John Stuart Mill on Political Economy [pp. 52-56]

Debow's review, Agricultural, commercial, industrial progress and resources. / Volume 3, Issue 1

MILL ON POLITICAL ECONOMY. their conduct by an infinite variety of motives, feelings, passions, affections, sympathies, likings, hatreds, prejudices, prepossessions, local and national antipathies, patriotism, pugnacity, chivalry, pride of caste. of family and race, etc., and a thousand other feelings, too subtle for detection and exposition, and too numerous for citation. The man who always acts upon the conviction that man is purely and entirely a selfish animal, is already a fool, and in a fair way to become a knave. ART. VI.-JOIIN STUART MILL ON POLITICAL ECONOMIY. DON'T be frightened, dear reader, for we assure you that you know just as much about political economy as Mr. Mill, or Adam Smith, or Say, or Ricardo, or ourselves, or any one else, who ever wrote upon the subject. The science is neither abstruse, nor dry and uninteresting. Every one practises it, we are sorry to say, every day of his life; and every business man and woman understands its practical applications far better than any of its teachers. The best political economists we ever met with, were horse jockeys and negro market-women. They are ever ready to quote and practice on its extremest maxims. Such as: "All's fair in trade." "The worth of a thing is just what it will bring." "Every man for himself, and the devil take the hindermost." etc., etc. Concealed in Latin verbiage, and intended for ears polite, the lawyers have a like leading maxim: "Caveat emptor!' They, too, quite unconsciously, are admirable political economists. But there is a shorter way of getting at this pretended science or philosophy than any of these. It is fully comprehended and thoroughly defined, so far as it is susceptible of comprehension or definition, in two French, or two co-relative English words. Our lamented deceased friend, the late George Frederick Coleman, of Virginia, the best classical scholar, the most fascinating and instructive companion, and in all respects, one of the most intellectual men we ever knew, said to us one day: "Fitzhugh, I have not paid enough attention to moral science, I want to study political economy. -low shall I go about it?" "You understand French, Coleman. Now I will teach you in two words all that can be learned or taught on the subject. 'Laissez-faire.' That's all that's in this boasted science, but real quackery, panacea, or charl(atanry. You keep repeating'Lais sez-faire,' or'let alone!' or'unrestricted liberty.' They all mean the same. So does "let every one do pretty much as he pleases." Be bold and fearless in thought. Don't revolt at the conclusions to which you will inevitably be led. No law, no gov er.-ment, anarchy, free love, etc., etc., are unavoidable conclusions 52


MILL ON POLITICAL ECONOMY. their conduct by an infinite variety of motives, feelings, passions, affections, sympathies, likings, hatreds, prejudices, prepossessions, local and national antipathies, patriotism, pugnacity, chivalry, pride of caste. of family and race, etc., and a thousand other feelings, too subtle for detection and exposition, and too numerous for citation. The man who always acts upon the conviction that man is purely and entirely a selfish animal, is already a fool, and in a fair way to become a knave. ART. VI.-JOIIN STUART MILL ON POLITICAL ECONOMIY. DON'T be frightened, dear reader, for we assure you that you know just as much about political economy as Mr. Mill, or Adam Smith, or Say, or Ricardo, or ourselves, or any one else, who ever wrote upon the subject. The science is neither abstruse, nor dry and uninteresting. Every one practises it, we are sorry to say, every day of his life; and every business man and woman understands its practical applications far better than any of its teachers. The best political economists we ever met with, were horse jockeys and negro market-women. They are ever ready to quote and practice on its extremest maxims. Such as: "All's fair in trade." "The worth of a thing is just what it will bring." "Every man for himself, and the devil take the hindermost." etc., etc. Concealed in Latin verbiage, and intended for ears polite, the lawyers have a like leading maxim: "Caveat emptor!' They, too, quite unconsciously, are admirable political economists. But there is a shorter way of getting at this pretended science or philosophy than any of these. It is fully comprehended and thoroughly defined, so far as it is susceptible of comprehension or definition, in two French, or two co-relative English words. Our lamented deceased friend, the late George Frederick Coleman, of Virginia, the best classical scholar, the most fascinating and instructive companion, and in all respects, one of the most intellectual men we ever knew, said to us one day: "Fitzhugh, I have not paid enough attention to moral science, I want to study political economy. -low shall I go about it?" "You understand French, Coleman. Now I will teach you in two words all that can be learned or taught on the subject. 'Laissez-faire.' That's all that's in this boasted science, but real quackery, panacea, or charl(atanry. You keep repeating'Lais sez-faire,' or'let alone!' or'unrestricted liberty.' They all mean the same. So does "let every one do pretty much as he pleases." Be bold and fearless in thought. Don't revolt at the conclusions to which you will inevitably be led. No law, no gov er.-ment, anarchy, free love, etc., etc., are unavoidable conclusions 52

/ 116
Pages Index

Actions

file_download Download Options Download this page PDF - Pages 47-56 Image - Page 52 Plain Text - Page 52

About this Item

Title
John Stuart Mill on Political Economy [pp. 52-56]
Author
Fitzhugh, Geo.
Canvas
Page 52
Serial
Debow's review, Agricultural, commercial, industrial progress and resources. / Volume 3, Issue 1

Technical Details

Link to this Item
https://name.umdl.umich.edu/acg1336.2-03.001
Link to this scan
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/m/moajrnl/acg1336.2-03.001/56:9

Rights and Permissions

The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials are in the public domain in the United States. If you have questions about the collection, please contact Digital Content & Collections at [email protected]. If you have concerns about the inclusion of an item in this collection, please contact Library Information Technology at [email protected].

DPLA Rights Statement: No Copyright - United States

Manifest
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/t/text/api/manifest/moajrnl:acg1336.2-03.001

Cite this Item

Full citation
"John Stuart Mill on Political Economy [pp. 52-56]." In the digital collection Making of America Journal Articles. https://name.umdl.umich.edu/acg1336.2-03.001. University of Michigan Library Digital Collections. Accessed May 9, 2025.
Do you have questions about this content? Need to report a problem? Please contact us.