Superiority of Southern Races [pp. 369-381]

Debow's review, Agricultural, commercial, industrial progress and resources. / Volume 31, Issues 4-5

SUPERIORITY OF SOUTHERN RACES. they are the drones of the race for whose laziness the wilderness was a refuge, or for whose crimes it was an asylum. They fled to it because they could enjoy the unrestrained idleness they loved. Of course they formed a class, as pauperism does everywhere, and the forests did the rest. The same is true of the unsettled districts of the North. The Adirondack, the Jersey pines, and the verge of the Western territories are full of these people, and they are only a little more respectable because the climate is more inclement. The shadows of endless forests cow down man's ambition by theirvery vastness, and nothing but imminent starvation will excite his energies. ART. IV. SUPERIORITY OF SOUTHERN RACES-REVIEW OF COUNT DE GOBINEAU'S WORK. The science of ethnology has of late years become a favorite subject of investigation among the learned and the curious, and no doubt, will always hereafter be pursued with avidity by a large class of readers. No study is more innocent, none more interesting, and few more useful when it is not pushed to extremes.' Oui author does not push it to extremes. lIe assumes the Bible account of the origin of man to be true, but says that from the earliest dawn of history we find various races, divisions and varieties of the human family, differing from each other more or less widely, and that these differences can never be effaced except by intermarriage; and that then a new variety is produced; which, like its predecessors, can only be changed by the infusion of foreign blood forom some other race or variety. lie holds that not only is the Caucasian race superior to all other races, and must ever continue so despite of circunmstance and education, but that there are very many families or varieties in that race of different grade of capacity, different characteristics, and different talents, turn or genius; and that these differences are just as ineradicable as the widler ones between the races. We have always concurred in these propositions, the truth of which, we think, will be equally obvious to the learned historian, the curious antiquary, and the successful breeder of colts and cattle. lie (does not attempt to account for these varieties or different breeds of men, and to make them concur with the scriptural history of a comnimon parentage; nor do we see any reason why he should do so. God, who made man, could certainly change or modify his nature; or, it may be, that all created things were more plastic and adaptable in the beginning than now. The great merit of the work is, that it treats of existing phenomena, or of such as have existed within the historic period, and does not attempt to account for their origin. Philosophy is always foolishly and 369 AO


SUPERIORITY OF SOUTHERN RACES. they are the drones of the race for whose laziness the wilderness was a refuge, or for whose crimes it was an asylum. They fled to it because they could enjoy the unrestrained idleness they loved. Of course they formed a class, as pauperism does everywhere, and the forests did the rest. The same is true of the unsettled districts of the North. The Adirondack, the Jersey pines, and the verge of the Western territories are full of these people, and they are only a little more respectable because the climate is more inclement. The shadows of endless forests cow down man's ambition by theirvery vastness, and nothing but imminent starvation will excite his energies. ART. IV. SUPERIORITY OF SOUTHERN RACES-REVIEW OF COUNT DE GOBINEAU'S WORK. The science of ethnology has of late years become a favorite subject of investigation among the learned and the curious, and no doubt, will always hereafter be pursued with avidity by a large class of readers. No study is more innocent, none more interesting, and few more useful when it is not pushed to extremes.' Oui author does not push it to extremes. lIe assumes the Bible account of the origin of man to be true, but says that from the earliest dawn of history we find various races, divisions and varieties of the human family, differing from each other more or less widely, and that these differences can never be effaced except by intermarriage; and that then a new variety is produced; which, like its predecessors, can only be changed by the infusion of foreign blood forom some other race or variety. lie holds that not only is the Caucasian race superior to all other races, and must ever continue so despite of circunmstance and education, but that there are very many families or varieties in that race of different grade of capacity, different characteristics, and different talents, turn or genius; and that these differences are just as ineradicable as the widler ones between the races. We have always concurred in these propositions, the truth of which, we think, will be equally obvious to the learned historian, the curious antiquary, and the successful breeder of colts and cattle. lie (does not attempt to account for these varieties or different breeds of men, and to make them concur with the scriptural history of a comnimon parentage; nor do we see any reason why he should do so. God, who made man, could certainly change or modify his nature; or, it may be, that all created things were more plastic and adaptable in the beginning than now. The great merit of the work is, that it treats of existing phenomena, or of such as have existed within the historic period, and does not attempt to account for their origin. Philosophy is always foolishly and 369 AO

/ 248
Pages Index

Actions

file_download Download Options Download this page PDF - Pages 363-372 Image - Page 369 Plain Text - Page 369

About this Item

Title
Superiority of Southern Races [pp. 369-381]
Author
Fitzhugh, Geo.
Canvas
Page 369
Serial
Debow's review, Agricultural, commercial, industrial progress and resources. / Volume 31, Issues 4-5

Technical Details

Link to this Item
https://name.umdl.umich.edu/acg1336.1-31.005
Link to this scan
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/m/moajrnl/acg1336.1-31.005/273:4

Rights and Permissions

The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials are in the public domain in the United States. If you have questions about the collection, please contact Digital Content & Collections at [email protected]. If you have concerns about the inclusion of an item in this collection, please contact Library Information Technology at [email protected].

DPLA Rights Statement: No Copyright - United States

Manifest
https://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/t/text/api/manifest/moajrnl:acg1336.1-31.005

Cite this Item

Full citation
"Superiority of Southern Races [pp. 369-381]." In the digital collection Making of America Journal Articles. https://name.umdl.umich.edu/acg1336.1-31.005. University of Michigan Library Digital Collections. Accessed May 10, 2025.
Do you have questions about this content? Need to report a problem? Please contact us.