Quakerism a-la-mode, or, A history of quietism particularly that of the Lord Arch-bishop of Cambray and Madam Guyone ... also an account of the management of that controversie (now depending at Rome) betwixt the Arch-bishop's book / writ by Messire Jacques Benignes Bossuel [sic] ... ; done into English from the original printed at Paris.
About this Item
Title
Quakerism a-la-mode, or, A history of quietism particularly that of the Lord Arch-bishop of Cambray and Madam Guyone ... also an account of the management of that controversie (now depending at Rome) betwixt the Arch-bishop's book / writ by Messire Jacques Benignes Bossuel [sic] ... ; done into English from the original printed at Paris.
Author
Bossuet, Jacques Bénigne, 1627-1704.
Publication
London :: Printed for J. Harris ..., and A. Bell...,
1698.
Rights/Permissions
To the extent possible under law, the Text Creation Partnership has waived all copyright and related or neighboring rights to this keyboarded and encoded edition of the work described above, according to the terms of the CC0 1.0 Public Domain Dedication (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/). This waiver does not extend to any page images or other supplementary files associated with this work, which may be protected by copyright or other license restrictions. Please go to http://www.textcreationpartnership.org/ for more information.
Subject terms
Guyon, Jeanne Marie Bouvier de La Motte, 1648-1717.
Fénelon, François de Salignac de La Mothe-, 1651-1715.
Quietism.
Link to this Item
http://name.umdl.umich.edu/A28847.0001.001
Cite this Item
"Quakerism a-la-mode, or, A history of quietism particularly that of the Lord Arch-bishop of Cambray and Madam Guyone ... also an account of the management of that controversie (now depending at Rome) betwixt the Arch-bishop's book / writ by Messire Jacques Benignes Bossuel [sic] ... ; done into English from the original printed at Paris." In the digital collection Early English Books Online. https://name.umdl.umich.edu/A28847.0001.001. University of Michigan Library Digital Collections. Accessed June 13, 2024.
Pages
Sect. 3. The second part of the Relation, contain∣ing
what passed betwixt Mr. de Chaalons, and
Mr. Tronson and my self.
1. VVHilst I was taken up with these
thoughts, and labouring betwixt
hope and fear, Madam Guyon turned the exami∣nation
to quite another thing than what it was at
first.
descriptionPage 26
She took it in her head to have the accusations
brought against her Morals, and the disorders that
were imputed to her, examined. Upon this she
wrote to that future Protectress, whom she thought
to have seen in her Prophecy, beseeching her to beg
of the King that some Commissioners should be
appointed, with power to inform themselves, & to
pronounce Judgment upon her Life. The Copy she
sent me of her Letter, & that which she joyned to
it, shew by their Dates, that this happened in June
1694. This was a design to fulfil her Predictions,
and for that end Mad. Guyon gave a specious turn
to the thing, dexterously in sinuating that she must
be cleared of the Crimes she was accused of, with∣out
which they would enter upon the examinati∣on
of her Doctrine with too much prejudice. But it
is not so easie a matter to surprize an enlightned
Piety. It was soon perceiv'd by the Mediatress
she had chosen, that this Proposal of the Commis∣siners,
besides other inconveniences, shot wide of
the Mark, which was to begin by examining the
Doctrines contained in her Wrirings they had in
hand, and in the Books where with the Church
was overflowed, and so the Proposal dropt off it
self: Madam Guyon yielded, and then demanded
by her Friends the thing in the World that was
most agreeable to me; viz. that to put an end to
an examination of a thing of that importance,
wherein the matter of Question must be through∣ly
canvass'd, and a sort of prayer so pernicious,
abolished, if possible; I should be associated with
Mr. de Chaalons, now Archbishop of Paris, and
descriptionPage 27
Mr. Tronson superior General of the Congrega∣tion
of St. Sulpice. The Letter by which Madam
Guyon acquaints me with this step, makes out to
the full all the reasons that induced her to submit
to those two Gentlemen and to my self. The last
of 'em was unknown to me, except by his repu∣tation;
But the Abbot of Fenelon and his Friends
had a particular confidence in him. As for Mr. de
Chaalons, it is known with what holy friendship
he and I have always been united: He was also
an intimate Friend to the Abbot of Fenelon. With
such Collegues I hoped to compass all things. The
King was acquainted with the thing so far as it
related to Madam Guyon only, and approved of
it. The Archbishop of Paris has explained what
was written to him upon that account, and what
he answered. The Books I had seen were delivered
to those persons: The Abbot of Fenelon begun
then very privately to write upon that matter.
The Writings he sent us augmented every day;
and without naming in them Madam Guyon or
her Books; every thing he wrote tended to main∣tain
or to excuse them: The thing really in que∣stion
was those Books, and they made the sole Sub∣ject
of our Meetings. The silent prayer of Ma∣dam
Guyon was, that M. de Fenelon was for, and
perhaps 'twas his own in a particular manner.
That Lady did not forget her self, and during
seven or eight month that we applied our selves
to so serious a discussion; she sent us fifteen or six∣teen
big Bundles, (which I have still) to make a
parallel betwixt her Books, the holy Fathers, Di∣vines,
descriptionPage 28
and the Spiritual Authors. All this was at∣tended
with proffers of entire submission. The Ab∣bot
of Fenelon took the trouble with some of his
Friends to come to Iby, a house belonging to the
Seminary of Sr. Sulpice, where we were obliged
to hold our Conference, because of the infirmities
of Mr. Tronson. They all desired that we would
enter upon that examination throughly, and pro∣tested
they would refer all to our Judgment. Ma∣dam
Guyon testified the same submission by Letters
full of respect, and afterwards our only care was
to terminate that Affair very privately, so as to
prevent all suspicion of any dissention in the
Church.
2. We began to read, with more Prayers than
Study, and with Groans, God knows, for all
the Writing they sent us, especially those of
the Abbot of Fenelon: To compare all the
passages, and often to read over again whole
Books how tedious and laborious soever the read∣ing
thereof might be. The long extracts I have
by me shew what attention we gave to an Affair,
wherein really the Church was so nearly concern∣ed;
seeing the thing in question was no less than
to hinder the revival of Quietism, which we saw
again appearing in the Kingdom, by the Writings
of Madam Guyon which were spread over all.
3. We look upon it as the greatest misfortune
of all, that she had the Abbot de Fenelon for her
Defender: His Wit, his Eloquence, His Vertue,
the place he filled, and those he was designed for.
descriptionPage 29
Engaged us to labour with utmost diligence to
reclaim him. We could not despair of success;
for although he wrote to us things that we must
own made us afraid, the memory where of is as
fresh to those persons as to me; he mixed them with
so many testimonies of submission, that we could
not perswade our selves that God would deliver
him up to a Spirit of Error. The Letters he
wrote to me during the examination of this Book,
and before we had come to a Final Resolution,
breathed out nothing but obedience; and tho
he surrendred himself entirely to those Gentle∣men:
I must own here, that beside my being the
President of the Conference, he semmed to ad∣dress
himself to me with so particular a freedom,
because we had been long used to treat together
of the Theological matters in dispute: One of
those Letters was conceived in the following
terms.
4. I receive my Lord with—great
acknowledgement the kindness you shew me. I can't
but see that you are willing out of Charity to
to settle my Heart in Peace: But I confess it seems
to me, that you are somewhat afraid to give me a
true and perfect security in my State. When ever
you please I shall acquaint you as to my Confessor with
whatever may be comprized in a General Confession
of my whole Life, and of all that regards my
inward State. When I besought you to tell me
the truth, and not to spare me, it was neither for∣mal
Complement, nor a trick to discover your senti∣ments;
If I had a mind to use Art it should be in
descriptionPage 30
other things, and we should not have come to this
pass. I never desired any thing, but what I will ever
wish, that is, if it be Gods will that I may know
the Truth. I am a Priest, I owe all to the Church,
and nothing to my self, nor to my personal Reputa∣tion.
I declare to you still my Lord, That I wont
abide in Error one moment through my own fault;
If I don't abandon it without delay I declare it is
you who are the cause of it, seeing you determine
nothing to me. I do not value my place, but I am
ready to leave it if I am rendred unworthy of it by
my my Errors. I summon you in the Name of
God, and for the Love you have to the truth, to
tell it me in the utmost severity. I shall go and
hide my self and do Pennance the remaining part
of my Days; after having abjured and recanted
the Erronious Doctrine that has seduced me; But
if my Doctrine be innocent, do not keep me in sus∣pence
out of some Humane Respect. To you it ap∣pertains
to instruct with Authority those that are
scandalized, because they know not the Operations
of God in the Soul: You know with what confi∣dence
I have delivered my self to you, and applied
my self without intermission, that you should not be
Ignorant of my strongest perswasions. There re∣mains
nothing for me to do but to obey. For it is
not the Man, or the most Grand Doctor that I
esteem in you; it is God. And though you should
mistake your self, my simple and upright obedience
shall—not deceive me; and I account it as no∣thing
to mistake, when I do it with Ʋprightness
and Humility under the hand of those who have
descriptionPage 31
Authority in the Church. Once more, my Lord,
if you doubt never so little of my decible Temper
withou reserve, be pleased to put it to the proof with∣out
spairing me. Although your mind is more
enlightned than that of any other Man. I pray to
God, that he would be pleased to take away all your
own Wisdom and to leave you none but that which
is his.
5. Thus, you have the whole Letter word
by word. And may see by his Offers to leave
all, and to make a Solemn Recantation of what
consequence the matter was, and how far he was
engaged therein: Though he had not as yet writ
any Defence of the new way of Prayer. I accept∣ed
with joy the Prayer he made for me, that I
might lose all my own Wisdom, which indeed
I did not relie on; and I endeavoured to listen to
nothing but Tradition.
Thus seeing the Abbot of Fenelon so well dis∣posed
to submit, I look upon it as an injustice to
entertain any doubt of his compliance. It never
entred into my mind that the Errors wherein I
saw him involv'd, tho' in themselves very impor∣tant
and pernicious, could ever do him any injury,
or debar him from the dignities of the Church.
They were not afraid in the fourth Age to make
the famous Synesius a Bishop, tho' he confessed
many Errors; they knew him so well disposed
and so full of compliance, that they did not so
much as think that those Errors, tho' Capital ones,
ought to be an obstacle to his Promotion. I do
not speak thus to justifie my self: I only set down
descriptionPage 32
the matter of fact, the judgment whereof I refer
to those who consider it: If they will defer their
Judgment until they have seen the effect of the
whole, they will do me a great favour. Every
thing here depends upon what follows; so that
'tis not possible for me to conceal any thing from
the Reader, without involving all in darkness.
Moreover, the compliance of Synesius was no
greater than that which the Abbot of Fenelon
shewed. Another of his Letters contain these
words.
6.
I cannot forbear to ask you with a full
submission, whether you have at present any
thing to require of me. I conjure you in the
Name of God, not to have any regard for me
in any thing; and without expecting the Con∣ference
you promise me, if you now believe that
I owe any thing to the Truth, and to the
Church wherein I am a Priest, one word with∣out
Arguments shall suffice. I hold only one
thing which is simple obedience, so that my Con∣science
is in yours. If I do amiss, it is you who
make me to err for want of advising me. It is
your part to answer for me if I continue one mo∣ment
in the Error. I am ready to be silent, to
recant, to accuse my self, and even to retire, if I
have fail'd as to what I owe to the Church. In
a word, regulate me in whatever you please;
and if you do not believe me, take me at my
word to entangle me. After such declaration I
think I ought not to conclude with Comple∣ments.
descriptionPage 33
7. In another Letter, he said:
I have
already besought you not to delay one mo∣ment,
out of any respect to me, the deci∣sion
that I beg of you. If you are resolved
to condemn any part of the Doctrine I
have exposed to you, out of obedience, I
beseech you to do it with as much speed as
you shall be desir'd. I had as good, nay,
rather recant to Day than to Morrow.
The rest was to the same purpose, and con∣cluded
with these words:
Deal with me
as with a School-boy, without minding ei∣ther
my place, or your ancient Kindnesses
towards me. I shall be all my life full of
Acknowledgement and Compliance, if you
deliver me, as soon as possible, out of Er∣ror.
God forbid I should propose this,
to engage you into a precipitant Decision,
to the disadvantage of Truth; I only wish
you would not delay at all on my ac∣count.
8. Those Letters were written to me by
the Abbot of Fenclon, betwixt the 12th of
December, 1694. and the 26th of January
1695. during which time we were draw∣ing
up the Articles. Having read all the
Writings, as well those of Madam Guyon,
as of Monsieur Fenelon, wherein we com∣prised
the Condemnation of all the Errors
we found in t'one and t'other; weighing all
the Words, and endeavouring not only to
resolve all the Difficulties that appeared,
descriptionPage 34
but also to prevent by Principles, those
that might arise afterwards. We were at
first, after the reading of the Writings, for
Conversation by word of Mouth; but we
feared lest by bringing things to a Dispute,
we should sooner exasperate, than be able
to instruct a Person whom God was pleas∣to
lead into a better Way, which was that
of an Absolute Submission. He wrote thus
himself to us, in a Letter I have yet by
me:
Spare your selves the trouble of
entring upon that Discussion: Take the
thing in gross, and begin by supposing
that I have mistaken my self in my Cita∣tions.
I forsake them all; I don't pre∣tend
either to understand Greek, or to
make fine Arguments upon Passages: I
insist only upon those that you think may
deserve some regard: Pronounce my Judg∣ment
according to those, and give a De∣cision
upon the essential Points; after
which, the remaining part will be of
little moment.
By this it may be perceiv∣ed,
that we had declared our selves enough
upon his Writings. He had explained him∣self
therein so thoroughly, that we per∣fectly
comprehended his Sentiments. We
met every day; we agreed so well on the
Point, that there was no need of a long
Discourse. Notwithstanding, we carefully
collected what the Abbot of Fenelon had
told us at the beginning, and what he spoke
descriptionPage 35
upon occasion. We dealt plainly, as is u∣sual
among Friends, without taking any ad∣vantage
one of another; and so much
the more, because we our selves, whom
they took for Arbitrators, had no other
Authority over the Abbot of Fenelon
than what he himself gave us. It seem'd
that God made his Heart sensible of the
Way we were to follow, in order to re∣claim
him gently, without offedning so fine
and acute a Spirit. The Examinauion last∣ed
long: It is true, the Necessities of our
Diocesses caused some interruption to our
Conferences. As to the Abbot of Fenelon,
we had rather not to have given him a∣ny
trouble at all about his Opinions, than
to seem to have condemned him rashly,
and before we had heard all his defences.
It was something of a Blow given to them,
to hold them as supicious, and to subject
them to Examination. The Abbot of Fen∣elon
had reason indeed to tell us, That af∣ter
all, we knew not his Opinions any o∣ther
way but by himself. As he could have
conceal'd them from us, so the freedom
wherewith he discover'd them, was to us
a mark of his docible temper; and we
concealed them so much the more carefully,
the more freely he discover'd them to us.
9. So that during all the time we three
treated of that Affair with him, that is, for
Eight or Ten Months, the Secret was no less
descriptionPage 36
impenetrable than it had been during the
time that I alone was upon it. It must be
confess'd here, that the least whisper to
the King, of the Abbot de Fenelon's favour∣ing
M. Guyon and her Doctrine, would
have produced strange effects in the Mind
of a Prince so Religious, so nice as to mat∣tets
of Faith, and so circumspect in fil∣ling
up the great Places of the Church;
and the least that this Abbot must have ex∣pected
from it, had been an unavoidable
exculsion from all Dignities. But we did
not so much as suspect (at least for my part
I own it) that any thing was to be feared
from a Man, whose return was thought so
sure, his Mind so docible, and his Intentions
so upright; and whether it were by Rea∣son,
or prepossession; or if you will, through
Error: (For I rather here make a publick
Confession, than seek to defend my self)
I thought the Instruction of the Princes of
France in too good a hand, not to do, on
this occasion, whatever might conduce to
the Keeping of so important a Trust there∣in.
10. I carried that Confidence to the high∣est
pitch, as will be known by the fol∣lowing
Discourse. It was the Will of God,
perhaps to humble me: And perhaps also,
I sin'd by putting too much confidence in
the Knowledge I believ'd a Man endowed
with; or else, that in reality, I thought
descriptionPage 37
I might put confidence in the strength of
Truth, and power of Grace; I spoke with
too much assurance of a thing that surpas∣sed
my Power: However we acted upon
that ground, and as we were labouring to
reclaim a Friend, so we applyed our selves
with a scrupulous regard to manage his
precious Reputation.
11. It was this that inspired us with
the Design you shall hear of presently.
We thought our selves obliged, in order
to set bounds to his Thoughts, to restrict
him by some thing under his hand; but,
at the same time, we proposed to our
selves, in order to avoid making him look
like one that retracted, to have him sign
with us as an Associate in our Delibera∣tions.
We had no other design in any re∣spect,
but how to save such a Friend;
and we were unanimously agreed for his
Advantage.
12. A little while after, he was named
to the Archbishoprick of Cambray. We
applauded the Choice, as did every body
else, and he continu'd nevertheless in that
way of submission God put him in: The
higher he was to be raised upon the Can∣dlestick,
the more I thought he should at∣tain
to that great splendor, and to the
grace of the Episcopal State, through the
humble compliance we saw in him. So
we continued the forming of our Sentence;
descriptionPage 38
and he of his own accord begg'd if of us
with the same humility. The Four and
Thirty Articles that were drawn up at
Issy in our private Conferences, Mon∣siur
de Chaalons and I, presented to the new
Prelate in my Apartment at Versailles. The
Archbishop of Paris has expressed in his
Answer to the Archhishop of Cambray,
how uneasie he was in reading it. We
told him without disputing, with an Epis∣copal
sincerity, how he ought to dispose
of the Writings he had sent us in so great
numbers; he said not a word; and not∣withstanding
the reluctancy he had shew∣ed,
he offer'd that very moment, to sign
the Articles meerly out of obedience. We
thought it more fit to put them into his
hands, that he might peruse them some
time. Tho' they went to the quick, or ra∣ther
indeed overthrew the Foundation of
the new way of Prayer; yet their Prin∣ciples
being clear, we thought that the Ab∣bot
of Fenelon would not contradict them,
when once he understood them. He brought
us some restrictions to every Article, which
eluded all the strength of them; and the
ambiguity thereof did not only render
them useless, but also dangerous; we did
not think fit to admit them. My Lord
of Cambray yielded, and the Articles
were Signed at Issy, at M. Tronsons, the 10th
of March, 1695.
descriptionPage 39
13. When the Archbishop of Cambray says
in his Answer to our Declaration, that
he drew up the Articles with us; I am
sorry he has forgotten those holy Dispo∣sitions
God had then put him into. It
has been seen by the Letters he wrote,
during the time we were busie in drawing
those Articles, that he begg'd a Decision
without Arguments. If we came to be of
that Opinion. I desire those that read this,
not to impute it to any haughtiness or
disdian. God forbid! on any other occasion
we would have accounted it an honour to
deliberate with a Man of so much Light
and Merit, who was moreover going to be
received into our Episcopal Body, but at
that time God shewed him another way;
which was, that he must obey without ex∣amining.
Men must be led in the Path
which it pleases God to open unto them,
and by the Disposition his grace puts into
their Hearts. Therefore the first time M.
de Cambray spoke of our Thirty Four Ar∣ticles,
(which was in the Advertisement of
the Book of the Maxims of the Saints)
he mentions only two Prelates, Monsieur
de Chaalous and I, that had drawn them
up, without thinking then that he should
name himself as one of the Authors. He
remember'd the disposition of Mind we
were all in when we sign'd. Thus you
have an Account of the little Mystery we
descriptionPage 40
were put upon meerly in regard to his
Advantage. I hear his Friends give out,
that this was as a secret of Confession a∣mong
us, which he would not discover,
and that we have revealed it. Never any
such thing came into our thoughts, nor
did we imagin any other Secret but that
only of having a regard to his Honour,
and of his retractation under a more spe∣cious
Title. If he had not declared him∣self
too much in his Book, and then for∣ced
our silence, that Secret should still
have lain in Darkness.
We have seen how in one of his Let∣ters
he offer'd to make a general Confes∣sion
to me; he well knows that I never
accepted that offer. Whatever could have
relation to Secrets of that nature, upon
his inward disposition, is forgotten, and
will never be call'd in question. The Arch∣bishop
of Cambray insinuates in some of his
Writings, that I made nice Exceptions to
some of his Restrictions, and that the Arch∣bishop
of Paris took me up sharply for
it. We have then both of us forgotten
it, since we have no Idea of it left in
our Minds: We were all along so una∣nimous,
that we never had any occasion
to perswade one another, and being
wholly guided by the same Spirit of Tra∣dition,
we were all the time of one
and the same mind.
descriptionPage 41
14. The Archbishop of Cambray continued
so stedfast in the spirit of submission God
had put him into, that, having desir'd me
to Consecrate him, two days before that
divine Formality, kneeling and kissing the
Hand that was to Consecrate him, he took
it to witness that he would never enter∣tain
any other Doctrine but mine. I was
cordial, and I dare say it, more at his
Devotion than he was at mine. But I
received that submission as I had done
all others of the same nature, which are
still to be seen in his Letters. My Age,
my being older in Orders than he, the
simplicity of my Sentiments conformable
to those of the Church, and the Person
I was to act, gave me that confidence.
M. de Chaalons was desired to be one of the
Assistants in the Ceremony, and we thought
we should give the Church a Prelate, of the
same mind with those that Consecrated him.
15. I don't believe that M. de Cambray
will forget this praise-worthy Circumstance
of his submission. After the signing of
the Articles, and about the time of his
Consecration, he desir'd me to keep, at
least some of his Writings, to serve as an
Evidence against him, if ever he should
stray from our Sentiments. I was far from
that spirit of mistrust. No Sir, said
I, I will never use any other precaution
with you than to take your word. I gave
descriptionPage 42
back all the Papers as they were given
me, not keeping so much as one, nor a∣ny
other thing except my extracts for a
memorandum of the Errors I was to con∣fute,
without naming the Author. As for
the Letters that belonged to me, I kept
some of them as has been seen, rather
for my comfort, than that I believed I
should ever have need of them, except
perhaps for M. Cambray, to put him
in mind of his holy Submissions, in case
he should be tempted to forget them;
that they are now published, is really ow∣ing
to pure Necessity, which compelled
me to speak more than I would. The
protestation he made to me a little before
his Consecration, should also have been
kept in silence as well as the rest, if it
had not come to the King's Ears, that
advantage was made of it, and that they
made as if I confirmed the Doctrine of
the Book of the Maxims of the Saints, be∣cause
I had Consecrated the Author.
16. A little before the Publishing of
that Book an Affair happen'd that gave
me a great deal of Trouble. In my Pa∣storal
Instructions of the 16th of April,
1695, I had promised a larger one to
explain our Articl••s, and I desired the
Archbishop of Cambray to join his Ap∣probation
to that of M. de Chaalons, then
promoted to the See of Paris, and to that
descriptionPage 43
of M. de Chartres, for the Book I design'd
for that Explication. Seeing we are to
name here the Bishop of Chartres, I must
take notice he was the first of the Bishops
of that neighbourhood, who discover'd the
evil Effects of the Books and Conduct of
Madam Guyon. The Consequences of that
Affair made us concur together in many
things; as for the Archbishop of Paris,
I was so much the more obliged to sup∣port
my self by his Authority, because
for the good of our Province, he was be∣come
the Chief of it. I thought also, it
was for the publick Edification, that our
unanimity with M. de Cambray should be
known more and more every where I
put my Book, in Manuscript, into the Hands
of that Bishop: I expected his Excepti∣ons,
and to correct my self according to
his Advice: I found in my self, I thought,
the same compliance for him that he had
shewed to me before his Consecration:
But about three Weeks after, his Appro∣bation
was refused me, and that too for
such a Reason as was far from my being able
to foresee. A Friend to us both gave me,
in the Gallery of Versailles, a Letter of
Credentials from the Archbishop of Cam∣bray,
who was in his Diocese. Upon which
I was given to understand, that that Pre∣late
could not enter into the Approbati∣tion
descriptionPage 44
of my Book, because I therein con∣demned
Madam Guyon, whom he could not
condemn.
17. It was in vain for me to repre∣sent
unto that Friend the Incovenience that
M. de Cambray would fall into. What! it
will appear, said I, that to sustain M. Guy∣on,
he disunites himself from his Brethren?
then all the World will see that he is her
Protector; the suspicion wherewith he was dis∣honoured
abroad, will now be found a cer∣tainty?
What becomes of those fine Discour∣ses
we so often had of M. de Cambray,
and which he and his Friends spread abroad;
as that he was so far from being concerned
in the Books of that Woman, that he was
ready to condemn them if it were necessary?
Now that she had condemned them her self;
that she had, before me, subscribed the Con∣demnation
of them, together with the Evil
Doctrine contained in them; would he counte∣nance
them more than her felf? In what
amazement will the World be, to find at the
head of my Book, the Approbation of the Arch∣bishop
of Paris, and of the Bishop of Chartres,
without his? Was not that the way to make
the signs of his Division from his Brethren
manifest? his Consecrators, his most inti∣mate
Friends? What Scandal, what Reproach
to his Name? Of what Books would he be∣come
descriptionPage 45
the Martyr? why would he bereave
the People of the comfort of seeing in the
Approbation of that Prelate, the solemn Testi∣mony
of our unanimity? All these Reasons
had no effect; my Manuscript was resto∣red
to me again, having staid three whole
Weeks in the hands of M. de Cambray.
The Friend that had taken upon him to
give it me again, said he had kept it for
most part of the time himself, and that
M. de Cambray had it but few days, and
gave it back without having read much
of it. I wrote a few Lines to that Pre∣late,
intimating to him my just Fears. I
received an Answer that signifi'd nothing,
and then he had begun to prepare what
you shall see afterwards.
18. You would perhaps know beforehand
what was become of M. Guyon. She had
desired to be received into my Diocese,
in order to be there instructed. She was
six Months in the Holy Convent of the
Damsels of St. Mary, upon condition she
should have no communication with any
person whosoever, either within or without,
by Letter or otherwise, save only with the
Confessor I appointed her according to her
Desire, and with two Nuns I had chosen,
one of whom was the venerable Mother
le Picard, a most prudent Woman, Supe∣rior
of that Monastery. Seeing all her
descriptionPage 46
Letters and Discourses breathed out no∣thing
but submission, and a blind submis∣sion,
we could not refuse her the use of
the Holy Sacraments. I instructed her di∣ligently;
she subcribed the Articles where
she plainly saw they utterly condemn'd her
Doctrine: I rejected her Explications, and
her submission was pure and simple. A
little after she subscribed the just Censure
that M. de Chaalons and I published against
her Books, and the Evil Doctrine con∣tain'd
in them, condemning them with
Heart and Mouth, as if each Proposition
had been expresly utter'd. Some of the
chief of 'em were specified that compri∣sed
all the rest, and she renounced them
in plain terms. The Books she condemn∣ed,
were the Short Method, and the Song
of Songs, which were the only Printed
Books she owned: I would not meddle
with the Manuscripts that were not known
abroad: She offer'd at every word to burn
them all; but I thought that precaution
needless, because of the Copies that re∣main'd.
So I satisfi'd my self with for∣bidding
her to communicate them, or to
write of 'em to others; or to teach,
dogmatise, or direct, condemning her to si∣lence,
and retirement as she desired. I
received the Declaration she made against
the Abominations she was accused of, pre∣suming
descriptionPage 47
her to be innocent, as long as she
was not Convicted by a lawful Examina∣tion
whereupon never enter'd. She asked
me leave to go to the Waters of Bour∣bon;
after her submissions she was free:
She desired to be received after her re∣turn
from the Waters into the same Mo∣nastery,
where she kept her Apartment. I
granted it one design to instruct, and tho∣roughly
to convert her, without leaving
her, if possible, not so much as the least
tincture of the Visions and Delusions past.
I gave her that attestation her Friends so
much bragg'd of abroad; but she never
durst shew it, because I expresly specified
therein, that Account of the Declarations
and Submissions of M. Guyon, which we
had by us, subscribed by her own Hand:
and of the Prohibitions accepted by her
with submission, neither to Write, Teach,
nor Dogmatise in the Church, nor to spread
abroad her Printed Books, or Manuscripts,
nor to lead People into the way of her
silent Prayer, or otherwise. I was satisfi∣ed
with her Conduct, and had continu'd
her in the participation of the Holy Sa∣craments,
wherein I found her. This At∣testation
was dated the First of July, 1695.
I set out the next day for Paris, where
we were to advise what course we should
take concerning her for the future: I
descriptionPage 48
shall not recount how she went off before
the day I had fixed for her departure, nor
how she since absconded her self; how
she was taken again, and convicted of seve∣ral
things contrary to what she had signed.
What I cannot conceal is, that she set up
always for a Prophetess; I have in her Wri∣tings
sign'd with her own hand, that God
had put into her disposal the life of such
as oppose themselves to her Visions: She
has made Prelates and Archbishops, far
different from those the Holy Ghost hath
chosen: She has also made such Predicti∣ons
as would strike horror into those that
hear them. You have already seen what
she had foretold as to the Protection of
her Silent Prayer by the King himself: She
has since given out, that after what she calls
Persecution, her Prayers would spring up
again under a Child: The Prophecy has
been taken notice of to the August Infant,
without making any Impression upon his
Mind. God forbid I should accuse M. de
Cambray, nor the wise Heads that are a∣bout
that lovely Prince, of the Discourses
that have been made to him concerning
it; but there are amongst all Parties, Peo∣ple
of outragious tempers, who speak with∣out
measure or aim, and that sort of People
spread Reports abroad, that the times will
change, and thus they frighten the simple.
descriptionPage 49
You see then plainly, the Reasons I have
to write those Circumstances: You see
in whose presence it is I write them,
and why, at last, I make a Woma nknown,
who is at present a cause of Divisions in
the Church.
14. M. de Cambray, during the time of
our examination, spoke of her in different
manners; he has often frighten'd us, when
he said to two or three of us together,
that he had learnt more from her than
from all the Doctors together; and at o∣ther
times he comforted us, saying, he
was so far from approving her Books, that
he was rather ready to condemn them, if
it were thought necessary in the least; I
doubted no more of his Conversion upon
this point than upon the rest; and seek∣ing
nothing else but to convince throughly
of his Errors a Man of parts, by a me∣thod
so much the more sincere as it was
meek, and without compulsion: I wished
he might come, of his own accord, to
himself again, as it were from a short fit
of giddiness; and we thought fit to defer
the proposing to him the express con∣demnation
of the Books of that Woman,
'till such time as he could do it without
reluctancy. Thus you have an Account of
those unmerciful Men, and of those Per∣sons
that envied the glory of M. de Cam∣bray;
descriptionPage 50
those that had a mind to ruin him;
that have carried their severity so far, as
it's impossible the relation of it can find Be∣lief
amongst Men. Let the time at least
be instanc'd when that madness seiz'd us.
They might well have found fault that we
spared him too much, shew'd him too much
meekness, and were guilty of too much
compliance: Let it be so, and I will
own it; and, to speak only of my self,
that I carried my Confidence, the love
of Peace, and that benign Charity which
suspects no evil, too far; hitherto it re∣mains
at least an uncontroverted Truth,
That the Archbishop of Cambray disuni∣ted
himself from his Brethren, to maintain
Madam Guyon against them.
email
Do you have questions about this content? Need to report a problem?
Please contact us.