the offence aforesaid, for the Term of three Months from the day of the date hereof, without Bayl or Mainprise, accord∣ing to the tenor and effect of the Act of Parliament afore∣said. And this shall be your Warrant therein, Dated this fifth day of January, 1662.


FAr be this from you, good Sir, spare your self, and retire un∣til this Calamity be overpast. Come my people,*enter thou nto thy Chambers, and shut thy doores about thee: hide thy self as it were for a little moment, until the indignation be overpast.

Mr. Calamy,

What mean you to weep,*and to break mine heart? for I am ready not to be bound onely, but to dye for the Lord Jesus.

Page  5

Now you will not be perswaded, we must cease, and say,*The will of the Lord be done.


The Lord Jesus did not hide him∣self when he was to be taken for me, but said, Here I am: I will not hide my self now I am to be taken for him, but will say, Here I am: only I shall entreat some of your Company, to my Lord Mayor, to whom you may give an ac∣count of that daies proceeding.


With all our hearts: —

Lord Mayor.

As I would upon other occasi∣ons have been glad, so really I am now sorry to see you Mr. Calamy: equally sorry I am, that I must inflict such a punishment (as I am obliged by the Act) upon a Person of your Years and Profession; and that such a Person should deseve it: In charity I could not think your Conscience could have allowed you at a∣ny time, so open an affront to the most Solemn Establishment of Authoritie: I reason I could not think your prudence could have allowed it at this time, when His Majestie was so fll of gracious thoughts towards you, and all sober men of your way.


In prudence I should not at this time have displeased his Majestie: In Conscience I cannot at any time displease God.

Lord Mayor.

I hope His Majesties Govern∣ment is so just, so moderate, so agreeable to the great Principles of Religion and Reason, Page  6 upon which mankind joyn in a Society, or ChristJan. in a Church; that there is no di∣screet and knowing Person put upon the sad Dilemma of either provoking God, or oppo∣sing the Authority ordained of God.


Necessity is layd upon us, yea,*woe unto us if we preach not the Gospel. That you may have a reason of that which was done by me, and so may not think I did it unwarranta∣bly, I offer your Consideration what hath been much upon my spirit, from the 5. of the Acts, As the Apostles taught the People, the Priests, the Sadduces, the Captain of the Tem∣ple, came upon them, being grieved that they taught the People: And they layd hands on them, and layd them in hold against the next day: Howbeit, many of them which heard the Word believed, and the number of the men was about five thousand. And when they had called them before them, they asked them by what Power, or in what Name have you done this? Then Peter filled with the Holy Ghost,* said unto them: Ye Rulers of the People, and Elders of Israel, if we be ex∣amined this day of the good deed that we have done; be it known unto you all, we have done it it in the Name of the Lord Jesus Christ. And when they saw the bold∣nesse of Peter and John they marvelled, and they took knowledge of them. But when they had commanded them to go aside out Page  7 of the Councel, they conferred among them∣selves, saying, What shall we do to these men; for that indeed notable things have been done by them, is manifest to all them that dwell at Ierusalem, and we cannot deny it: But that it spread no further among the Peo∣ple, let us straitly threaten them that they speak henceforth to no man in this Name. And they called them, and commanded them, That they should not speak at all in the Name of Jesus. But Peter and John answer∣ed and said unto them: Whether it be right in the sight of God, to hearken unto God more than unto you, judge ye; for we cannot but speak the things which we have seen and heard: So when they had further threatned them, they let them go, finding nothing how they might punish them, because of the People.

L. B. L.

If it were not our businesse rather to manifest our obedience to the Act of Uni∣formity in performing duty, then to dispute your disobedience in neglecting yours, we could easily show you how many waies you have wrested this Scripture, as the unlearned and unstable wrest them, to their own dam∣nation: and how wide your case is from theirs.

For 1. They were silenced by no Lw; you are silenced by a Law: they could say with St. Paul, Acts 25. 8. for themelves, and an∣swer, That neither against the Law of the Jewes, Page  8 nor against the Temple, nor against Caesar, have we offended at all. You must confesse, That a∣gainst the Law of the Nation, against the Church, and against Caesar, in many things have you offended all.

2. They were forbid to preach in the Name of Jesus. You are onely forbid to Rebel in the Name of Jesus: They were restrained from publishing the Truth: You are restrain∣ed onely from publishing Errors.

3. There the whole Ministry was to be silen∣ced: Here you onely, and a few others, are su∣spended: So that now Christ is preached, and you may rejoice.

4. They were suspended by the prevailing power of oppressions: You are silenced by the reasonable power of your own Represen∣tatives in Parliament. ewes silenced them without a Law; you by a Law, which the men you have chosen have made, have silenced your selves.

5. A necessity which lay upon them, who were called of God, to reveal the Gospel which was hid from Ages; doth not ly upon you, who many of you, are not so much as called by man to preach that Word; which for ma∣ny years. God be thanked, hath dwelt rich∣ly among us.

6. They loved not their life unto the death, that they might preach the Gospel; you love your opinion so well, that you will rather Page  9 not preach the Gospel then hear it: they would not be silenced to save their lives, you silence your selves to al•• your rpute and esteem.

Mr. Calamy.

O add not reproach unto affliction▪ O Sir, we would not have left our callings and stati∣ons for fear of death, we must now leave them for fear of that which is worse then death: we would willing∣ly die rather then not serve the Lord in our calling: we must rather not serve the Lord in our calling then sin.

An honest man.

Really I am afraid that while you think you avoid sin by refusing Ceremonies which are indifferent, you committed sin in neglecting your calling, which was necessary.

Mr. Calamy.

Let every man be fully perswaded in his own mind: what is but indifferent in your apprehen∣sion, was sinful in mine, and every man must give an account of himself.


It is not what you think of the thing imposed can secure your conscience, but what they are▪ that which is good remains good, and that which is evil, evil: and that in the very same degree of good and evil as it was before, neither better nor worse, any mans particular judgement or opinion thereof not∣withstanding.

Mr. Calamy.

Thats true indeed, yet what is good or indifferent in it self, if I am perswaded it is evil, it is evil unto me: to him that esteemeth any thing to be unlawful to him it is unlawful, Rom. 4.14.


To him th•• thinketh a thing unlawful, and is at liberty, whether he doth it or no, to im it is unlawful: but to him that thinketh a thing unlaw∣ful, bu yet is enjoyned by lawful authority to do, to him if he hath not a clear rule to the contrary, it is lwful. Whtsoever it co•••ded us by those whom God hath felt over us 〈◊〉 in Chur, Common∣wealth, or Family, which is not evidently contra∣ry to the Law and will of God, ought to be receiv∣ved Page  10 and obeyed no otherwise, then as if God him∣self had commanded it; because God himself hath commanded us to obey the Higher Powers, and to submit our selves to their Ordinances, Rom. 13. 1. 1 Pet. 2.13.

Mr. Calamy.

I hope I must not go against my Conscience within me, to comply with my Supe∣riours above me.


What a strange thing is this! that when the blessed Apostle commanded you to obey for conscience sake, you should disobey, and that for conscience sake too: Your Governors charge you upon your Conscience to be obedient, and you pre∣tend your conscience to be free from that subje∣ction: It is a sad thing that you have brought your selves and other poor souls to such strait between two sins, and you can by no means pos∣sible avoid both, as long as you persist in this way; for if you do the things commanded, you go a∣gainst the perswasion of your own conscience, and that is a great sin; and if you do them not, you disobey lawful Authority, and that is a sin too.

Mr. Calamy.

Truly neither fancy, faction, nor humor makes me not to comply, but meerly for fear of offending God: And if after the best means used to satisfie my self; as prayer to God, discourse, study, I was not able to apprehend the lawfulness of what was required; if it be my un∣happiness to be in an error, surely men will have no reason to be angry vvith me in this vvorld, and I hope God vvill pardon me in the next.

Mr. Srin.

When I vvas called upon either to conform to the Lavvs for Uniformity, or to leave my Ministry, I asked of my self tvvo things, Whe∣her I would rather suffer death then use the thing imposed in a Church professing the foundation, and urging them as things indifferent, not pressing them as binding consciences in themselves, or as needful Page  11 to salvation? And whether the execution of my Mi∣nistry (which was pressed upon my conscience with wo, if I neglected it) should be as dear to me as my life.


Good God, to see to what pass small errors have brought us! how difference of apprehension hath brought forth difference of judgment: and dif∣ference of judgment bath brought forth difference of practice, and disagreement of affection. The dif∣ference of practice hath moved Authority to silence and suppress refusers of conformity. The disagree∣ment in affection doth move you who are deprived, to speak and act against persons in authority; where∣by in the event the course of the Gospel is interrupt∣ed, and of Popery enlarged; the friends of Sion are grieved, the enemies rejoyce; the enemy of mankind is gratified, and the Lord is displeased; the Church is rent with schism, the truth scandalized by dissen∣tion; the Ministers undone by loss of living, and the unity of brethren living in the same house, professing the same faith and rejoycing in the same hope, is pul∣led in pieces, and this like to continue God knows how long.

Mr. Calamy.

It is sad that Magistrates should en∣joyn such things as should cause such divisions as cause great thoughts of heart.


It is sad indeed that Subject cannot submit to such things as are enjoyned for peace, order, and decency.

L. M.

I wonder you should not consider how dangerous it should be to affront the most solemn in∣junction of the whole Nation, a Law so universally desired, so deliberately resolved on, so seriously pres∣sed, as the greatest security of Church or State.

Mr. Calamy.

I was several times persecuted for owning his Majesties Authority and Interest. I did not think I should live to be imprisoned for opposing it.

Sr. T. E.

The more favour his Majestie had for you for former service, the more sorry he is that you Page  12 have forfeited it by your presen and 〈◊〉. His Majestie thought that Mr. Calamy would not have 〈◊〉 so, of any man in England.

Mr. Calamy.

Really I did not do it upon mine own head, but upon the request of divers honourable and worthy persons who were otherwise like to be disap∣pointed of a morning Sermon.

Sr. R.B.

It is generally reported, and upon the ex∣traordinary concourse of people to your Church, as generally believed that it was designed before hand; several Citizn inviting one another to your Church to hear you preach.

Mr. Calamy.

It might be a design upon me, it was no design by me: this is not the first time we have been trpanne.


There are few that know you that can allow you so much indiscretion as to yeild to the private importunities of a few Gentlemen, against the pub∣lick authority of a whole Parliament.

Mr. Calamy.

I may say (with reverence to the Lord Jesus, of whom it is written) that I had com∣passion of the multitude, who were as sheep without a shepherd.


You would have taught the people better by your silence, then by your Sermon: your obedience had been better than sacrifice the misguided throng had been better taught by your cheerful submission to authority, then by your indiscreet discourse against it. When you had been importuned to preach, you should have said; I pray you go home and learn what that maneth, Submit your selves to every ordinance of 〈◊〉 for the Lord's sake, whether it e the King as su∣pream, or 〈◊〉 Governor〈…〉 them who are sent by him for the punishment of evil doers, and for the praise of them 〈◊〉 do well , for so is the will of God that wish well doing we may put to silence the ignorance of foolish men, as free and using your liberty as a cloak of icenti∣•••ness,〈…〉 wherefore ye must needs be Page  13 subject not only for w••th, but for conscience ske, 〈◊〉 13.5

Mr. Calamy.

I hope an offence of this nature may be passed by, being so innocent in the design of it, so harmless in the consequence of it.


How harmless it is in the design of it, be it between you and your God and soul: how dange∣rous it is in the consequence of it, any man may guess that considers what encouragement it may give your party, if you are not punished; and what offence it may give them if you are. If you are win∣ked at, why say others, are we not winked at too, without respect of persons. If you are punished, then they say, we are persecuted. It is sad that you are become such an occasion of offence between the King and his good people.

Mr. Calamy.

I hope I am not so unhappy.


You were looked upon as the fittest man to break the Ice, being a man so much esteemed for your own worth, and so much interessed in honoura∣ble friends and acquaintance. For as formerly Cart∣wright was encouraged by the E. of Lecester, Travers was entertained by the L. Treasurer Cecill, Walsing∣ham was owned by Secretary Walsingham; so you stir up your honourable women, and look for the fa∣vour of many excellent personages.

Mr. Calamy.

I hope his Majesties gracious Declara∣tion may excuse me.


When my Lord of London acquainted his Majestie with what you had done, his Majestie said, I am sure he hath no encouragement to, if from my decla∣ratin: His Majestie never intended any favour of this nature to you and I fear this pssage will ob∣abstruct that favour he intended.

Mr. Calamy.

So far I hope may this passage be from prejudicing his Sacred Majesty against us•• that it may rather incline him to favour us: considering the necessity he hereby may perceive of our service, and the reasonableness of his indulgence.

Page  14
M. O.

Flatter not your self with these vin thoughts; his Majesty may pity you, but he doth not want you. God hath sent his Word, and great are the company of Preachers.

Mr. Calamy.

Let not the rigour of one Session re∣strain those whom the indulgence of another may release.


It is a question whether the same Parliament may repeal the act that made it: whether those things that have been over-ruled, may be debated by the same House.

Mr. Calamy.

I hope that what a Popish Priest may do without check, a Protestant Minister may do with∣out imprisonment.


Neither the one nor the other may be endu∣red to seduce the people, and with fair words to de∣ceive the hearts of the simple, if any man teach any other doctrine, and consent not to wholesome words, &c.

Mr. Calamy.

I hope his Majesty will use his interest with the Parliament.


You of all men should not expect it, who complained of his late Majesties protecting Delin∣quents against his Parliament.

A Brother.

It is an unheard of course that the Church should be governed by Civil Laws, and Mini∣sters punished by Lay-men.

An honest man.

Since the reformation, by your leave and the Papists, we have owned his Maj. under Christ, Defender of our Faith, and Law-maker of our Church: the Church directs, the State establisheth.

Good women.

Als, that they should use the good man so unworthily and hardly!


When Mr. Calamy and Mr. Love, &c. were under restraint, and word was sent to the Army in Scotl. concerning it, Harrison and others said, If godly men transgress the Law, they should be punished by the Law

Good w.

Alas what harm hath the good man done?

Page  15
R. L.

In short he abused the Kings Authority, he hath broken the settled Law, he hath vilified the power of Parliam. he hath disturbed the publick peace, he stands to the principles of the Rebellion, and provokes another.

Good wo.

I wonder what he preached?


He preached that glory was departing from our Isr.

Good w.

These courses will bring us to another war.


Not so we hope. What, will you endanger the publick peace rather then be restrained? will you not scruple at Rebellion, who scruple at a few ceremonies? what would you do if you had power in your own hands, that are so bold without it? shall the minor part impose upon the major? shall a novel fancy bear down an Apostolical institution? shall a private opinion contest with a publick Law?


Alas that our teachers are removed into corners.


Our dangers begin at the Pulpit, without the aid of seditious Sermons, I do believe the strife had ne∣ver come to bloud: he was a wise man that said, The sin∣gle imprisonment of Crofton hath quieted that party more then all the multiplied and transcendent favors of his Majesty.

Good w.

These are sad times.


Say not that the former times were better then these, for thou dost not enquire wisely concerning this thing: when you guided the times others complained; now others guide the times, you complain; when shall we be quiet, I think it is our best way to rest where we are

Good w.

Good man, he hath discharged his conscience.


He hath it may be discharged his conscience, and my L. M. must discharge his: he who in order to the making of good ChristJan., makes bad Subjects, hath a zeal indeed, but it is seditious; a Religion, but it is Re∣bellion.


Now you suffer for righteousness sake, happy is he.


Yes, but what glory have you, if when ye are buf∣feted for your faults you take it patiently. Let none of you suffer as a murderer, or as a thief, or as an evil doer, or as a busie-body in other mens matter.

Page  16
Mr. Calamy.

May I but 〈◊〉espied until o mo row.


Yes, with all my heart upon your, and your fri••ds word.

Sr. I.B.

Remember how you prayed, preached, and what you did June 6. 1641. and what was done Jan. 6. 1644, and I pray speak not with Argyle as you go home.

    Jeremiah 338.
  • 1 This man se hath not the welfare of this people, but their 〈◊〉.
  • 2 Thou fallest away to the Caldeans.
  • 3 Its false. I fall not to the Caldeans.
  • 4 Jeremiah said, what have I doe against thee 'or a∣gainst they servants that I should be put in prison.
  • 5 Let my supplication I pay 〈◊〉, &c accepted before thee O King.
  • 6 Then took they Jeremiah and sent him to the dungeon.
  • 7 When Ebed•••lech the EthiopJan. the chamber lain of the Kings house heard that they put Jeremiah in the dun∣geon, he spake to the King, saying, My Lord the King, these men have done evil in all they have done to Jeremiah the Prophet whom they have cast into the dungeon, &c.
  • 1 This man envieth the establishment of this Nati∣on, and seeks its hurt.
  • 2 Thou fallest away to the separation at Hemsted.
  • 3 It is false, I kept no Convenucle at Hemsted.
  • 4 Mr. Calamy said, what have I done worthy of im∣prisonment?
  • 5 Let my petition be re∣•••ved by your most xcel∣lent Majestie.
  • 6 Then took they M. Ca∣lamy & sent him to Newgate
  • 7 Now when L.Ch. heard that Mr. Calamy was in pri∣son, he went to the King, and said, May it please your Majesty, it is pity that re∣verend Mr. Calamy should be sent to Newgate.

Pana ad unum, terror ad omnes.

Page  [unnumbered]